User reviews

I never watched many medical shows until I retired. Didn't want to bring the hospital home with me. Shows like House may have had good actors but were unrealistic fantasies when it came to real medicine. After retiring I watched all 15 seasons of ER over a few months. That show captured the reality of ER medicine as well as hospital politics, although it compressed time. Things happen fast, but not that fast or intense over an entire day, and not nearly as many open chest heart massages occur. But you really did get to see what it was like. Now The Pitt brings the same flavor of show as ER was. So if you enjoyed watching ER, you will like this.

I'm a board certified EM physician who has worked in big trauma centers and small but busy community ER's. Most medical shows are hyper unrealistic, which normally leads to absurd requests from patients. I'm only one episode in, but this is the first show (besides scrubs) that paints an accurate picture of what it's like to work in emergency medicine. Bravo to the consultants they got for this one; clearly they consulted an emergency medicine physician or three. I look forward to watching the rest of the series. Future medical series should follow in The Pitt's footsteps and actually consult a real physician if you want it to be accurate.

The Pitt is easily the best hospital series I've ever seen. It's been praised up and down by just about everyone and for good reason. It currently has a 97% on Rotten Tomatoes. This show will have you in your feelings so much by the time you finish even one episode you'll be as exhausted as the employees of The Pitt. I didn't think the every episode is an hour (like 24) would work for a medical show but I was wrong. It not only works but is a big reason why this series is so good. The pacing of each episode makes them fly by. No show or movie you've ever seen will prepare you for the experience of watching The Pitt. With how many medical series that have been made it's amazing that the genre was able to come out with such an original show as The Pitt.

There are a million doctor/hospital shows out there so you really need to be special to stick out and The Pitt absolutely does that. It's not hyperbole when I say it's by far the most realistic hospital show that's ever been made. I'll be shocked if this show doesn't get nominated for a bunch of awards, especially Noah Wyle in the lead role. I've always like Wyle but this is career defining performance. He's fantastic in every scene. I'm a binged, I love to binge watch shows, so much so that even for the shows that come out weekly I wait until the entire season is over before I start it so I can binge it. This is the first show I've ever seen that I can only watch a few episodes at a time because of how intense each mood each episode is. I'll still watch a few episodes each day and binge the entire season within 5 or 6 days but it's a work out doing it. I'm so glad that people have enjoyed it so much that it's already been renewed for another season.

A rare occasion when all of the elements come together and engage the viewer completely. The pacing is fast but with the right rhythm. The writers have done their research, and the little I know about emergency procedures feels convincing. They must have some great medical consultants supervising. But the personal stories, complex interactions, and character development are where it shines. And it's not always the highest profile actors carrying it - Noah Wyle is polished for sure, but all of the young residents are individuals whose uniqueness, sensitivity, strengths and weaknesses, will have you holding your breath and sighing in relief when they save a patient. This is seriously a top tier series. I never anticipate a new episode of a show dropping, but I do for The Pitt. I wonder if season two will be able to match it.

Absolutely amazing! Only 2 episodes in and I can't stand the week long wait to find out what happens next. Innovative, captivating, charming, exciting, & very intriguing. I'll update when episode 15 comes in for a landing, but so far I can say that I have not enjoyed medical series or any series this much in a long time. Noah Wyle didn't miss a beat. Dr Carter was fantastic, but Dr. Michael "Robby" Robinavitch is next level. All of the limitations of network television be damned. This show has heart. This show has guts. This show has brains. This show has balls! The surrounding and supporting cast share chemistry like television hasn't seen in years. Keep it up guys. I am eagerly awaiting episode 3.

I work in healthcare and this show is an accurate depiction of what takes place in a very busy urban Emergency Department. The scenes of intubation, codes, and family grief are real and something that happens on a daily basis if not hourly. People complaining about camera angles need to realize that healthcare workers that are part of the "action" often feel disjointed and out of control we just have a better way of disguising it! This show shows that there are always subplots to the action that is occurring and occasionally that are bright spots! With only 2 episodes so far I say give it a chance you might learn something about healthcare. Noah Wylie is a great person to headline this show.

I'm a physician / psychiatrist, and I am so happy to have a medical show I enjoy!

I spent three months in the trauma bay of a busy inner city ER, as a med student, and many more many more years in the ER for other rotations and for work.

It's refreshing to see the ER portrayed in a realistic way. Also, mental health patients and their issues are handled appropriately and with empathy. I wish they showed psychiatrists and other specialists as they consult in the ER.

I experienced burnout and took time off, this show has been a major factor in me reconsidering returning to work. It has reminded me of the redeeming part of my work and all the wonderful colleagues I had. As medicine becomes increasingly monetized and scrutinized for productivity and bled dry by private equity it helped me remember why I have so much to do this job.

I worked in EMS after training at a large teaching hospital. I rarely watch medical shows because the portrayal of medicine is so dumbed-down and inaccurate. I understand that it's a show and some license will be taken, but at least put in some effort to help me suspend disbelief. The Pitt puts in major effort to get it right (which I expect from creator of 'Southland' John Wells, one of the few cop shows that did it more accurately than most). ER's are places of extreme excitement, sadness and humor (the rat scene alone beat many comedies made today). It's fun to be a couple episodes into a medical show and looking forward to more instead of rolling my eyes and moving on.

Being Hollywood we get the usual moralizing, but most shows lecture while delivering inane dialogue with one dimensional characters. Give me a solid story in a realistic setting with great characters and I can sit through a fair share of finger-wagging. It's great seeing Noah Wylie in a hospital again, especially as a veteran doctor surrounded by fresh-faced medical rookies like he was in ER. The acting has been great from everyone. I recognize so many of these personalities from a career around this environment. The Pitt is a great new show.

I have watched and re-watched every episode. Great show. Huge entertainment value; the show challenges my view of doctors, nurses, and hospitals. It has raised my awareness of the stress and struggles of the job working in an ER. This show humanizes the people, and gives us a much more realistic view of their personal and professional struggles than we have ever seen in a hospital show. So interesting. Great cast and characters I care about. Every character is likable. The pacing, balance, and action in the show is superb. This is among my favorite shows of all time, and I can't wait for season two.

I recently decided to check out The Pitt, even though it's not my usual type of show, and I am completely hooked. I went in with no expectations, thinking I'd maybe watch an episode or two and move on, but from the very first episode, I was captivated. Every single episode has either left my heart racing or completely dropped in shock. The emotional rollercoaster this show puts you on is unlike anything I've experienced in a long time.

One of the things that stands out the most to me is the acting. The performances in this show are nothing short of phenomenal. Every character feels so real, so raw, that I often forget I'm watching a scripted show. The actors bring their characters to life with such authenticity that it feels like I'm watching real people navigate the chaos of the emergency room. Whether it's a high-stakes medical emergency, an ethical dilemma, or the emotional struggles of the staff, every moment is portrayed with a depth that makes it impossible to look away.

Another aspect that I absolutely love is the realism of the ER setting. Many medical dramas try to capture the fast-paced and high-pressure environment of a hospital, but The Pitt does it in a way that feels incredibly authentic. The background, the procedures, the way the doctors and nurses interact-all of it adds to the immersive experience. The show doesn't shy away from the harsh realities of working in emergency medicine, and I appreciate the attention to detail in how they depict both the triumphs and tragedies that come with the job.

What really sets this show apart for me is how it dives into the mental and emotional toll that working in the ER takes on the staff. It's not just about the patients and the medical cases; it's about the people behind the scrubs and how they cope with the weight of their responsibilities. You see them struggle, you see them break, but you also see their resilience. The show does a phenomenal job of exploring the psychological impact of constant high-stress situations, and it makes you appreciate just how much these professionals go through every day.

The storytelling is another reason I'm so hooked. The way the show balances intense, heart-stopping moments with deep, emotional character development is masterful. Every episode leaves me on the edge of my seat, desperate to know what happens next. Just when you think you have a moment to breathe, something shocking happens that changes everything. The pacing is perfect-there's never a dull moment, and every scene feels like it has a purpose.

At this point, I'm impatiently waiting for each new episode to be released. It's the kind of show that sticks with you long after you've finished an episode, making you think about what's coming next and how the characters will deal with their ever-growing challenges. I find myself constantly wanting to talk about it, analyze the characters, and predict what might happen next. It's rare for a show to grip me this hard, especially one outside my usual preferences, but The Pitt has done exactly that.

I can't recommend this show enough. Whether you're into medical dramas or not, The Pitt is worth watching. It's intense, emotional, and deeply compelling, with incredible performances and storytelling that will keep you hooked from the start. If you're looking for a show that will make you feel every emotion possible, this is it. 100% worth watching.

It's been a very long time since I watched a medical series. OK, so I watched House but for me it was never about the medical stuff. It was always about Gregory House. WWHD? One of the best characters ever written for television.

Anyway, prior to House, I think it was E. R. but that was literally a soap opera. 'Nuff said.

The Pitt is different.

The cast is great.

The acting is top notch.

The writing is excellent.

The characters are engaging and relatable.

It's very easy to get sucked into the show.

Some of the medical stuff is maybe a bit much but it's not loads of miraculous crap that you see on other shows. For the most part, The Pitt is realistic.

The final Season 1 episode airs tomorrow. I can't wait to see it but I also don't want to watch it because then the wait is on for Season 2 in January 2026.

It's really a very good show. Check it out and see.

A few episodes into this show I was in! Despite my overall rating of this show being a 6.5/10 by episode 13, I would give the early episodes and most recent episode a solid 9/10. I thought, wow, a show about the ER that subtly focuses on how the HCPs, patients, and cases reflect the world around them without beating us over the head with a certain point of view - all while capturing the chaos of emergency medicine with a high degree of medical accuracy!

Well, the subtle part did not last. I feel like I am a good person to make this point, because not only have I worked in this setting, but also, I agree with many of the social points they're making on a practical level. I just hate when I feel like a show is preaching at me at the expense of narrative & immersion. It's fine for a show to have a point of view, and medical cases are a good vehicle for this, but it starts to feel like instead of exploring interesting characters, this becomes a tertiary focus, and many of the patients and some of the HCPs just become avatars to preach about some social issue. This would still be ok if it was just shown in an interesting way, but the writers have a tendency to preach and write these things unnecessarily into the dialogue, or go too cliche/unrealistic with the scenario.

These don't really become a big issue until the middle/late episodes (before things pop off, but no spoilers here) so it can feel a little bait and switchy.

There's just WAY too much telling over showing with any social issue, too. One example that comes to mind is an obese patient who was misdiagnosed due to assumptions about her metabolic health, because of her obesity. There's nothing wrong with showing this, in fact it's cool to show how complex diagnosing in this environment is, but after we are shown this and can deduce for ourselves what happened and why it was a problem, we get a doc lecturing another about why they're bad for for doing and why you shouldn't judge an obese person by their obesity. Or the trans woman who comes in and gets called by the wrong name from their insurance, and the doctors treat her with respect in the room. A bit unnecessary story wise but that alone made sense and showed us more about who those characters are, which is great. But then we get one of the doctors stopping her on her way out the room talking about I'm sorry your name was misgendered we need to do better etc etc. There's no need for these afterschool movie moments - just let the scenes speak for themselves!

That brings me to my last point. Some of the acting is bad, and some of the characters are quite grating as a result of this plus some thin writing. On its own it's not a big deal, but with the issues I mentioned above, you need skilled actors to pull some of this off. Dr Robby, Dr Heather Collins, Whittaker, Dr Mel King, the head nurse, they're all fantastic. But for every one of those we have a Santos, Mohan, Javadhi, many of the patients, even Langdon at times, who make this feel like a high school play. These are also some of the more obnoxious characters where it's especially important to have charismatic actors playing them. I mean "SloMo" Mohan specifically, you need a certain kind of person with a magnetism to pull off the "I'm more empathetic than you all" and "I know I'm great" schtick without it being grating and obnoxious.

Anyway, this show is still worthy of watching, but I do hope they address some of these issues for S2 if it returns.

The Pitt is one of the most realistic dramas I've ever seen - raw, intense, and unflinchingly honest. It's graphic at times, both emotionally and visually. The performances are top-notch, and the writing is sharp, capturing the chaos and adrenaline of emergency medicine in a way that feels more like virtual reality than TV.

What truly sets The Pitt apart is its handling of the medicine itself. It never talks down to the viewer or over-explains. Instead, it thrusts you right into the action, trusting you to keep up - and that trust pays off. I've never seen a medical show navigate clinical detail with this level of authenticity and urgency.

However, the show's need to check every political and social commentary box weighs it down. While topicality is expected in the genre, The Pitt veers dangerously close to preachy and one-sided, which might hurt its longevity. These moments can feel forced and detract from the otherwise gripping narrative.

Still, this is easily a 9/10 show - maybe even an 11 if it had let the story breathe without constantly hammering its messaging. Watch it for the performances, the realism, and the ride. Just be prepared for a few heavy-handed detours along the way and a near 15-hour roller coaster ride.

This is ER on steroids, I can't believe they did it and brought back my fav tv doc of all time!

I'm ecstatic!

I'm only 1 episode in and this is getting better by the minute, it's the first time I'm so happy that I'm 42 and have had the privilege to watch ER and now we get this gem.

Only thing that could make this better is adding the OG ER into theme.

Noah waily is charming, his character is much less dark that I thought they would make him, there's no non-cringy way of saying this but he's like an older, more mature and evolved Dr. Carter.

I wish I could see the look on his face when he got a call to show up for this role.

"The Pitt" emerges as a compelling and unflinching medical drama, offering a raw and realistic glimpse into the daily chaos and emotional intensity of a Pittsburgh hospital's emergency room. Created by R. Scott Gemmill, the show distinguishes itself with its expert pacing and gripping narratives, making it remarkably easy to get drawn into the lives and challenges faced by the frontline healthcare heroes.

Leading the ensemble cast is Noah Wyle, who delivers a standout performance as Dr. Michael "Robby" Robinavitch. While reminiscent of his iconic role in "ER," Wyle imbues Robby with a seasoned gravitas, portraying a doctor deeply committed to his patients and staff while grappling with his own past trauma from the pandemic. The supporting cast is equally strong, creating a believable and engaging ensemble of doctors, nurses, and students, each with their own personal crises and professional hurdles.

What sets "The Pitt" apart is its commitment to realism. The medical details are portrayed with a level of accuracy rarely seen in television dramas, and the show doesn't shy away from depicting the often-gruesome realities of emergency medicine. The series also delves into the systemic issues plaguing the American healthcare system, including understaffing, dwindling resources, and the emotional toll these factors take on healthcare workers. While occasionally venturing into "teachable moments," these instances are largely integrated organically within the compelling patient-of-the-week storylines.

The show's visual style contributes to its immersive atmosphere. The understated direction and subtle editing maintain a strong momentum, seamlessly transitioning between high-stakes medical procedures and the quieter moments at the nurses' station. The lighting and set design further enhance the realistic feel, creating a bright yet not sterile environment that feels authentically like a busy urban hospital.

"The Pitt" manages to strike a delicate balance between thrilling medical emergencies, heartbreaking patient stories, and moments of dark humor, reflecting the multifaceted nature of life in an emergency room. It's a show that will keep you on the edge of your seat while also fostering a deep empathy for the dedicated individuals who work tirelessly on the front lines of healthcare. If you're looking for a medical drama that is both gripping and grounded in reality, "The Pitt" is undoubtedly one of the best new shows of 2025.

The Pitt is simply amazeballs! I love everything about it. The more mature cast outshines everyone else, as they should. The younger cast play their roles just as they should: inexperienced, very talented, and also too full of themselves, given the circumstances. The writing is spot on, and the amazing newer equipment blows me away. I am not a medical series junkie and never have been until now. I didn't even recognize Noah Wyle at the beginning but am absolutely in love with this gem of a show. Smart, heartfelt, and phenomenal. Kudos to the cast, writers, crew, and producers! Britbox's Casualty is also this good, but previous seasons-MANY-are not available to watch in the U. S.

When I first saw an ad for this, I thought why are we recreating ER with Noah Wyle again? So many shows seem to just be recreations these days. But this is a completely different show. This show is real and raw with excellent acting and storylines. It does get very intense and emotional but appropriately so. This is probably the most realistic hospital show I've seen. We get glimpses in the medical staff's lives without any "soap opera" stories. Even though we are thrown into a day in a busy ER, we get to know the characters quickly due to great writing with surprises scattered throughout the season. I look forward to seeing season 2 of this great new drama. Noah Wyle is excellent!

And I can honestly say I have never seen another show with more realism about what life in the ER is really like. This show captures it all... bravo to the writers, directors and the actors. Well done!!!!

Yes, it is really that chaotic, busy and sad.. from the tight-knit group of doctors and nurses, techs, secretaries, EVS and security. We all band together to take care of sick patients, homeless patients, behavioral medicine patients, dying patients, trauma patients, nursing home patients, not sick patients, you name it we take care of it.

And we have a thing called ER humor, I really appreciate that the show has captured this because without it we'd cry every day. Again, thank you to the writers and the actors for portraying a day in our life.

This is my new favourite show.

I watched ER growing up and loved it. I have tried watching other medical dramas over the years, but none captured me, and I just assumed that maybe I didn't really like medical dramas and that ER was a once-off for me.

Enter: The Pitt. It probably isn't a coincidence that this show comes from a lot of the same team responsible for ER, but it is certainly a real achievement that they have managed to create a compelling medical drama a second time. Not everyone can capture magic twice.

The Pitt is truly exceptional. Not only does it offer a fresh take on medical dramas with the "real time" format (each episode covers an hour of a 15 hour shift), but it somehow feels new and comfortable at the same time.

The show isn't afraid to tackle difficult subjects that medical professionals have to deal with every day. This show is a real reminder of how important it is to respect and appreciate the real humans who work so tirelessly to save lives, and the mental and physical tolls that kind of career can take.

The writing of The Pitt is sharp, the characters are interesting, and the acting is brilliant. Noah Wyle shines once again.

I'm hooked on The Pitt and I've already watched it twice. I cannot wait for season 2 and I would highly recommend this show to every one.

Enough already with everyone asking if everyone else is OK!

Well, this new series has all the vibes of the old 'ER', which frankly is curious because this show could appear on network TV. But, since it's on HBO MAX, why not make it more adult?!

That aside, the supporting cast, other than Noah Wyle (of course) are not of the caliber of the old 'ER', although there are some promising candidates. Noah, however, is on his 'A' game. I am further surprised that Shawn Hatosy is not more prominently featured and billed.

Otherwise, it has all the rhythms and pace of the old 'ER', and I did enjoy it, I just didn't love it. But, I will add it to my weekly viewing schedule.

This was a really well made show. Well acted and written. You can go on and on about all the good things in this show and the characters and their strengths and flaws and how well most were written and acted. It was overall great. Now it's time to ignore the urge to keep it going. It will never be a better show from here. It will only get old and tired and as more ridiculous themes and stories emerge it will crash and burn and just be fodder. I know it won't happen but I only can wish it does. Most really good shows usually hit their peak after the first season but by season 4 they stretched thin . This one hit it in season 1 and won't be better. Live and let Die.

Creator R. Scott Gemmill knows his way around the medical field via the classic series, E. R. Now gloves are off for The Pitt, showing warts and all in this adrenaline pumped hospital series where each episode is an hour of the day shift in an emergency ward. Within two hours (in 2 episodes) there is so much that happens, that it even makes the viewer overanxious! To top it all off, there are flashes to the pandemic chaos in the emergent ward, where even that is enough to trigger anybody with PTSD from that period. An intense series that reveals what the poor staff go through each hour of what seems to be an eternity in damnation. Glad it is a weekly screening, because I sure need that break, and I'm only watching this from the comfort of my armchair...