User Reviews (40)

Add a Review

  • Jack Irish is a detective show with yards of gritty, very Australian character.

    Jack is wryly witty, hard drinking, somewhat self destructive, self styled detective and part time ladies man. Played with a world worn, crusty charm, by Guy Pearce.

    Jack Irish and the larger than life, cast of very colourful Australian characters, really bring this series to life. Each of the characters in this series has a well rounded, often off beat or odd ball personality and their own well scripted narrative. There are no "filler" characters in Jack Irish and the series is so much better, for it.

    The quality characterizations are matched up with robust, mystery/crime, tales, that typically have an "underdog taking on the corrupt establishment" flavour. Jack is always the underdog, who inevitably comes out on top, but, typically, not without exacting a personal toll.

    I really, really like Jack Irish. If you have not spent time in Australia it may be hard to appreciate some of the cultural artifacts and nuances found in the series. That said, its a very approachable watch, that's certainly a departure from mainstream US and UK crime/mystery drama's. I say give it a go. Eight out of ten from me.
  • tomsview29 April 2016
    I loved the first three "Jack Irish" movies, they just went from strength to strength.

    They formed a body of work that can stand comparison with the best in the crime/mystery genre such as "Morse", "Lewis", "Wallander", "Jesse Stone", and "Vera."

    All share key ingredients that are even more important than a cutting-edge plot, the critical one being that the lead character must have feeling. It doesn't matter how tough or worldly-wise they are, these people know your pain. All the best ones understand human failings even if they don't always forgive them. Wit serves their characters well - not so much cynicism, but a knowing, world-weary wit.

    The first three "Jack Irish" movies had those qualities in spades, plus unique, beautifully realised characters right down the cast list.

    But I'm not so sure about the latest 6-part series. I think the extended format works against the tighter format of the movie length episodes. Where the filmmakers edited to fit 90-minutes, they now extend to fill 4-hours plus.

    There are still clever touches and some very funny lines, and you can't fault the performances, but there are definitely some well-worn themes: a trail that leads to crooked politicians; ruthless multinationals; terrorists, and that old favourite of just about every series, the cult church with dark motives. Despite sub-plots going off in all directions, the principle that 'no one is introduced for nothing' is applied with a vengeance - no one is random, everything is connected.

    Familiar elements added spice to the first three movies, but here things are perilously close to being over-spiced. Jack's buddies get a major workout with a lot more business to get through.

    A factor is possibly the creation of more content for a voracious medium, but I can't help feeling that the six episodes would have made two more succinct movies along the lines of "Bad Debts", "Black Tide" and "Dead Point".

    It will be interesting to see where "Jack Irish" goes from here.
  • I'd long had the intention to watch Jack Irish, having missed the boat when the three telemovies were aired and the subsequent series. Finally I got stuck in, and there I remained glued to every instalment.

    The quality acting ensemble, the look and feel, the tangled webs woven by the writers, the diverse characters and dry humour - everything about Jack Irish is a joy.

    It's understandable this show may not be everyone's glass of Scotch - it certainly enhances the experience to be familiar with the locations and uniquely Melbourne references. But difficult to understand are the critiques owing to the protagonist (brilliantly played by Guy Pearce) being dismissed as a loser / dead beat. For good reason he is damaged and flawed and thus makes questionable decisions in the pursuit of the truth, which imperil himself and those he cares for. I guess some need their heroes to wear capes.

    The strongest series is open for debate. What the final season lacks in uniqueness by travelling down the corrupt cop road is more than offset by the full circle narrative which lays bare the opening scene of the first telemovie underpinning Jack's character arc. The memorable final few minutes of this memorable show were beautifully executed, serving to exacerbate the bittersweet satisfaction Jack Irish has resolved his last case - himself.
  • wynne-112 August 2016
    Australian author Peter Temple's series of detective novels about Jack Irish have been lighting up television screens since 2012, when the first two adaptations were broadcast. An immediate hit, a third Jack Irish telefilm was broadcast in 2014.

    Jack Irish is an emotionally wounded, borderline down-and-outer who had once been a successful lawyer but was professionally and personally derailed when his wife was murdered. Guy Pearce, the star of the JACK IRISH series, brings just the right amount of world-weariness to his role to suggest a classic film noir protagonist. The supporting cast, including Marta Dusseldorp as Jack's on again-off again love interest, Linda (who also stars in two other Autralian series--JANET KING and A PLACE TO CALL HOME) are just as compelling in their own way and the show is as much a series of character studies as it is a detective show.

    Now we have JACK IRISH Season 1: BLIND FAITH, the most recent addition to the JACK IRISH canon, which is a six-part mini-series, a format that serves the story well. While not based on one of the JACK IRISH novels, it is as faithful to the original characters as die-hard fans might want it to be. With the increased running time, multiple story-lines can converge and develop without seeming rushed. Given that one of the story arcs focuses on religious extremism, (both Christian and Muslim) it is wise the makers of JACK IRISH recognized they needed a larger canvas to fairly examine the inherently sensitive issues. While it is common these days for people of faith to be portrayed negatively in film and television programs, it is encouraging to see some balance achieved amidst the accusations. Case in point: there is a scene in JACK IRISH--once we've established that a "mega-church" is behind a series of murders and other misdeeds--in which a character points out, while sitting in a soup kitchen, "That fellow there runs this place. He makes $40,000 a year and gives most of it away. He's doing what the others SHOULD be doing." (I paraphrase, but the gist is clear). One can only appreciate such fairness. It is a breath of fresh air, really. Of course, the principle characters are shown specifically to be non-believers, another annoying trend that needs to be addressed in this writer's opinion, but it's a start.

    JACK IRISH is notable too for being about people who are older, from forty-somethings, like Irish, to a substantial cast of older, even elderly, characters. The regulars who haunt the bar Irish might call his second home are a great bunch of old codgers. And Irish's furniture-making mentor, an old master by the name of Charlie, whose infinite patience with Irish gives him the much-needed respite he occasionally needs from his problems, is a true rarity on television today. Interestingly, Charlie was portrayed in the first two JACK IRISH films by German actor Vadim Glowna, who passed away before the third film was made. The role is re-cast for the mini-series and features an actor named David Ritchie--who also passed away not long after the mini-series wrapped. Is the role of Charlie cursed? Only time will tell...

    While it is not yet known whether there will be more JACK IRISH films/mini-series produced, it's a pretty good bet that there will be. The show is extremely well produced, brilliantly acted, with quirky humour, troubled romance and a world-view that, while sometimes cynical and dark, like the best of film noir, is ultimately life-affirming. Jack is a classic underdog and we want him to succeed, to get his life back together, to rekindle his romance with Linda (Dusseldorp's character).

    How many characters on television today do we truly care about? Jack Irish is one of them.
  • For an Australian crime show, this is by far the one of the best. I like Guy Pearce and the supporting cast. I started watching Jack Irish the movies versions last year. I was pleasantly surprised that they made it into a TV series. It is a great watch, because it is so not like any other show on television. I'm hoping for more, a second season and continue on from there. This is one television show that should be aired in the United States. It deserves a larger audience.

    I am really in a kind of quite love affair with the Blackhawk that Pearce drives in the series. I just wonder how many are still running around the down-under continent? Australia has a knack for holding on to a lot of nostalgic artifacts of American origin or design. Even with the right hand drive.

    Cheers Mates.
  • mstylianou78 July 2021
    This show is like a diamond in the rough! Mystery combined with danger and violence done very well. Guy Pearce is good, playing second fiddle to the locations of iconic Fitzroy, Melbourne.
  • I'm sure many agree that the writing, acting, direction and overall storyline are simply excellent. What really appealed to me, however, were the side stories. In most shows they are annoying and irrelevant, but the story lines related to race horses, the old footballers in the pub, the carpenter, and others make this a truly complete and enjoyable "universe."
  • I like a lot of the Oz tv and film I see. The Jack Irish films were fun, in large part, because of the supporting ensemble, many familiar to me from other productions. S 2 puts the film gang back together and is much better for it. S1 I rated 5, S2 rate 8 so 7 overall.
  • Great actors and actresses, they all play phenomenal roles. A very good mix of comedy and crime with expected and unexpected outcomes. Watched the 3 movies and both series in 5 days.
  • The show has it's merits as it attempts to have the quirky comedic side story parallel the serious detective story. The quirky side has characters and plot lines that go from inane to stupid, the detective side has serious business going on. Unfortunately the inane and stupid too often migrate to the serious side. The police are either invisible or incompetent, the bad guys get to be bad without consequences episode after episode, and poor old Marta Dusseldorp gets hung out to dry (luckily she has a much better gig in Sydney circa 1950's). Jack seems confused more than not, and manages to get himself nearly killed every episode, and the cops just laugh. And they're not even shooting for satire!
  • lucy_kearn31 August 2021
    I really enjoyed this series - I've binged the first two seasons, and eager for the third. Jack Irish manages to pack in everything that makes for great viewing: fantastic locations (I love Fitzroy, but also really enjoy the overseas locations), a treasure chest of wonderful Australian actors, intriguing plots and plenty of witty humor.
  • I like J I for the obvious reasons. Intriquing stories, likeable ensemble, OZ/NZ in general. But I am very tired of disaffected youths providing frustrating plot developments in a most cliche manner. S2 introduces a character that's nearly worse than Rusty from Major Crimes! We've seen this character repeatedly and its so frustrating. My temptation to slap the smirk out of them is not pleasant or much in line with my experience of todays' yuuts. Its just lazy writing! Season 2 is more enjoyable than S1 despite the disaffected kid and a grafted on horse racing subplot. That adds charm and gives the supporting crowd we like do fun stuff.
  • It's just painful to watch the characters painstakingly come to conclusions you saw coming ages ago. The connect dots like we hadn't put it all together in the first episode. Characters don't even seem to know what they're doing while they're doing it. Linda thinks she's chasing a completely different story for the majority of the series. Everything just happens to her. Lazy writing.
  • People are flawed. That is what makes this show great.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    (Review based on watching the whole of the season with the "Via crucis" plot, which I suppose was the first season.)

    By a coincidence, I missed the first minutes of the first episode. Upon hearing the accents and upon discovering the off-beat and laconic humor, I thought : hang on, this series seems to come from Australia ! And indeed, Australia it was.

    "Jack Irish" is a pretty good thriller series with a strangely likeable and addictive hero/anti-hero. It contains a number of quirky plot twists and of funny, picturesque characters (such as a Greek chorus of old men propping up the bar and reminiscing about a long-forgotten sports legend), but it also dares to tackle serious, contemporary themes. On the whole the mix works ; I suppose mainly as a result of the casting and acting, both of which are exceptional. Many of the characters look and feel like real, living individuals one could meet in a pub, a courtroom, a self-help group for recovering addicts.

    I for one hope to watch the next seasons too.
  • caronbc1 January 2023
    The whole Jack Irish series is without doubt a winner all 'round!

    Great characters, played by great actors with great story lines in great locations.

    Jack Irish himself is a gritty, multifaceted character played brilliantly by Guy Pierce. All other cast members, no matter what size their part, play their well layered characters beautifully; Aaron Pederson, Roy Billing, Marta Dusseldorp, Damien Gavey, Kate Atkinson, Jacek Woman, Bob Franklin etc etc etc

    I can't fault it, and in my opinion, this series should have won even more awards.

    I love it all, and I hope that the makers of this brilliant series keep making more. We know these great characters so well now, and want to know them even better.

    BRING ON SERIES 4!
  • Jack and his friends are up to no good again. The last woman in his life is off to follow a story in the Phillipines, Jack is alone again and trouble always finds Jack. If it is no his horse friends, then it's his legal friends, if not them then it is the woman or women in his life ,and that usually means Jack is in for pain and broken bones.Then there are always his friends at the pub to help him find the answers and hide him from those that want to kill him or through him in jail. This season is more painful then the others because there is a bigger cross over story then before. From the jungles of the Phillipines and the story being covered there the murders and mysteries of where is " Tina" and "who and why people are being killed" Also who took Jacks money after putting it into his account. Will Jack ever find the answers before he is killed himself?
  • Very low key..and more than a bit hammy...but so nice to watch something relatable on Netflix..as a NZer or Australian..you love the European Crime..but sometimes its nice to watch something a whole lot less slick.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    Really enjoyed the movies and first two series of this excellent show. The third and final series is a lot darker and a little disappointing with the an old familiar story line of corrupt cops and a heartless racing industry. Never the less, it is well written, directed and with a fine cast. All in all an excellent series well worth a watch.
  • I really enjoyed season 3, but it was the weakest of the seasons so far.

    It was not bad, dont get me wrong, it just lacked a bit of "wow" factor.
  • If you like being a dude, then it doesn't get any better than Jack Irish. Occasional P.I. work, sweet secret hideout type house, booze, some babes here and again, some guns, lots of gambling, and shady characters of the friend and foe variety. Jack is very Irish and he knows it. You should too.
  • I really dislike the contrivance of troubled, pain in the a** kids delivering dramatic complications. I like so many things about Jack and his ensemble but both seasons are a storytelling shamble. Solid acting, good production, exotic NZ make it enjoyable enough.
  • the_nephilim711 September 2019
    I really wanted to like it but it was so boring it almost put me to sleep after only 20 minutes.
  • This is so so good, brilliantly acted, superbly filmed but the stand out is the writing. I thoroughly enjoyed the first 3 season, the little side stories, the innuendo and the typical Australian play on language made this riveting to watch. Lots of twists and turns but it all seems relatable and genuine. So.many great characters in this, opportunity for spin off's I really hope they keep producing more series. Guy Pearce is really good, bringing a genuine level of acting you don't see in TV series normal. The ensemble cast is a who's who of Australia TV with quality support acting from the younger generation. Definitely grab a wine and enjoy this series.
  • Jack Irish is one stupid mf. Kind of annoying to watch. Yep he show is slow but ok. Not the greatest but watchable.
An error has occured. Please try again.