Primetime Emmy Awards (2016)

Primetime Emmy [Nominee]

Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Drama Series

Constance Zimmer

Primetime Emmy [Nominee]

Outstanding Writing for a Drama Series

Marti Noxon
Sarah Gertrude Shapiro
Lifetime Network

AFI Awards, USA (2016)

AFI Award [Winner]

TV Program of the Year

Casting Society of America, USA (2017)

Artios [Nominee]

Outstanding Achievement in Casting - Television Pilot and First Season - Drama

Barbara Fiorentino
Katrina Wandel George
Coreen Mayrs
Heike Brandstatter

Critics Choice Television Awards (2016)

Critics' Choice TV Award [Winner]

Best Supporting Actress in a Drama Series

Constance Zimmer

Critics' Choice TV Award [Nominee]

Best Actress in a Drama Series

Shiri Appleby

Critics' Choice TV Award [Nominee]

Best Drama Series

Critics Choice Television Awards (2016)

Critics' Choice TV Award [Nominee]

Best Supporting Actress in a Drama Series

Constance Zimmer

Critics Choice Television Awards (2015)

Critics' Choice TV Award [Winner]

Most Exciting New Series

Gay and Lesbian Entertainment Critics Association (GALECA) (2016)

Dorian Award [Nominee]

Unsung TV Show of the Year

Gold Derby Awards (2016)

Gold Derby TV Award [Nominee]

Drama Supporting Actress

Constance Zimmer

Gotham Awards (2015)

Gotham Independent Film Award [Nominee]

Breakthrough Series - Long Form

Marti Noxon
Sarah Gertrude Shapiro

Online Film & Television Association (2016)

OFTA Television Award [Nominee]

Best Supporting Actress in a Drama Series

Constance Zimmer

Peabody Awards (2016)

Peabody Award [Winner]

Entertainment and Children's Programming

Lifetime Network

Prism Awards (2016)

Prism Award [Nominee]

Drama Series Multi-Episode Storyline

Television Critics Association Awards (2016)

TCA Award [Nominee]

Outstanding New Program

TCA Award [Nominee]

Outstanding Achievement in Drama

TCA Award [Nominee]

Program of the Year

UBCP/ACTRA Awards, Vancouver (2016)

UBCP Award [Nominee]

Best Actor

Ty Olsson

Women's Image Network Awards (2016)

WIN Award [Nominee]

Outstanding Show Directed By a Woman

Shiri Appleby
Lifetime Network

Women's Image Network Awards (2015)

WIN Award [Winner]

Outstanding Show Produced by a Woman

Marti Noxon
Sarah Gertrude Shapiro
Lifetime Television

WIN Award [Nominee]

Outstanding Drama Series

Lifetime Television