Self - Host / Self / Gary Bouchard / Patrick Henry (151 episodes, 2011-2015)
Self / Crystal Mineral / Keeper and Company house band (138 episodes, 2011-2015)
Mimi on the Hoops / Self (137 episodes, 2011-2015)
Panelist / Self / Betsy Ross / Conspiracy Theory Mary (136 episodes, 2011-2015)
Self / Joe Evans III / Keeper and Company house band (136 episodes, 2011-2015)
Self / Claude Dijon / Keeper and Company house band (133 episodes, 2011-2015)
Human Fish / The Human Fish / Self / Panelist / Ancestor of the Human Fish / Clint Flashbang / Israel Bissell / The Conspiracy Turtle (131 episodes, 2011-2015)
Panelist / Self / Self - Panelist / Sir Titus (119 episodes, 2011-2015)
Panelist / Self / Bo Montez / The Whiffle Bat Gang member / Luther Martin / Mopus Dopus (114 episodes, 2011-2015)
Self / The Lone Cornmeal Machine / Stillman (77 episodes, 2011-2015)
Bananaman / Self / Cowboy Dan (73 episodes, 2011-2015)
Self / The Hintmaster / Horse / The Guy Who Likes Cream But Not Too Much Cream's Personal Barista / Chug Clamato / Bee / Carl Steven Howlings / Chong / Mr. Snyde / President Abraham Lincoln / Stewart Heary / The Guy Who Likes Grapes But Not Too Many Grapes's Personal Barista / The Lamb (67 episodes, 2011-2015)
Self (65 episodes, 2011-2015)
Random Messenger Bag / Self (56 episodes, 2013-2015)
Self (55 episodes, 2011-2014)
Vacation Jason / Self / Booty Mummy / Master of Terror / Vacation Jesus (48 episodes, 2011-2015)
Self / Bee / Horse / The King of Hats / Dr. Heckle / Dr. Saul Thunderburk / King of Hats / Triceratops Who's Not Very Good at a Boston Accent (46 episodes, 2011-2015)
Self / Aaron Burr / Hot Dog (42 episodes, 2011-2014)
Self / Hanz Von Gregor (41 episodes, 2011-2015)
Random Jean (33 episodes, 2011-2015)
Self / Beef Jerky / ALF / Break Dance Maid Boy / Human Barber Pole / Human Disco Ball / Human Pyramid / Human Scoreboard / Human Video Camera / Human Wishing Well / Roman / Scoliosis Alf / The 'C' (32 episodes, 2011-2015)
Self / Roman Phil Jackson (28 episodes, 2011-2013)
Self / Jarnatz the Magnificent / Ong (26 episodes, 2011-2015)
Self (26 episodes, 2011-2014)
Self / Shadow Person / The Man Behind the Plant (25 episodes, 2011-2015)
Random Andrew / Self (25 episodes, 2011-2013)
Self / Self - audience member / The Time Tit (24 episodes, 2011-2015)
40 Year Old Goosey (24 episodes, 2011-2014)
Self (23 episodes, 2012-2014)
Self / 18th Century American Gladiator (21 episodes, 2012-2015)
Self (21 episodes, 2012-2014)
Self (20 episodes, 2011-2015)
The Lone Cornmeal Machine / Self (19 episodes, 2011-2015)
Self (19 episodes, 2011-2014)
Self / Meowgic Matt, the Magician for Cats / Meogic Matt, Magician for Cats / Meowgic Matt, Magician for Cats (19 episodes, 2011-2014)
Self / Vinegar Al / Clown / Cow / Ken Dolla Bill (19 episodes, 2012-2014)
Random Ellen / Random Aphrodite (18 episodes, 2012-2013)
Self (15 episodes, 2012-2015)
Self / Audience Member with a Sleeping Baby / Audience Member With A Sleeping Baby / Jarnatz's Virgin / Mermaid / The Ghost of the Ultimate Warrior (12 episodes, 2011-2014)
Self / Lil Woody Allen / The Whiffle Bat Gang member (12 episodes, 2011-2013)
Self (11 episodes, 2011-2014)
Self / The Ghost of Macho Man Randy Savage / Sandwich Knight / The Whiffle Bat Gang member (10 episodes, 2011-2014)
The Keeper of the Battledome / Self (10 episodes, 2011-2013)
Vampire, Abraham Lincoln Hunter / Self / Stillman's Robot Army Member / The Hemlock Gang member (10 episodes, 2012-2013)
Beast Masturbator / Bungalow Bill from Mulberry Hill (9 episodes, 2013-2014)
Self (8 episodes, 2011-2013)
The Guy Who Likes Cream But Not Too Much Cream / The Guy / The Guy Who Likes Grapes But Not Too Many Grapes (8 episodes, 2012-2013)
Writer Who Was Fired From The New Yorker For Being Too Pretentious / The Writer Who Was Fired From The New Yorker For Being Too Pretentious / Ratliff Press Secretary (7 episodes, 2012-2013)
Dougie from Connecticut / Self / Dougie From Connecticut (7 episodes, 2012-2013)
Self / Referee (7 episodes, 2013-2014)
Self (7 episodes, 2014)
Self (6 episodes, 2011-2014)
Self (6 episodes, 2011-2013)
Rachel from The Couple Who Is So In Love Now But Will Definitely Break Up In Six Months / Self (6 episodes, 2011-2013)
Self / Mopey Janitor with Bad Timing and A Broken Mop / Mopey Janitor with Bad Timing and a Broken Mop / Stillman's Robot Army Member / The Hemlock Gang member (6 episodes, 2011-2013)
Self (6 episodes, 2011-2012)
Self (6 episodes, 2013-2014)
Self (5 episodes, 2011-2015)
Self / Hair and Make-Up Woman (5 episodes, 2011-2013)
Mysterious Man / Self (5 episodes, 2011-2013)
Self / The Whiffle Bat Gang member (5 episodes, 2011)
Self / Self - musical guest (5 episodes, 2012-2014)
Self (5 episodes, 2012-2014)
Self (5 episodes, 2012-2013)
Self (4 episodes, 2011-2014)
Self (4 episodes, 2011-2012)
Gethy / Self (4 episodes, 2011)
Self (4 episodes, 2012-2014)
Self (4 episodes, 2012)
Zero Fucks Boyd (4 episodes, 2013-2014)
Ray from A Couple Who Are So In Love Right Now But Will Definitely Break Up in Six Months (4 episodes, 2013)
'Stone Cold' Steve Austin Powers / Austin Power Tools / Bob Ross-ton Powers / Uno Mas-ton Powers (4 episodes, 2014)
Self (4 episodes, 2014)
Grimace's Dad / Psychological Terrorist / Self (3 episodes, 2011-2014)
Secret Service Agent / Secret Service Guard / Secret Service agent (3 episodes, 2011-2012)
Self (3 episodes, 2011-2012)
Self (3 episodes, 2012-2014)
Self (3 episodes, 2012-2013)
Hiro Coquayne (3 episodes, 2012-2013)
Dan Black, The Guy Who Fucking Hates The Chris Gethard Show / Self (3 episodes, 2012)
Self (3 episodes, 2012)
Scott 'The Animal Man' Joshert / Scotty Gunk / William Frankin (3 episodes, 2013-2014)
Self (3 episodes, 2013-2014)
Big Cat Who Loves Monopoly (3 episodes, 2013)
Smith / Count Dracula, Doc Freakman, Bobby Blayze (3 episodes, 2014-2015)
Audience member / Harley Tucker (3 episodes, 2014-2015)
Random Sandy (3 episodes, 2014)
Self (2 episodes, 2011-2014)
Self (2 episodes, 2011-2012)
Ilana / Self (2 episodes, 2011)
Self (2 episodes, 2011)
Self (2 episodes, 2012-2014)
Self / Weenie Feet Bobbins (2 episodes, 2012-2013)
Self (2 episodes, 2012-2013)
Watermelon Cop (2 episodes, 2012-2013)
Self (2 episodes, 2012)
Cocoon Central Dance Crew / Self (2 episodes, 2012)
Hiro Coquayne's wife (2 episodes, 2012)
Candy Coquayne (2 episodes, 2012)
Self (2 episodes, 2013-2014)
Self (2 episodes, 2013)
Dress Saleswoman (2 episodes, 2013)
Self (2 episodes, 2014)
Self / Self - musical guest (2 episodes, 2014)
Self (1 episode, 2011)
MC Chris (1 episode, 2011)
Self (1 episode, 2012)
Johnny Fairplay (1 episode, 2012)
Random Vin (1 episode, 2012)
Penis Bailey (1 episode, 2012)
Member of The Cool Guys (1 episode, 2012)
Lil Dinky (1 episode, 2012)
Self (1 episode, 2013)
Man Ham (1 episode, 2013)
Jesse Ventura (1 episode, 2013)
Chef Michael Dinaldi (1 episode, 2013)
Self - Musical Guest (1 episode, 2013)
Retired Kitten (1 episode, 2013)
Cynthia Knight, the Horny Sex Therapist (1 episode, 2013)
Cockstain Tearduct (1 episode, 2013)
Drunk Daddy Who Brings Home Snowcones (1 episode, 2013)
Duhaarae (1 episode, 2013)
Max Chang, Professional Scientist (1 episode, 2013)
Self - musical guest (1 episode, 2013)
Themselves - Musical Guest (1 episode, 2013)
(1 episode, 2013)
Intern Paige (1 episode, 2013)
Panelist (1 episode, 2014)
Scrompin Nompin Nompin (1 episode, 2014)
Todd Watch (1 episode, 2014)
Self - Guest (1 episode, 2014)
Self (1 episode, 2014)
Jesus Christ Razorblade Tuna Fish Motherfucker (1 episode, 2014)
Ira Ass (1 episode, 2014)
Asian Thor (1 episode, 2014)
Themselves (1 episode, 2014)
Teresa (1 episode, 2014)
Self - musical guest (1 episode, 2014)
Tony Murloney, the Zamboni Jabroni (1 episode, 2014)
Cum Pappy (1 episode, 2014)
Eddie Kingston (1 episode, 2014)
Referee (1 episode, 2014)
The God Amongst the Ashes (1 episode, 2014)
Self (1 episode, 2015)
Mr. Jokes (1 episode, 2015)