User Reviews (39)

Add a Review

  • Warning: Spoilers
    This was a compelling drama, with the drama of a hospital in Berlin, in the last years of World War 2.

    I hadn't realised until the series was well in that many of the characters are based on real people - the head doctor Sauerbruch, Adolphe Jung, Dietrich Bonhoeffer and members of his family, and Hans von Dohnányi amongst others. This made the story much more compelling. It's good to have Wikipedia available when watching.

    The final episode with the fall of Berlin, was especially powerful.

    The use of colourised film clips from the time was well done.

    A high quality, well done series.
  • I watched the original Charite', which was focused on the "competition" between Drs. Robert Koch and his developing treatment for tuberculosis, and Emil Behring, who discovers an effective cure for diphtheria. Both series are well produced and written, and capture the "zeitgeist" of both eras represented in this series. Both series set high standards for both production and performance, but I have to give the nod to this latest installment. It backs off the melodrama a bit more than its predecessor, and gives-- what I believe-- a more clear-eyed perspective of the political times and the trials and tribulations of the German people in WW2. It scores extra points in that this perspective is viewed through the eyes of non-combatants and non-political figures in Nazi Germany. This series and "Babylon Berlin" (really waiting for the next installment of this gem) are huge leaps forward for German television, threatening to not only becoming a peer of the BBC and other British programming, but shows signs the Germans are ready to assume the role of being the class of European exporter of "small screen" production. Good stuff.
  • "Charite at War" covers the German hospital during World War II.

    The film focuses on Anni (Mala Emde), her doctor husband Arthur (Artjom Gilz), the brilliant surgeon Sauerbruch, and Anni's brother (Otto Jannik Schumann), an in-the-closet gay. Given Rule 175, homosexuals who were caught were arrested and worse.

    The group at the hospital reflects the differing views of citizens under Hitler's restrictions, some of whom display delusional thinking. Artur works with disabled children who are wards of the state as he works to develop a new vaccine. These children are eventually sent to another hospital, where Artur believes the children receive treatment, though the truth is, they are exterminated.

    Sauerbruch goes along with Hitler's restrictions, but he believes he has a duty to all patients, and that includes Jews. He himself spoke to the Minister of Justice to end the extermination of children - and believes it is no longer happening.

    Anni is a would-be doctor studying with Sauerbruch. Anni is comfortable that she and Artur have the correct genes. However, their new baby, Karin, possibly has hydrocephalus. This means she has to be reported and transferred, and that they may be sterilized. Instead, they treat the baby at home and then appeal to Sauerbruch for help. She and Artur face a crisis in their beliefs and in their marriage.

    Otto falls in love with a male attendant at the hospital. There is a young nurse after him, who presses him for a commitment before he leaves for the service. When she doesn't get it, trouble ensues.

    A cruel doctor accuses soldiers in the infirmary of faking their illness or wounded themselves, and they are sent for execution.

    Meanwhile Germany is losing the war, and everyone hopes it will be over soon. Nobody seems to like Hitler. Sauerbruch thinks he's crazy. But they all live with terror.

    Toward the end of the film, we see what Hitler sent out to fight - teenage boys. Pathetic.

    An interesting cross-section of those who are secret spies and just plain keeping secrets as they try to get through their lives and survive Hitler.

    "Charite at War" is depressing, and we see how the German people suffered. Toward the end of the war, there was no water, no supplies at the hospital, nothing, as doctors use liquor to sterilize their hands and anesthetize the patients.

    And that's what happens when someone tells you that some people are superior to others, and anything that goes wrong with the country is the fault of these lesser people.

    I'd say never forget, but it seems as though we have.
  • pandsfluck22 June 2019
    Moving, thoughtful and thought provoking. While these events were unfolding in Berlin I was in London and, briefly, a patient in the blacked out and lightly blitzed Children's Hospital, Great Ormand St. Only people of my advanced age , British as well as German, will fully understand what they are seeing. However all the youngsters can enjoy the intelligent script and fine acting.
  • bshaef-342291 August 2019
    A great WW II movie from an angle I never thought about before. I enjoyed the entire series but it was difficult watching the parts where the little kids were in their beds or being transferred. Something to think about on this hot summer day.
  • But the task is well executed. While there is some telescoping of historical events, I have a degree in history and the story line I found to be artistically effective. Acting, pacing and production values exceed expectations. And to disagree with one reviewer, the Russians were barbaric in their ending of the war. If anything, that was downplayed.
  • A very good show.

    I liked the telling of the beginnings of modern bacteriology. I had Google on the ready, to look up every new name which appeared - they were people who had a huge impact on our world. They are shown with all their faults and failings, as well as their successes.

    I was sceptical about the introduction of Arthur Conan Doyle (creator of Sherlock Holmes), which I thought was just a dramatic device, but Google showed it to be factual, and what followed on was also based on fact.

    An extremely interesting, and educational (in the good sense of the word) series.
  • Interesting series from point of view you would not think of, regarding the medical staff in the German hospitals towards the end of World War Two
  • mark-9393919 June 2019
    An excellent series that reflects the moral turmoil in a German hospital during the war.
  • Calicodreamin19 December 2020
    A great period pieces, both seasons of charite are well scripted and well acted. The characters have such depth and the storylines are compelling.
  • B244 July 2019
    On first viewing the promos for this series, I was determined not to watch it, fearing that...like so many German films in recent past...it would be filled with sensationalist and graphic wartime atrocities. When at the urging of a colleague I did give it a chance, I was pleasantly rewarded by its technical brilliance and occasional emotional depth. The medical scenes are nowhere as good as those of British or American hospital soaps, but they are in any case subordinate to a riveting drama framed by actual historical data from World War 2. The main characters are in fact based on real people, and the events more or less accurately in harmony with contemporary events. As usual, subtitles are inferior to dubbing. Simultaneous verbal and visual effects are needed to avoid losing a great deal of dramatic impact. Many subtle or ironic phrases in German go flying right past translation, especially in a rapid fire interchange like many in this story. Another minor fault is that, as in many fictional accounts of the war, too many small gratuitous references and characters from history keep popping up to impede the main narrative. But that in no way diminishes the central theme of ordinary people, non-combatants, coping with the traumatic impact of atrocities occurring all around them. Are there other lessons to be learned from witnessing a sympathetic and righteous population taken over by a cult leader in challenging times? I think so.
  • rbenford13 July 2019
    Not as good as the original Charite series.. Watchable though.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    The opening of this series was very good, and that is why I kept on watching it. However, I feel the series suffers from a lack of direction: it knows not what it wants to do. While the central concern shifts from scientific investigation of diseases and their cures to personal lives of the major characters --their love and betrayal, ambition and disgrace -- the series starts to descend into melodrama. This is unfortunate because the series deals with a prestigious real institution, and real historical doctors, some of whom later went on to win the Noble Prize.

    There are also several issues that the series picks up, only to discard them without exploration. For example, in the last episode, we are shown a "human zoo" comprising of "22 inhabitants from the Indian Subcontinent". The human zoo is conducted by the historical figure Carl Hagenbeck. Yet, he claims to have "Senegalese" and "Bengalese" people in his zoo. Needless to say, Senegal is not in the Indian Subcontinent, and there is no such people as Bengalese. The Indian people are shown to be clad in elaborate turbans and saris, and when one woman dies of pox, she gifts her nurse (who previously called her "dark as chimney" and "cannibal") an oriental-looking pendant. I think this part is very callously made, and stinks of what Edward Said would call Orientalism. Those people from the Indian subcontinent seem to function only as a source of momentary exoticism in the series, something Hagenbeck tried to do in the late 1800s.
  • As a native Berliner who still recalls the last remaining ruins of WWII, I found this Historical Drama series to be not only authentic in all aspects, but also very moving in its portrayal of individual characters. Most of the story takes place at a time where most people were certain the War was nearing its end. Despite dutifully exchanging the obligatory Hitler greeting in formal settings, many no longer shared the vision of Germany dominating the World, but instead secretly wishing for "the enemy" (namely the Americans) to finish it all, so everyone could somehow rise from the rubble.

    The legendary Charite Hospital is caught in the middle of the political turmoil, constantly deluged with ever changing "orders" from the Fuehrer. The most outstanding characters are the Hospital administrator/world-renowned surgeon Prof. Dr. Sauerbruch and his equally talented wife, who quietly aid the resistance, all the while honoring their hippocratic oath. When in one scene, directives from the highest office dictated that all doctors and nurses should receive fire arms to face the approaching allied forces, the messenger had to endure a very verbal and unmistakable refusal of such orders. "Am I to operate with a gun in my hand?"

    Quite disturbing was the fact, that some of the very young people, even school children, appeared to be so entranced by the Nazi vision, that in the face of certain death, they would nonetheless march through the streets to shoot on sight anyone who capitulates or shares any other political view. High officers knew better, and for the most part chose suicide over capture.

    A variety of character studies enhance the story. To me, the best lines of dialog came from Head Nurse Kate. With her endearing, thick Berlin dialect she would deliver the most profound and witty observations. Here are some samplings: "Child, be glad we're at war, because after it's all over, it sure will get less comfortable!' - "Whoever isn't dead yet, has only himself to blame, because there sure have been enough bombs dropped." - "Don't you act so innocent, you knew exactly what was going on!" - "Keep your head up high, even if the neck is dirty!"

    Most eye witnesses to one of the darkest hours in Germany's History are no longer with us. Through documents and the arts, we are privileged to learn and never forget this part of history. Even then, our better angels prevailed and lifted humanity up from such a deep fall. We shall live, and learn, and appreciate the suffering and the hard work of those who came before us, that our children and grandchildren may live a more fulfilled life in love and in peace.

    Television Drama just doesn't get any better than this!
  • Very well made and great character studies. There were some inaccuracies such as the setting started out in the Autumn of 1943 and and there is a discussion about heading to Africa to be with Rommel. The North African campaign was lost by the Germans and over by the Spring of that year. Many medical issues and procedures seem correct for its time, but the one doctor was doing mouth to mouth on a baby and that procedure did not come into practice until the 1950s. Perhaps that was to show the doctor was imaginative and non-conformist. An event where the doctors were treating a hemo-pneumo thorax showed the doctors first interested in removing the metal in the chest, when in fact the priority is on relieving intrathoracic pressure via a chest tube or needle decompression and then stopping bleeding and then vascular and tissue repair. Getting the bullet out is something Hollywood has been hung up on from the beginning. The doctor though, does explain why he wants to look for the metal and remove it, perhaps to appease those that would question it, but the priority was off. Anyway, the show is a must for those interested in history and/or medical shows.
  • calemero13-113-72417620 June 2019
    9/10
    Good
    A really well done series covering many aspects of the moral difficulties for the common man during he war
  • 04/20/2018 This relatively short six (6) episode series starts off slow, so be patient because the longer you watch the further you as the viewer will be drawn in. Charité is the foundation of this series and a German hospital that entwines all of the early 20thC real life characters and their ever engaging life circumstances which get woven into the storyline. All of it starts feeling like you're really watching a true to life story of today versus actors playing their parts. The factual aspects of diphtheria and tuberculosis, the cures that were tried and eventually found, become so interesting that the viewer will probably decide to research each of them, if only to be factually certain and know how close to reality this series is? Mix that in with the intertwined sub stories and now you know that you're watching something really great, alot to short in time but filled with quality of content, which is foremost to most viewers, versus length of play. After researching the series, it appears that it will be continued again next season, however all new characters will be playing, so lets hope for the best and that the second season will end up being as good or better than the first? It's a really wonderful series in my opinion. Bon Appetit
  • rbenford13 July 2019
    Watchable drama..first series is better than the second ..it has its faults but overall interesting just from a historical point of view
  • tilokaudaman7 April 2020
    The thing I found most fascinating about this series is the way normal people survive under fascist rule. The duality of being healers and having to follow the terrible laws of the Nazi regime come very much into play. The production quality is superb. It is provocative and we'll worth watching.
  • Overall, good television. There are a few points that an American audience may find cloying, but I had no problem with it. It may be too "soapy" with the romantic entanglements woven into the story. I could have done without the melodrama-- less of it anyway-- but it has to be taken into consideration this is a "continental European" drama. In many ways, this can be attributed to the timeframe of the story. Late nineteenth century European society was more heavily church dominated in that era. So, what seems like quaint, outdated and even eyerolling concerns that weigh so heavily in this story can come off as silly, in that period these were issues that strongly impacted daily life. While these subplots may seem overly dusty to most viewers, it certainly is historically appropriate. There is also the fact that this was produced with a German audience first and foremost. As I've seen in other recent German productions (Babylon Berlin; Our Fathers, Our Mothers --aka "Generation War" outside of Germany) , the romantic subplots aren't presented in quite the same fashion as they are on this side of the Atlantic. As for myself, I find it a refreshing shift in presentation.

    Production, writing and performance are all high standard. Well above what is typical German television. While it might not grab a huge audience in the U.S. because of its subtle but still distinctly different style in telling a story, I strongly encourage folks to give it a try.
  • qui_j29 June 2019
    This so full of medical inaccuracies that the scenes dealing with medical issues all become laughable after a while. The acting is amateurish as is the dialog for the script. It is however well costumed and the sets are well done. It will probably have limited appeal to a small niche audience but certainly not wide, global appeal. The politics and issues are just too local and would not be well understood, or embraced by a global audience. If you are a Soap Opera fan, it will keep you engaged.
  • Because I'm bilingual I was able to watch this streaming from (I think it was ARD). This was such a great mini-series, and hopefully it might make it to a more global market. I didn't really know what to expect when I started watching this, but was very pleasantly surprised. It takes place in Charitê hospital in Berlin...during the time when Diptheria and other vaccines were being researched and developed. It is a drama, so there are love and power struggles as well as some insights into the period. Highly recommend, maybe a major streaming service can buy it. Educational, intriguing, and entertaining. Recommend.
  • kiwes85 January 2019
    A doctor friend recommended this series and what an enjoyment watching it has been! Battles amongst the 3 future Nobel price laureates, brave nurses and doctors, questionable scientific methods (consent, privacy, standardization of drugs), and a lot more just keep you begging for more at the end of each chapter thanks to a brilliant combination of real and fictional characters and events. Free from obvious PC sociopolitical agenda, this series tells things how they were at the time, with just the right dose of fairytaling, which is what movies are all about.
  • The excellent actors and actresses, the story writing, atmosphere and presentation - while having its roots in a true historic scenery - make this show to one of the best, if not the best German Drama Television production since years!

    For me as a Composer and Orchestrator I of course always take a closer look at the score as well, and the music is simply as fantastic; last but not least also as they hired a real ensemble. The themes are highly memorable, with arrangement and orchestration being simply fantastic. Same goes for the sound design and SFX.

    The only thing I rather disliked was the added stock footage in season 2, which was shot in real Nazi Germany. Though it was coloured, it felt yet slightly out of place. But this is complaining on a high comfort level.

    In my opinion a must-see for anyone who enjoys dramatic TV shows, with both seasons being exciting from on the first, till the final second!
  • drsachinppatel27 October 2019
    A Brilliant Masterpiece. Would love to see more seasons.
An error has occured. Please try again.