Like many others, I really enjoy time travel/alternate reality movies. This is a tried and true formula that has worked ever since "A Christmas Carol" and "It's a Wonderful Life". Hallmark has made a bunch of really good "What if?" movies. Some of my recent favorites include "Next Stop Christmas", "Love Strikes Twice", and "Ghosts of Christmas Always". Hallmark Queen Lacey Chabert starred in another good one called "Family For Christmas". And Hallmark King Andrew Walker starred in a good one called "A Dream of Christmas."
This movie starts off with an "inspired" speech by "Harbourview College" psychology professor Lindsay Rogers who clearly loves her career. "How do we become people who always strive to be better? How can any of us live a truly inspired life? For each of us, the answers may be different. But what's important is asking the question...what gives my life meaning?"
Behind her, during the speech, is an enlarged picture of Maslow's "Hierarchy of Needs" pyramid with "self actualization" at the top. She doesn't discuss the pyramid, but it's a famous visual depiction of Maslow's theories about motivation which linked human biological needs with human psychology. Well worth a Google if you're unfamiliar with Maslow.
Shortly thereafter, while driving to meet her boyfriend for dinner, Lindsay has a phone call with "the Dean" at Yale University who offers to publish her thesis and suggests it might, somehow, become a best seller (improbable but not impossible; see Camille Paglia, whose thesis became a best-seller).
I love this exchange:
Lindsay: "Wait, you think that 'Inspired: a study in self conceptualization and its quantifiable impact on interpersonal paradigm outcomes' could be a best seller?"
Dean Jackman: "So maybe the title could use some work."
The Dean then also dangles a tenure track position as an associate professor in Yale University's psychology department. Professionally, Lindsay has hit the jackpot. That's not a small thing. The only problem: her boyfriend Jacob, played earnestly by Michael Stahl-David, wants to get married and doesn't want to leave the West Coast for the East Coast.
I thought this was well directed by Sean McNamara. The beginning features a crisply edited latte making scene at Jacob's "Caffeinated Cafe" and there are a lot of great and emotive reaction shots along the way that allow all of the actors to shine. I was also impressed with the writing by Helen Frost and Don MacLeo.
There was also some stunt casting with Christopher Lloyd as Grandpa Bob. He gets a few "wink wink" lines that were obviously intended to remind viewers of his role in Back to the Future (he did this again in "Next Stop Christmas"). I thought those were fun. This movie also features William Shatner as Nick the Coachman. Shatner is infamous for shamelessly overacting and being way too hammy in his roles. But here, he is surprisingly low key, restrained and pleasant.
Laura Soltis plays Lindsay's mom and is effective as always. She's also one of my favorite "Older Moms" in Hallmark movies along with Barbara Niven. Tess Atkins also does a lot with a little in playing Jacob's sweet coworker Becca. I felt really bad for her in the alternate reality.
The leads were both charming and believable as lifelong friends who fell in love and seemed poised for the next step (the video highlight reel was really sweet). In some ways, this was like watching a sequel to all the Hallmark movies that feature childhood and/or high school friends who reconnect, fall back in love and decide to live Happily Ever After. This movie picks up after the endings of those movies, and features what happens "After", when reality kicks in and career goals conflict.
I thought the writers presented a very honest and realistic conflict with very reasonable and legitimate alternatives. I didn't think this was an easy choice for anyone. And, thankfully, gone are the days when the woman is always and automatically forced to give up her dream job, or a place she loves, in order to have true love.
I had a few issues (why was that park worker raking a giant empty field? Millions of dollars, a mansion, and a limo to a book signing after one self help psychology book?) but overall I really enjoyed the movie and I just can't get enough of Eloise Mumford. She is easily one of my favorite Hallmark actresses.