Jamie Holbrook (43 episodes, 2014-2020)
Ryan Holbrook (35 episodes, 2014-2020)
Colin / Colin Murphy (32 episodes, 2014-2020)
Callie / California Beatrice / Callie Beatrice (26 episodes, 2014-2020)
J.P. Cutler / JP Cutler (15 episodes, 2014-2020)
News Anchor (12 episodes, 2014-2020)
Randy Holbrook (12 episodes, 2020)
James Taylor Bennett / Man (12 episodes, 2020)
Detective Epps / Detective Evelyn Epps (12 episodes, 2020)
Detective Allen (10 episodes, 2020)
Jenny Dakota (10 episodes, 2020)
Skye / Noho Park / Sapphire Skye (10 episodes, 2020)
Joy / Joy Bennett / Joyful Spirit Bennitt (10 episodes, 2020)
Smiley (9 episodes, 2020)
Emma Skye (9 episodes, 2020)
Jay (9 episodes, 2020)
Hal (9 episodes, 2020)
Robert Skye (9 episodes, 2020)
Young Callie (8 episodes, 2020)
Tamborine Cultist 1 (8 episodes, 2020)
Lanky Cultist (8 episodes, 2020)
Waitress (8 episodes, 2020)
Tamborine Cultist 2 (8 episodes, 2020)
Potato Peeling Cultist 2 (8 episodes, 2020)
Young Sapphire Skye (8 episodes, 2020)
Potato Peeling Cultist 1 / Marty Smith (8 episodes, 2020)
Detective Hanson (6 episodes, 2020)
Deputy Shaw (5 episodes, 2020)
Young Jamie (5 episodes, 2020)
Detective Williams (4 episodes, 2020)
Ellie (4 episodes, 2020)
Bellflower Beverly Wilson / Beverly Wilson (4 episodes, 2020)
Kareem (4 episodes, 2020)
Markus (3 episodes, 2020)
Deputy Schatanoff (3 episodes, 2020)
Nicki / Waitress (3 episodes, 2020)
Captain Mateja / Captain Meteja (3 episodes, 2020)
Police Sergeant / Sherrif Burke (2 episodes, 2015-2020)
Jane (2 episodes, 2020)
Millie (2 episodes, 2020)
Lucy / Lucy the Coroner (2 episodes, 2020)
Ava (2 episodes, 2020)
Mr. Wilson (2 episodes, 2020)
Sleeping Woman / Woman (2 episodes, 2020)
Tow Truck Guy (2 episodes, 2020)
Ali (2 episodes, 2020)
Park Bum (2 episodes, 2020)
Toluca Village (2 episodes, 2020)
Deputy Smoak (2 episodes, 2020)
Lex (2 episodes, 2020)
Betsy Palmer (2 episodes, 2020)
Sleeping Man (2 episodes, 2020)
Jerry (2 episodes, 2020)
Billy (1 episode, 2014)
(1 episode, 2020)
Bar Back (1 episode, 2020)
Bartender (1 episode, 2020)
David (1 episode, 2020)
Violet (1 episode, 2020)
Crime Scene Investigator (1 episode, 2020)
Police Officer One (1 episode, 2020)
Reggie's Burgers (1 episode, 2020)
Detective Flannagan (1 episode, 2020)
Carol (1 episode, 2020)
Rick (1 episode, 2020)
Olancha Local (1 episode, 2020)
Medic (1 episode, 2020)
Police Officer Three (1 episode, 2020)
Dollar Theater (1 episode, 2020)
John (1 episode, 2020)
Jason (1 episode, 2020)
Police Officer Two (1 episode, 2020)
Paramedic (1 episode, 2020)
Self (uncredited) (2 episodes, 2014-2020)