Beat Bobby Flay (2013– ) User Reviews (58)

You Have To Make Your Own Mother The Star of Your Dish

[DKosty123 · 6/10 · 1 December 2016]

This show is the ultimate ego trip for Bobby Flay. It takes place on his home turf, he only has to win 1 round while any challenger has to win 2 rounds, and the judges from round 1 are not judging the final round. The only challenger advantage is they get to name their "signature" dish for Bobby Flay to make.

Often Flay does seem to win though recently I saw him lose twice. There are always two judges who make things exciting by bothering Flay during the second round as he goes up against their choice chef to challenge him. Some of his major pests show up for more than one show.

I'm going to retire Bobby Flay, but you know this does make cooking fun. Flay gets to name the food the challengers work with in the first round, and some of his choices are pretty outrageous. The humor is what makes this fun. It's like co-workers who like their job jabbing each other, trying to beat the big straw dog, Bobby Flay, in his own dog pound. When he gets beaten, it is just as fun as when he wins.

When Flay wins, they give him a final word. Reminds me of Jerry Springer's routine, though there is little knowledge spoken in either instance.

Just a suggestion

[momzeeto · 7/10 · 11 February 2022]

I think if they beat Bobby they should be able to say i beat Bobby Flay then they ring the bell before running off. Lol. I like the show and think it's funny too.

Sunny Anderson

[esmith_se · 5/10 · 21 January 2022]

Why do we have to turn the volume down every time this woman opens her mouth? She hast to be the loudest thing on TV and she laughs at herself more than anyone else. There have been bakers there making the same dish for 30 years and Bobby reach them? I don't know.

Really !! He always wins

[albertd-33201 · 17 January 2022]

I think the show is fake . I know the results as soon as I see many repeat judges, Bobbie will win . And why is his food tasted always last . Bobbie really , stop making yourself better than you are . I hate your show, so fake.

Not Bad While Awaiting Car Repairs

[krgunn · 7/10 · 1 November 2019]

I had to take my car to the Honda dealership for regular maintenance yesterday afternoon. I was told it was going to take 90 minutes, so I sat in the waiting room expecting to be horribly bored. "Beat Bobby Flay," which is the type of show I never watch, was on the big-screen TV, and I saw three episodes before my car was ready. I have to say it's not bad. The premise, that two challengers have to cook against each other with the main food item of Bobby's choice, then Bobby has to cook against the winner with the main food item of the winner's choice, is actually pretty clever. The announcers were somewhat annoying but didn't spoil it for me. The cooking itself was impressive and made me hungry. Bobby lost against a challenger two out of the three shows I saw, so the challengers definitely had a chance. I doubt I will ever watch this show at home, but it made waiting for my car less boring than I would have expected.

Bobby flay

[puffnstuff-70096 · 10/10 · 29 January 2022]

Love watching Bobby flay. Gives me ideas about different dishes. Only bad part about this show is Sunny Anderson. I swear to god this has to be the MOST ANNOYING PERSON in the world. Also why after only a couple minutes someone has to run over and annoy who ever is cooking. Please get rid of sunny Anderson and Katie Lee both way too too too annoying.

Viewing

[pkergos-71819 · 6/10 · 4 June 2021]

When finishing your dishes, you need to be behind curtains. To many visuals... give aways😡

Disappointingly predictable

[sailbelladonna · 3/10 · 1 March 2015]

Every time I watch this show, they emphasize that the judges are completely unbiased. Yet, while they are critiquing the plates, the 2 chefs are standing there in front of them and grimacing when their plates receive any sort of criticism. The number of times this happens, and Bobby Flay wins, is extraordinary. The judges should judge without any influences - i.e. the chefs and audience. Its disappointing, and becoming very predictable. Also, there is a lot of times when Bobby's dish is NOT the best, yet he wins. Same happens in Iron Chef - I stopped watching because it didn't make sense - several of the guest chefs deserved to win. All quite political. Starts to resemble the Oscars.....

A Very Entertaining Competitive Cooking Show

[magicpandaboom · 9/10 · 13 April 2021]

For some reason watching people cook fancy food is always really satisfying, and in this show, it's made even better by the fact that the people cooking are competing against each other. What happens in this show is chef Bobby Flay, along with his two guest-hosts, will bring two chefs into the kitchen, and Bobby Flay will choose either a specific dish for them to make, or a random ingredient that must be the main ingredient in their dish. They have 20 minutes to make their dish, then the two guest hosts eat and critique their dishes. Whoever made the best dish gets to continue to compete against Bobby Flay himself, this time with a dish of their own choosing. They have 45 minutes to do so, and then they bring in 3 food judges, who eat the dishes without knowing which one is which, and then they all vote for one. Whoever gets the popular vote wins. It's always amusing to watch the chefs and speculate who will win. It's also incredibly satisfying to see the person who's competing against Bobby Flay actually beat him, as Bobby Flay is surprisingly and impressively knowledgeable on pretty much every dish in existence. One thing I don't like about this show is the fact that the guest hosts have such empathy for the chef competing against Bobby Flay, that they'll go up to Bobby Flay and screw with him by doing things like knocking his tools off his table, or dancing around him in a really dumb dance to distract him. I just wish they would let a competition be a competition, even though Bobby Flay is an expert in practically every dish in the world. Another thing is the winner always makes a terrible pun about their dish at the very end of the episode. Other than that, it's an entertaining show that has a lot to offer, after all, there is 27 seasons as of April, 2021.

He always uses Some sort of Chili's.

[meganhayes-74115 · 6/10 · 29 January 2021]

The judges know which dish is which because Bobby always uses some sort of Chili flakes/seasonings. I watched the brunch burger episode. He said he had that in his restaurant as well as she did. When I looked up the recipe he uses there in his restaurant there was no chili peppers anywhere. He added them to the bacon on the show. Well duh.... now they know which plate is his. And let's be honest who in the culinary world voted against a man like that if they know which dish is his. Stop cooking with the chili spices if not necessary in dishes. Gives him the upper hand EVERYTIME.

Don't appreciate this show

[zosia-16784 · 1/10 · 6 December 2018]

I usually don't have time to even bother writing reviews for things (let alone Food Network TV shows), but this show is absolutely so ridiculous that I was triggered enough to do so. To have your own show where you have people try to beat you because apparently you are so fantastic is probably the most egotistical garbage I have ever heard of. I don't even get why this dude is so great. Maybe I would understand Gordon Ramsey or something but this dude I don't even respect. His stupid over the top attitude is actually way too much for me to handle. He doesn't even make anything that looks that good or special. Not to mention the annoying people he somehow rakes in to form a measly crowd. They are all obnoxious and obviously have queued reactions. This is THE worst food network show I have ever witnessed. I would rather watch Guy Fieri haphazardly eat a greasy burger than watch Bobby Flay arrogantly daunt the contestants to see if they're "good enough" to beat him. hah. Find another hobby Bobby Flay.

I love this show

[4ri4n4 · 9/10 · 10 January 2018]

Ok, first of all, those people who are saying other person's dish is better... are not the ones tasting it. Presentation wise, maybe, but maybe Bobby's tastes better? I binged watched this, and no, Bobby doesn't win all the time. He wins about 70% of the time. My only question is, when they had an episode where Marcus was selected to go against Bobby, and Marcus is Ethiopian... and of course Marcus selected an Ethipian dish..one of the dishes was Ethiopian food critic. How did they know that Marcus will be chosen and that he will cook Ethiopian, so they prepared an appropriate judge ahead of time? Maybe they had different judges ready in case either contestant wins..but this was sketchy. Still a fun show.

Pie episode

[judylove-95864 · 7/10 · 9 July 2020]

The only pies that should have gram cracker crust is cheesecake!

Appalled/Chicken Mole

[maridyl · 1/10 · 15 June 2018]

I watched this show, they emphasize that the judges are completely unbiased. Traditional chicken mole is very complicated and a lot of work. For Bobby to slaughter the dish with raisins, mango, molasass was very disturbing!! I do not care who you talk too Chicken mole does not have any of those ingredients. Yet, while they are critiquing the plates, the 2 chefs are standing there in front of them, the judges clearly have not tasted traditional chicken mole. Shame on you judges for giving Bobby the win over the colorful plate over a boring traditional plate. New flash: nobody in Mexico unless they go to culinary school have used the ingredients Bobby used to make chicken mole. Chicken mole should never ever have pomegranate or mango in it! The number of times this happens, and Bobby Flay wins, is very disappointing! Also, there is a lot of times when Bobby's dish is NOT the best, and in this event it was clearly not the best! Bobby stick to what you know and do not slaughter chicken mole like you did in your show "beat bobby Flay"

Almost always predictable

[uzorchinedu · 26 March 2023]

I watch the Beat Bobby Flay program from Nigeria. You can almost always predict that Bobby Flay will win almost every other time because the judges look at their faces and dishes and Bobby Flay will always make facial and body expressions to show that it's his dish being judged.

For FAIRNESS the judging should be BLIND. No one should know the owner of the dish (say DISH A or DISH B) and the chefs should be invited after the results for dishes have been reached by the judges.

Most times I watch I feel like the visiting chef will lose even when it's obvious that Bobby's dish might have received some negatives. My opinion.

Don't cheat Bobby Flay

[kwnrsvrf · 6/10 · 14 May 2021]

Bobby Flay is amazing; but I believe the judges should be learned on the dishes they judge. When Bobby competed on the Manto dish his dish wasn't Manto. The competition was make the dish your challenger chooses, not make a dish that taste good. I believe you should make the original dish and then kick it up a notch. If you have to watch your opponent then make what you think it is. How can you win. If your judges were from the country where the dish is traditional he would have lost.

Winner rule/no chilies allowed!!!

[jenascott-69116 · 10/10 · 10 September 2021]

Challenger needs to appoint their dish sans any chilies or hotness. Otherwise basically you're fu$&d !!!

Like, The challenge is Oooy Goooy macaroni and cheese without any chilies or hot spices.

Media Director please keep up!

[Carriexoc · 7/10 · 28 May 2021]

Please keep up On seasons and episodes! Hard to keep track of which ones have been watched when they aren't even listed on IMDB! A 8 year old intern could do it! I track and rate the shows as I watch. Hard to do when they aren't even listed. IMDB is THE app to do this! Please! Thank you!

Already know who will win!

[chefsam-68037 · 4/10 · 12 February 2016]

I used to enjoy watching this show but the outcome is always the same. The competition topics are entertaining and interesting to see the different directions the chefs take in completing their dishes. However, there were plenty of times when the competitor's dishes were much better than Bobby's, yet he always seems to win. Every show that I have watched always ends with Bobby as the winner. I guess the judges must be biased... it's sometimes pretty obvious which dish belongs to whom. No longer watch the show because I already know who the winner is. Has there ever been a time when Bobby didn't win? If so, how many times has he lost and which episodes?

Judge please

[lucelighy · 9/10 · 6 September 2022]

I just watch the episode where a classic Chinese dish was prepared: The competitor created the actual authentic dish.

Not one judge was Chinese to verify its authenticity and flavors.

The one judge said the noodles were under cooked The original dish had the noodles al dente.

The judges need to be better selected to know the authentic dish.

There wasn't a Chinese judge to verify the authenticity

I love the show and Bobby

He also always uses the ideas if his competitor as they don't which is unsavory

Just use a cookbook

Some of the so called and Mexicane wasn't dishes aren't what I grew up with etc. Black beans are not northern Mexican or blue corn which is Southwest US Typically Cuban.

Raul Jon Carreon.

Predictable, sad.

[myramyra-96879 · 1/10 · 30 October 2021]

Like watching a high school clique, this is an embarrassing display of fawning over one person. I'm sure it has appeal to some, but if you're hungry for a legit cooking show, this isn't it. The chefs are interesting, individually; but they appear together so often, the network seems small and ironically stale.

Bobby should be judged on the Challenge Dish

[rpl-08583 · 8/10 · 3 July 2021]

I like the show and I know it's only entertainment, but my biggest gripe about the show is when Bobby wins but didn't actually make the Challenge Dish. Just watched a Pho challenge and 2 of the judges said what Bobby made wasn't Pho but it tasted better than the actual Pho dish the Challenger made, so they voted for him. He should be judged on the actual dish he was supposed to make. He's a world class chef, I'm sure everything he makes tastes wonderful, but that's not the essence of the show.

Lose the idiotic celebrity friends and gain 5 stars instantly

[acdc_mp3 · 3/10 · 5 June 2022]

This show has a great premise in that it gives up and coming chefs a 1-on-1 competition against Bobby Flay. There is a lot of creativity and very delicious looking dishes presented on the show.

What kills the show for me is the influx of Bobby's celebrity buddies who all gang up against him in such a contrived way it gets very old, very fast. When they go "bother" him while cooking isn't funny or cute or interesting in any way. Lose the celebrities and play the show more straight and it's a great show.

Hhhhmmmm?

[jenascott-69116 · 10/10 · 10 September 2021]

As much as I enjoy all of Bobby Flays shows and I do believe without tasting that his flavor pallet for food is fantastic. But, my issue and a question is basically is that on beat Bobby Flay, how biased and real are the judges on that show? He throws any Mexican or New Mexican spice or chili into almos 99% of all of his dishes. I just watched a rerun because I'm basically binge watching the show, But I knew right off she was going to add green chili to his recipe and guess what, he did. I could win a drinking game based on the fact that he will put some sort of chili in his recipe, even a dessert. Also, I do realize the TV shows are edited, but it shows both of the contestants right in front of the judges making their little smirks or sadness. I feel in this case, they should leave the room or stand behind the judges. IDK?

P. S..... Still love the game 🤙🏻

So FAKE !

[diane-14727 · 1/10 · 24 March 2022]

I quit watching the show a while back & decided to try it again. Big mistake ! Bobby does not do good when put against pastry chefs. The lady this time made an absolutely beautiful Eclair. Bobb's Eclair looked like something a kid would've made. And he won ! It seems like judges know if something has chile ,it's Bobby's so they vote for it.