Out of My Hand (2015) User Reviews (3)

Sometimes the American dream is a necessity.

[Sergeant_Tibbs · 7/10 · 8 July 2015]

Out Of My Hand is one of many cross-country tales of immigration that find themselves drawn to film festivals such as Los Angeles, where it won its prestigious Best U.S. Fiction Award. It's a procedural film in the ways it studies the laborious routines of its Liberian protagonist Cisco, and it's naturalistic in style rather than capitalizing on the state of his desperation. This is a revealing perspective on the elephant in the room of the land of hope and dreams. Juxtapositioning two worlds and two styles (the film had to switch cinematographers after the original director of photography Ryo Murakami died of malaria at age 33) it paints a powerful picture of working just to live.

We open on Cisco, played skillfully by Bishop Blay, as he taps rubber sap on several trees on a plantation in Liberia. Its docu-drama style is indistinguishable from the most fascinating documentary on the BBC, but afterwards it's distinctly fiction showcasing a remarkable economy in its restrained structure to deliver layers of conflict along with shreds of hope. Cisco's cousin is a New York taxi driver, something his peers, an impressive array of non-actors blending in with the professionals, admire but a prospective he treats with skepticism. Their union calls a strike, but the workers are no match for the pressures and ultimately find themselves having to cave in. In a bind, Cisco finds himself out of work and has to reluctantly leave his family and accept an invitation follow his cousin's footsteps.

The culture shock when the most famous skyline in the world unfolds is remarkable. We don't see Cisco on his flight, so we jump straight from Liberia to New York. The spectacle feels so trivial in light of day-to-day struggle as you see it through the eyes of those who really needs the hope that the American dream provides. The warmth of Murakami's lens in Liberia is harshly contrasted with the sterile chilliness of Owen Donovan's New York revealing America as a painful last resort. However, the film peaks at that moment. It unwisely has jumbled threads of narrative from then on, which may be are engaging on their own, unfortunately feel tacked on, as if it could be any assortment of half a dozen options. Cisco's character development heads in appealing directions as he gets meaner and bitter, while it reveals an intriguing and dangerous past.

Those ghosts are director Takeshi Fukunaga's main focus for its final stretch hinting at the lengths Cisco went to during the Liberian Civil War. Despite the irony that it would only be something that follows him 4,000 miles from home, it's something that should have been set up in the opening Liberia section to feel more connected. Temptations and financial traps of sex workers are a very interesting dilemma for Cisco after watching his loyalty to his family, but in the meanwhile the film misses a crucial gap I wanted to see. How did he get the taxi driver medallion that supposedly costs several hundred thousands? How does he know the streets of New York like the back of his hand? How does he cope with the competition of Uber? These aren't plot holes, these problems are perhaps too current, but they're struggles I wanted to see illustrated.

But Out Of My Hand isn't trying to be a modern statement. This is a timeless problem and a timeless opportunity. And that doesn't take away Fukunaga's controlled and efficient direction in the Liberian first half. It's a film about skill, and that feeds into all aspects of its production. Perhaps it's a film that would always suffer from feeling disjointed because of how different the two halves are on a narrative basis. With Cisco's initial reluctance, it's fascinating to look at a vocation in one of the USA's most populated cities being his best option for the survival of his family rather than the desired aspiration. The film makes it difficult to marry its themes of dark histories not being forgotten and the struggles of immigrants, but each ideas are exclusively poignant at the very least, and Out Of My Hand keeps you close to make you feel the sweat of the journey.

7/10

Impressive first feature about Liberian rubber tapper emigrant to America despite abrupt denouement

[Turfseer · 6/10 · 7 February 2016]

Director Takeshi Fukunaga spent time in Liberia researching his new, impressive film, Out of My Hand. He auditioned various local actors and cast neophyte Bishop Blay to play the role of Cisco, a disaffected rubber tapper toiling long hours on a plantation.

Fukunaga's research pays off as Cisco's tale smacks of a heady verisimilitude. The plot at first proceeds slowly as Cisco becomes embroiled in a labor action against his employer. He's convinced by his co-workers to join in a strike protesting long hours and low wages. His wife mocks him, believing that the company will simply replace him but he continues to persist until the strike fails and his co-workers end up going back to work.

At this point, Cisco decides to find work in New York City. He has a cousin who works as a cabdriver there and it's the cousin who sets him up in an apartment in one of the outer boroughs and gets him a job as a cabdriver. As this was Blay's first time in the US, the actor convincingly displays what it's like adjusting to life in a new country.

A notable scene includes Cisco being helped by a community worker when he first arrives. Later, Cisco's pride prevents him from accepting a large tip from one of his passengers.

The main plot involves the sudden intrusion of the menacing Jacob into Cisco's rather staid and routine life. Jacob claims that Cisco was in a position of power over him during the Liberian Civil War. We never really learn what Cisco actually did and he continually insists he doesn't know Jacob. But Jacob doesn't appear to be any angel himself. He sets Cisco up with a prostitute without his permission and then demands payment.

Fukunaga unsatisfactorily ends his story much too abruptly with Jacob being killed in a random fashion which I will not describe here. Somehow I wanted to know more about Cisco's back story and also wanted to learn of his ultimate fate.

Fukunaga was assisted with some excellent camera work by cinematographer Ryo Murakami, who sadly passed away from malaria right after the film was completed. This is an impressive first feature despite the abrupt denouement.

American Dream and Real Life

[christian94 · 8/10 · 31 August 2015]

Takeshi Fukunaga's promising first feature film focuses on Cisco, a complex character who is revealed throughout the movie with good writing, contemplative directing with a vision and inscrutable non-verbal acting. Liberian-born Bishop Blay plays Cisco with all the right cues and he will, like the character he portrays, come to America for the first time to film the New York part of the story. As fate would have it, he is still in the USA now as the 2014 West African outbreak of Ebola who greatly affected Liberia prompted him to try to make his life there and try the acting scene.

Takeshi Fukunaga himself came to America from Japan in hopes to find a better life more than a decade ago, even though in no way to the same disillusion and desperation as is seen in Liberia and most of the third world. He examines this false American Dream and land of opportunity or "land of milk and honey" very well. Another film to life parallel is that as the director's long time collaborator, cinematographer and brother-in-law, Ryo Murakami, came to Liberia to film both the documentary on the rubber plantation workers and this feature film, but came to pass from complication of malaria he contracted there.

Coming back to the movie, it offers nuanced scenes in Liberia with powerful dialog and a documentary visual style very close the the action and actors and non-actors. In New York, the focus is switched (metaphorically and physically as Owen Donovan has to take up the lens to capture the metropolis' chaos) to delve into Cisco's demons, dreams and fears. Two new important characters are introduced, a pimp and a whore, to bring about the perspective of past, present & future as well as pleasure & pain. Economic and emotional realities and restrictions reach the screen but with a distance like the Atlantic ocean who separates Cisco from his wife and children.

Fukunaga's achievement is in staying in the subtleties without losing the viewer's interest or intensity. While the engagement may be more intellectual at first, the underlying emotions, messages and thought- provocative portrayal are longer coming, but perhaps also longer-lasting.

USA & Liberia 2015 | 88 mins | Montreal World Film Festival | English & Liberian Pidgin (English subtitles)