User reviews

At a time when streaming platforms are inundated with content that often feels formulaic, it's rare to encounter a series that grips you with such immediacy and authenticity. This miniseries, which I stumbled upon purely by chance on its premiere day, turned out to be a remarkable discovery-an unassuming masterpiece that exceeded my expectations in every way.

What sets this series apart is its unflinchingly unsentimental approach to storytelling. By eschewing overly contrived emotional cues, it allows moments of genuine emotional depth to emerge organically, packing an understated yet profound impact. It's a raw, fast-paced, and intense experience that remains grounded and purposeful, never slipping into excess or artifice.

Visually, the series is a triumph. The meticulous attention to detail-whether in the period-accurate costumes, evocative set designs, or the dynamic and immersive camerawork-creates an unparalleled sense of presence. You're not merely observing events unfold from a distance; you're drawn into the action, experiencing the urgency and stakes alongside the characters.

While I often find action-heavy narratives reliant on spectacle at the expense of substance, this series defies that trend. Here, the brisk pacing and raw, visceral moments of violence serve as an extension of the story's thematic core, amplifying its authenticity rather than detracting from it.

From the first episode, the series establishes a gripping rhythm that's impossible to resist.

If this miniseries isn't recognized during awards season, it would be nothing short of an oversight. The precision of its costume design, the evocative score, the sharp direction, and the captivating performance by its lead actress deserve every accolade.

In many ways, this is more than just one of the best Netflix offerings in recent memory; it's a reminder of what storytelling can achieve when ambition meets artistry. For an industry that often prioritizes marketability over originality THIS is why I still am a subscriber.

I loved American Primeval even more than I thought I would. It's a brutal and gritty take on how the American West was started. First of all I love this genre, second I love Peter Berg (Lone Survivor, Friday Night Lights, The Kingdom, Patriots Day, Hancock, etc) and lastly it has an amazing cast starring Taylor Kitsch, Betty Gilpin, Jai Courtney, Dane DeHaan, Shea Whigham, etc. On top of all that it was also beautifully shot, the cinematography was amazing. This is a hard watch but a great one. My brother and I binged all 6 episodes in one day, that's how good this show was. If you're a fan of Westerns (and even if you're not) the give this series a chance...you won't be disappointed.

American Primeval is one of the better shows I've seen in the last year and I've seen some terrific shows so that's saying something. This miniseries shows how shockingly cruel and violent the West really was. I have to warn you that there are some really violent and gory scenes so if that bothers you then this show might not be for you. It has several different plots to follow but all of them are captivating. It doesn't shy away from how ugly and savage people were for their desire to get land. I know the year just started but this is still going to end up being on most peoples best of the year list. I was entertained from the very first episode to the last and can't recommend this show enough.

⭐ 10/10

"American Primeval" exceeded every expectation I had and delivered a raw, powerful portrayal of the brutal and unforgiving beginnings of the American West. From the first episode, the series hooks you with its unflinching realism, emotional depth, and incredible storytelling.

First, let's talk about the creative force behind it. Peter Berg, a master of gritty, character-driven narratives (Lone Survivor, Friday Night Lights, Kingdom), proves once again why he's one of the best in the business. His ability to combine breathtaking action with intimate, emotional moments is on full display here. The cinematography is nothing short of stunning, capturing the beauty and the savagery of the untamed frontier in equal measure.

The cast is another standout. Taylor Kitsch gives one of the best performances of his career, fully embodying the complex and tormented spirit of his character. Betty Gilpin, Jai Courtney, Dane DeHaan, and Shea Whigham round out an incredible ensemble that brings authenticity and raw emotion to every scene. Each character feels deeply human, shaped by the brutal world they inhabit.

This isn't your typical Western. It's brutal, uncompromising, and filled with tension. The writing is sharp, exploring themes of survival, morality, and the costs of progress without feeling preachy. Every episode had me on the edge of my seat, and by the time the credits rolled on the final episode, I found myself in awe of what I'd just witnessed.

It's a hard watch at times, but that's what makes it so effective. If you're looking for a Western that doesn't romanticize the past but instead dives headfirst into its harsh realities, "American Primeval" is a must-watch. Even if you're not a fan of the genre, this series is so well-crafted that it transcends its Western roots.

Netflix truly knocked it out of the park with this limited series. I binged all six episodes in one sitting and was left speechless. Don't sleep on this show-it's a masterpiece.

Similar vibe to The English (2022). Very well made. Great to have a quality production that's a Netflix original series amongst the mass of mediocre content they pour out so generously. It's violent but that period would have been I imagine, therefore, there's rape, hangings, children killed etc so if that bothers you, then I'd avoid. The tone is immediately bleak as is the prospect of any character being killed at any second. Judging by the lengths people go to with such effort just to stay alive another day, it's a wonder whether they'll have enough cast to fill the six episodes. Needless to say, I like it. 4.5 stars.

I'm on the third episode and thus far it's excellent. Felt I had to leave a review as I'm 3 episodes in and loving it. 100% does not deserve so many low reviews. If I went by reviews I would never watch anything. IGNORE REVIEWS, PEOPLE LIKE A WINGE, DEFO WORTH A WATCH. Atmospheric, gritty and right up my street. Cheers If the premise is appealing to you, do not be dissuaded from giving the show a chance. It's certainly violent but I do believe it's an accurate portrayal of what the time would have been for many. Great characters, beautiful cinema photography, with a complex, yet unconvoluted story.

Although I am not a huge american western fan, I binge-watched this series over two evenings and enjoyed every minute. It is refreshing to watch a series that does not require much introduction and engages straight away.

The plot is easy to follow and did not involve interminable switches to other characters at key moments or flip back and forth in time.

The acting overall is good and consistent throughout the series and there is good character development.

I looked forward to every episode and was reduced to tears at the end of the series.

I was left looking forwar to season 2 (which I hope will be coming soon).

Highly recommend this series to folk who don't mind a bit of violence in their viewing and want an evening of action and adventure.

American Primeval (2025), created by Mark L. Smith, is a gritty and adventurous exploration of the birth of the American West. The series immerses viewers in the violent and tumultuous clashes between cults, religion, and the men and women fighting for control of the new world. While the show excels at capturing the harshness and brutality of the time, it falls short in developing its characters and offering a more nuanced portrayal of the story's complexities.

The series is commendable for its authenticity in depicting the harsh realities of life in the American frontier. The landscapes, settings, and historical accuracy are all meticulously crafted, creating an immersive world where survival is a daily struggle. The violence is raw and unrelenting, giving the show an intense and visceral feel. The struggle for control, the clash of ideologies, and the brutality of the environment are well-drawn, making the series engaging for those who appreciate a no-holds-barred depiction of history.

However, while the world-building is impressive, the show suffers from a lack of depth in its characters. The focus on presenting the harsh realities of the time seems to have come at the expense of fleshing out the individuals involved in these conflicts. The characters often feel one-dimensional, their motivations unclear or underdeveloped, which weakens the emotional impact of their journeys. The lack of personal stakes and connections makes it difficult to truly invest in their fates.

The storytelling, while ambitious, leaves several gaps in the narrative. There are moments where the pacing feels uneven, and the plot can sometimes feel like it's stumbling through a series of disconnected events without fully exploring the consequences or emotional weight behind them. The lack of a cohesive emotional arc for the characters results in a series that, while visually striking, doesn't quite land in terms of its narrative depth.

Despite these flaws, American Primeval has its merits. The world it presents is rich in detail, and the performances from the cast-especially Taylor Kitsch, Betty Gilpin, and Dane DeHaan-are solid, even if the material doesn't fully give them the opportunity to shine. It's a show that offers a raw, unflinching look at a pivotal time in American history but falters in connecting viewers to the people at the center of it.

Rating: 7/10. A gripping portrayal of the American West's brutal realities, but the lack of character development and narrative depth keeps it from reaching its full potential.

American Primeval is a fantastic show. I am absolutely enjoying the incredibly realistic portrayal of these historical people, events and places.

I am stunned at the constant dust and debris in the air...the continuous wind. The sagebrush, the mud ... the actors look so uncomfortable. Their fatigue and emotions are palpable.

American Primeval is full immersion into this time and place.... just an amazing show that is so well done.

I grew up near the Mountain Meadow Massacre site. I have been there many times and I have friends that are descendents of some of the Mormons involved.

I am well familiar with the MMM story from both Mormon and non-mormon sources and I can tell you that the depiction of the MMM in episode 1 is not very accurate.

The true story of the Mountain Meadow Massacre is far worse.

What an incredibly shot scene this was though and what is very accurate is the portrayal of the different groups involved in the region at the time.

This series was awesome. Raw, violent and good character development. It's how the West was developed and involves many parties; Indians included.

I have a newborn at home and was up 1am till now and watched the entire series. Very well done. I assume it's a limited series and don't have additional seasons which is said.

The ensemble cast is ridiculous and awesome. Some big names only are in one episode but make the series what it is.

Costners American Boring Saga was painfully slow and I still am scratching my head trying to figure a plot if there is one.

This series gets you right into a plot of families expanding west and the trials and tribulations they experienced getting West.

Very appropriate name for series - epsisoeds 47 mins long and move fast. I am a huge fan.

I've always enjoyed what used to be called Westerns and based on viewing one episode, this one is going to be right up there. The violence although in your face/graphic , is not overdone imo and does fit with the storyline.

I find it fascinating to see what America was like a relatively short time ago and im also looking forward to seeing some amazing shots of the Western scenery.

Just a word - as a Brit ( I know please don't mock the afflicted 😉) I struggled to understand what they were saying at times. I'm going to re watch the episode and maybe turn the subtitles on.

Just wondering if some of you Yankies had the same problem?

This movie is a real power house treat for the action western genre & lovers alike. Gilpin was amazing in HUNTED she just has this natural persona that what ever she is in you just cant keep your eyes off screen. This was such a mega mega suprise start to finish it just got better & better. A forrest gump of the western genre. Well written well scripted good production value. And above super well acted from main lead to supporting cast. Kevin kostners horizon should have this good if not better. This movie even has a beautiful love angle which was well executed. The action and violence is gory and well made. I personallly cant praise this movie enough loved every minute of it. And truly hope they make another season would love to see how california panned out ....

I watched this over the course of a snow bound day and was glad to see a western story that was very different from the "popular" western series of the past years. Netflix released this as a complete limited series, which is such a relief after suffering through a bunch of series done in the old Big 3 network style of an episode a week.

We all know the network that released those recent series, and I do wish they would wake up to the fact that streaming did away with most of the viewers willing to put up with that game. Also, the recent western series are all done by the same guy using the same set of supporting actors, for the most part. That guy's work has worn out its welcome for me.

Anyway, this fine western has no episode filler, no interminable intro, and not too much anachronistic wokeness in the story line. The anachronisms in the weaponry and costumes isn't too much to bear and doesn't become a deal-breaker.

This story breaks the mold of western series, in several ways. It's storytelling that gets right to the point without all the padding that an ongoing TV series always has. We know right away when a character is a villain, without a multi-episode side story.

Western fans could well end up making this a very widely watched miniseries. I doubt that its success would convince the current makers of the old pattern of dragged out series, but that old model is dying off anyway.

I do hope that Netflix updates the IMDB pages for this show to give cast credits to some good actors who aren't listed, such as Irene Bedard and Jeremiah Bitsui. The cast is excellent, IMO.

This Netflix collaboration with Peter Berg hits the centre of the bullseye. It's barbaric, brutal, breathtaking and brilliant. A well seasoned and experienced cast are simply characters perched on a wild west rollercoaster with all the trimmings.

The story of a mother travelling west with her young son across the untamed west in the 1860's. There's the good, the bad and the downright ugly to navigate in her quest to be united with her husband.

There's plenty of native tribes and mountain men to contend with. The Mormon Militia, US Army and bounty hunters all add to this must be watched 6 part series. 10/10.

I'm not sure what the count is but there must be over 10,000 western films/tv shows at this point, so it has all been done. American Primeval doesn't try to reinvent the wheel here, what they do is take all the best parts and mash them into one epic collision.

There are some good performances here particularly from Taylor Kitsch, Betty Gilpin, Derek Hinkey & Kim Coates amongst others.

There are some brutal moments and moments of pure joy. Be prepared to go through every emotion here, I raged, I laughed and I cried.

Great writing but it is going to be hard to top if there is a second season.

If the series had been able to maintain the level of the first four episodes, we would be talking about a rating in the region of Deadwood. The world is cruel and brutal, with scenes often portrayed through a cold blue filter, creating an oppressive atmosphere at the beginning. Despite this, the series provides moments of emotional respite, allowing the viewer to catch their breath before the next wave of hardship.

The core story between the two main protagonists is simple and familiar: a man who shuns society and has lost everything crosses paths with a city girl accompanied by her son and a hidden secret. If this premise sounds familiar, it's because it is, and it quickly becomes evident how the series will unfold. Herein lies the show's greatest weakness: the characters and their development are flat and predictable. The narrative stumbles from one film cliché to the next, culminating in a disappointing six episodes.

The pacing of the series also leaves much to be desired. While the initial episodes build tension effectively, later ones feel rushed, leaving little room for meaningful character exploration. As a result, emotional moments that should carry weight instead feel hollow and unearned. The potential for deeper thematic exploration is squandered in favor of overused tropes and melodramatic twists.

Visually, the series excels in creating an immersive and atmospheric setting. The cinematography, combined with a haunting score, manages to elevate certain moments beyond the limitations of the script. However, strong aesthetics alone cannot compensate for the lack of originality and depth in storytelling.

I had hoped the series would avoid devolving into a brutalized soap opera, but unfortunately, it does. Despite its promising start, it ultimately succumbs to tired storytelling choices and underdeveloped characters. As a result, I can only give it a 6 out of 10.

Captivating show although the story line is not too deep, but yet riveting and explanatory enough as clues are revealed throughout the mini-series. Bloody, action packed, beautiful terrain, and reminiscent of "the revenant" and "hostiles".

Great cast overall with Taylor Kistch who is perfect for his character, not too much time is spent diving into his backstory, but he is made for the mysterious and dangerous vibe.

The gloomy environment is in line with the times, 1800s wasn't exactly the "happiest" of times in America. It is interesting how it paints a different perspective of some of the sacrifices folks from different cultures and views had to make in order to coexist.

This show tries to present itself as gritty and realistic but relies on shock content - sudden violence, grotesque imagery, and chaos - to mask a lack of meaningful storytelling.

The bleak, gray aesthetic feels more like an affectation than a thoughtful creative choice, and the narrative lacks depth or cohesion.

The reliance on gratuitous violence and shocking moments comes across as a shortcut to engagement, highlighting the absence of real creative craftsmanship.

Instead of immersing the viewer in a compelling story, the series opts for superficial tricks that ultimately leave little lasting impact.

So far I see negative reviews that are completely unwarranted. This Limited Series wants to tell a story and it achieves that in 6 parts, it plays like a 6 hr. Film. Does it beat The Revenant? No, it doesn't but it's a fine rendition of beautiful cinematic shots to intense one-shot takes. The main cast pulls out some outstanding performances. Taylor Kitsch (underrated) pulls that perfect cold blooded mountain man performance and doesn't disappoint. The story isn't some overly complex telling it's straight and to the point, which isn't a bad thing to have in a limited series. This is a must watch for any western/frontier film lover.

Please don't complain about the violence, it's plainly presented as a gritty and lawless time in our history. Peter Berg is an excellent director and went to great pains to make this film look as close to the reality of the time as he could with great success. The main characters are compelling, real in some cases sympathetic. The story is well written with edge of your seats, confrontations and nonstop action. I've seen the first two episodes and I can't wait to keep watching to see what happens. It's a great production. And probably historically correct and some of my favorite actors are sprinkled into the cast, even though they're hard to recognize under all the dirt that's on their faces.

If the person who gave the show one star doesn't like the violence, let them go back and watch reruns of the show Centennial from the 70s so she can see a more whitewashed version of the period.