Academy of Science Fiction, Fantasy & Horror Films, USA (2018)

Saturn Award [Nominee]

Best Superhero Adaptation Television Series

Saturn Award [Nominee]

Best Actress on Television

Melissa Benoist

Saturn Award [Nominee]

Best Supporting Actress on Television

Odette Annable

Academy of Science Fiction, Fantasy & Horror Films, USA (2017)

Saturn Award [Winner]

Best Superhero Adaptation Television Series

Saturn Award [Winner]

Best Actress on Television

Melissa Benoist

Saturn Award [Nominee]

Best Supporting Actor on Television

Mehcad Brooks

Saturn Award [Nominee]

Best Guest Performance in a Television Series

Tyler Hoechlin

Academy of Science Fiction, Fantasy & Horror Films, USA (2016)

Saturn Award [Nominee]

Best Superhero Adaptation Television Series

Saturn Award [Nominee]

Best Actress on Television

Melissa Benoist

Saturn Award [Nominee]

Best Supporting Actress on Television

Calista Flockhart

Saturn Award [Nominee]

Best Guest Performance in a Television Series

Laura Benanti

Critics Choice Television Awards (2015)

Critics' Choice TV Award [Winner]

Most Exciting New Series

GLAAD Media Awards (2017)

GLAAD Media Award [Nominee]

Outstanding Drama Series

Jupiter Award (2017)

Jupiter Award [Nominee]

Best International TV Series

Kids' Choice Awards, USA (2017)

Blimp Award [Nominee]

Favourite TV Show (Family)

Leo Awards (2018)

Leo [Nominee]

Best Sound Editing in a Dramatic Series

Kyle Petty

People's Choice Awards, USA (2016)

People's Choice Award [Winner]

Favorite New TV Drama

Teen Choice Awards (2018)

Teen Choice Award [Winner]

Choice TV Actress: Action

Melissa Benoist

Teen Choice Award [Nominee]

Choice TV Show: Action

Teen Choice Award [Nominee]

Choice TV Actor: Action

Chris Wood

Teen Choice Award [Nominee]

Choice TV: Villain

Odette Annable

Teen Choice Award [Nominee]

Choice: Scene Stealer

Katie McGrath

Teen Choice Awards (2017)

Teen Choice Award [Winner]

Choice TV Actress: Action

Melissa Benoist

Teen Choice Award [Nominee]

Choice TV Ship

Melissa Benoist
Chris Wood

Teen Choice Award [Nominee]

Choice TV Actor: Action

Chris Wood

Teen Choice Award [Nominee]

Choice TV Show: Action

Teen Choice Award [Nominee]

Choice TV: Villain

Teri Hatcher

Teen Choice Award [Nominee]

Choice: Liplock

Melissa Benoist
Chris Wood

Teen Choice Awards (2016)

Teen Choice Award [Nominee]

Choice TV Breakout Show

The Joey Awards, Vancouver (2017)

Joey Award [Winner]

Best Featured Actor in a TV Series 11 Years & Up

Aidan Fink