User Reviews (212)

Add a Review

  • This was a really nice hidden gem, why have I never heard of this before?!

    It was a bit of a slow burn to begin with but it was more so just exposition that was still intriguing. By the third act it was an instant banger, loved the multiple twists, was not expecting most of it.

    The acting was solid across the board. It was very well cast and as an ensemble I thought they did great.

    I could have done with a bit more horror/ spook, and the ending was a little corny but I still liked it. Weirdly enough this is kinda a... feel good horror? I know, that sounds ridiculous. Lol Idk how this isn't more well known or maybe I've been living under a rock but I would definitely recommend.
  • I absolutely loved the movie despite some predictable elements. But the acting is phenomenal. George Mackay just lives the character of Jack, its hard not to shed tears for him, feel his anxieties and emotions. It mainly deals with the trauma and challenges kids have to face when a parent is extremely abusive. Even if they find a way to escape the situation, the societal laws and challenges make it difficult to survive. Jack is the protector of his 3 siblings from his abusive father and society which wants to separate them as his mother has died. The whole movie is on Jack's fight for survival which at one point threatens his existence. The 3 other kids were fantastic and Anya Taylor Joy is again perfect as Jack's girlfriend who loves him unconditionally.

    However if you are easily disturbed and are in a low mood, please avoid as it does affect you.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    Don't get me wrong, this film is far from perfect, but with an open mind and a pure enthusiasm for art, Marrowbone will definitely surprise you as a imperfect masterpiece.

    To keep this review spoiler free, I cannot delve too deep into the plot or development of the characters, which sadly makes it hard to describe this film, as it truly is one of those unique films that completely surprises you, just when you think you have a grip on what's going on. To give you an idea, after watching this movie, the film ["Split"2017] came to mind. If you found that movie intriguing or in any way exciting to watch, this film will definitely have you asking for more.

    If you're not into horrors and the trailer gave you the idea that this is some sort of "scary" movie with spirits and demons cursed upon a family, it really isn't. In fact, there is no ghosts or mythical beings in this film, it's just a pure chair-gripping horror/adventure movie with great storytelling and immensely superb acting.

    That brings me to my final summary of why you should watch this film. If you're purely into acting, the fine art of performing well behind camera, you will definitely admire this film as a pure masterpiece. All the actors were extremely impressive at their role, each portraying emotion and understanding of their character at such depth. That being said, George MacKay, playing the role of "Jack", were definitely on a level of his own and in my opinion, deserved a best actor nomination. He truly brought his character alive with his complete understanding of the raw emotions that had be precisely portrayed.

    It is sad to see how such a great film with admirable storytelling and top class acting can be so greatly underrated. In my opinion, this film deserves no less than a 8/10.
  • Right from the start I was reminded of the 1967 film Our Mother's House, which featured strange kids dealing with strange situations and even stranger parents. The similarities remain, but the tone of this film is much different, starting off as a slow, almost idyllic dream and veering off into a nightmare. In fact, it's almost too slow at the beginning, and deceptively so, since once the real story begins to be told, it picks up speed and never stops moving. You'll also guess the twist early on, then you'll have to guess again, and then guess again, but guessing and being wrong a couple of times is a lot better than guessing and being right the first time. The horror elements are refreshingly not slash and dash slice and dice gore galore, but more of the growing dread variety, so despite the feeling of familiarity and the slow start, this movie is worth seeing.
  • If you haven't seen WHERE THE LILIES BLOOM, see it first, and follow up with MARROWBONE. The only glitch is that there was no U.S. homeschooling in 1969, when the story is set, yet homeschooling is mentioned. Other than that, this isn't a film you haven't seen before, with or without its non-Gothic predecessor mentioned above and in the title of this review, but it is a film that you won't mind seeing again. The twists are usual, but, fans of the classic slow-burn, there are NO jump scares. No, not one. And that, for me at least, is what sets the films apart from the B-flicks.
  • SPOILER: Four young siblings living alone in a big old house are plagued by a sinister presence which may or may not be real.

    I have almost completely finished watching horror because most of it seems to be copy or variation of something else, and most of them seem to prefer cheap thrills (sudden noises, jumps etc) to the proper world and character building which is a necessary base for any kind of good story.

    "Marrowbone" is derivative of other works, too, but has promise to be more than just a copycat. It concentrates on characters, environment and the atmosphere early on, slowly but steadily raising and holding the suspense, so we may have reason to care about what happens next.

    In this way, it's similar to the horror guru Stephen King's style, although written and directed by some Sergio G. Sánchez.

    it's the Spaniard's feature-length directorial debut but the man has written screenplays before, notably for J.A. Bayona's "El orfanato" ("The Orphanage", 2007) and natural catastrophe drama "Lo imposible" ("The Impossible", 2012).

    The first half of this slow-burning 111 minute joint is promising indeed. Finally, a rare horror with its own clear strong voice, I thought, already comparing it to the best I've seen such as M. Night Shyamalan's "The Sixth Sense" or Alejandro Amenábar's "The Others".

    The dark, moody atmosphere is effective - genuinely creepy - and there are no cheap tricks to "prove" anything to shallower part of audience who would ask for fast thrills.

    If I remember correctly, the first "unnatural" moment arrives late, maybe around 50 minutes in, which is also similar to King's best horror.

    Sánchez is able to use well-known cliches well, and the movie looks amazing in its old-postcard-way. I would give the result a much higher score were the story deeper.

    It is understandable that the author only had two hours, which is not a lot. But the development of event does feel shallow and jumpy, and when the revelations about what's really happening start to arrive, everything turns weak cliched fast.

    Why do so many horror movies use twists and "surprises" in the end anyway? By now, it would be refreshing to just enjoy a story well told, as "Marrowbone" during the first hour.

    The experience is less about actors and more about atmosphere with everything fitting neatly into the author's vision, but the cast has done their best indeed, as stated above. It's not to be taken granted in indie horrors, you know.

    Everybody makes you feel something by the power of their performance, be it sympathy, dislike or else. In a way, it turns out to be a good ensemble movie as well.

    It's an indie effort, so there's a slim chance you would know any of the cast by name, but they do reat job, even the small one. So here they are: George MacKay, Charlie Heaton ("Stranger Things"), Mia Goth, Matthew Stagg, Anya Taylor-Joy, Kyle Soller, Tom Fisher.

    All in all, prepare for likable and mostly effective movie. It's not gonna offer much for seasoned horror watchers but if you have not seen this kind of stuff (many times) already, this may be the first to make you interested in horror movies in general.
  • On the one hand its beautifully made the cinematography, direction acting and sound design is great.

    Where the movie is let down sadly is a frankly underdeveloped story which fizzles out after the predictable tweest at the end that would make M Night Shamaylan blush.

    Is it worth a watch? Absolutely if you liked the Orphanage and want a bit of a different horror movie thats more of a slow boil then a balls to the wall action horror movie like the over rated It remake.

    The ending isnt the weakest part of the movie by the way its the twist before it, the ending itself is charming and quite nice but as other reviewers have said it is a definite weak point of the story.
  • This enjoyable and interesting horror movie deals with a beloved mother : Nicole Harrison , a young man : George McKay and his three younger brothers : Mia Goth as the second oldest sibling, Charlie Holden as the third oldest and Mathew Stags as the younger, al of them decide to escape from a previous location and move to a far, detached mansion in the countryside. But this abandoned place is not what it seems, as it holds a terrible secret between its walls . There the brothers fear to be separated and that's why they keep a hidden dark event in order to remain get together. Along the way the oldest brother falls in love for a young girl : Anya Taylor-Joy . Then they attempt to protect themselves when they are plagued by a creepy presence who sunddenly shows up at home.

    A nice Spanish horror movie with terror , scary deeds, thrills, chills and a peculiar love story. An eerie, horrifying film with sinister happenings in which a family hides a ghastly secret into a sprawling manor. This is a decent horror movie with decent international cast and an awesome technician team . As it displays a colorful and evocative cinematography by Xavi Gimenez who has photographed notorious films such as Red Lights, Libertador, Agora, Transsiberian , The Machinist and Intacto. Being shot on gorgeous locations in Asturias, and Tarrassa, Barcelona, Spain . It packs a frightening and suspenseful musical score from Fernando Velazquez who has composed successes as Crimson Peak, The Orphange, The impossible, Sanctuary, Mama, Out of the dark ,Zipi and Zape, Legado en huesos, Hercules , 8 Apellidos Vascos, among others.

    The motion picture well produced by the prestigious Jose Antonio Bayona and Belén Atienza was competently directed by Sergio G. Sanchez. He is an important writer/filmmaker who wrote The orphanage and The impossible for J. A. Bayona, being this Marrowbone his film debut. Rating 7.5/10. Better than average. Well worth watching. Essential and indispensable seeing for horror movie fans.
  • S_Soma22 February 2018
    Warning: Spoilers
    Opening Scenes Preview:

    MARROWBONE opens with a narrating voice, who we soon discover is the character Jack, describing the arrival of his family at their new home. We are told that they have come a very long way, across an ocean, and that they have endured many difficulties to arrive at what they hope will be a safe haven for them. There are 5 in the family; Jack, the eldest, Billy, Jane, Sam, the youngest who seems to be about five years old, and Rose, their mother. The choice of this home was not an accident; we are told that it was Rose's childhood home and has been standing empty for 30 years.

    Apparently the family's life to this point has been horrific because Rose draws a line in the dust on the floor and proclaims that once they cross it, their lives will begin anew in all ways and that they will forget their former life altogether. They even change their surname to MARROWBONE.

    But we are given to know that the past may not allow itself to be forgotten. There are references to a "he" and a "him" that casts a shadow over the family and their new life, and there is the possibility that "he" could become more than a terrifying possibility.

    But the family settles in to their new home and life soon seems idyllic. Wherever this house is, the shore of the sea is close at hand. Even though they have no close neighbor, they do make a new friend, a young girl named Allie, a very friendly kindred spirit, who immediately seems to become "one of the family". The carefree, sunny summer days slide by.

    Sadly, there is more than one shadow upon the family. Rose has an unnamed disease, and the trip from England has taken her last bit of strength to fight against it. As she lies upon her death bed, and in private, she gives Jack her last instructions and important points on how to care for the family in her absence. Rose is to be buried in the garden at a place she has already specified. Jack must do his best to keep the family secret and hidden until he turns 21 or they will be split apart. Have a safe place in case "he" finds them. Lastly, there is a tin container holding a large sum of money that Rose took from the shadowy "he". Jack is shocked at this last item because Rose apparently lied in court to keep it. But before he can object he sees that Rose, his mother, is gone. The last of her instructions Jack reads aloud to the family from a note left with the tin of money.

    The four children proclaim an oath of unbreakable family bonds literally over the body of their mother, swearing that "nothing and no one" will ever be permitted to tear the family apart.

    But as luck would have it, not long after Rose's death, the terrifying "he" becomes far more substantial. He announces his presence by firing a shot through a window next to Jane from all the way across a meadow. In stark terror, Jane shrieks for Jack.

    But in the very next scene, which we are told is 6 months later, everything seems to be fine, surprisingly. Aside from an annoying legal representative whose pointy-headed inquisitiveness perpetually threatens to "out" the hiding family, things seem to be going surprisingly well.

    Although...

    There is now talk of a ghost in the house. The mirrors are all covered. There is something that menaces from above the ceiling...

    Review:

    Very surprising to me is the fact that this is a Spanish-made movie through and through. It's filming locations were Terrassa, Barcelona, Catalonia, Spain, and all of the credits and any subtitles are entirely in Spanish. For example, "six months later" appears on the screen as "seis meses más tarde". And yet the entire context of the movie is mid to late sixties America, all the dialogue is entirely in English, and absolutely no dubbing has taken place. As far as I can tell, the depicted Americana is pretty much flawless. First time I've ever seen something like this.

    While others have complained of the lack of originality in MARROWBONE, as I have mentioned in other reviews, this is never a problem for me. Considering how many thousands of supernatural/horror pictures have been made by now, it's my position that it's utterly unreasonable to expect true novelty/originality of a horror picture at this point. There are very few completely novel roller coasters or firework shows in my experience, and yet I still like to ride them/see them. A well-done horror picture is a thing of beauty even if it can't be completely new. And to those who incessantly prattle about "originality", if you insist upon limiting your sense of pleasure to only new experiences, do make a point of never getting married. You will be sharply disappointed.

    So, no, you will see nothing entirely original in MARROWBONE, but the execution of these tropes was so well done that I didn't catch on until late in the game. Additionally, there are many plot points that specifically support some of the more difficult-to-believe story elements, in contrast to the many horror pictures whose plot lines collide with their tropes, leaving large holes. When you find yourself disbelieving the lengths to which Jack will go to keep the family "together", one way or another, think back to the admonitions of Rose on her deathbed and the solemn swearing ceremony over her dead body. Jack truly was obsessed with keeping the family together. In whatever way he could...

    Early on in the picture I remember thinking that the character Allie, while not exactly beautiful, most certainly has a face and personality that would be virtually impossible not to love. The fact that the very, very ending of the movie is incredibly sweet and utterly unrealistic is entirely in keeping with that thought. Exceptionally charming, I also thought sadly, "Well, THAT would never happen."

    If utter originality is NOT your reason for living and you are able to enjoy a delicious dish more than once, you should give MORROWBONE a watch. It's exceptionally well done and has a heart wrenching, bittersweet ending.
  • Tweetienator3 August 2022
    Well produced, nice cinematography, fine cast - Marrowbone is really a nice watch, but for sure the twist is not as unique or surprising as some claim. Anyway, if you like to watch dark twisted tales, this one belongs on your list.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    This movie made me feel so conflicted. On one hand, I'm a sucker for a beautiful location, plucky kids and heartfelt narratives dealing with family togetherness and independence. I'm also a proponent of mental health awareness. It's high time we de-stigmatize and humanize and validate the suffering people experience at the hand of long-misunderstood phenomena that cause real pain and suffering. Too many horror films demonize people with mental illness and it's time for that to end.

    On the other hand, I'm a person who has little patience for filmmakers who underestimate their audience or rely on trickery and manipulation to make their point or tell their story in a way which fits their definition of "horror". Which this film has in spades. Its final, admittedly touching point, isn't made until the final 15 minutes. It felt rushed. It was confusing. It was clichéd. And that's too bad because it had all the right pieces to be something really amazing. As it is, it feels more profound than it was because it ends on such a sentimental high note. Hence many of the positive reviews you see here.

    The first half hour of the movie is engaging and emotional, and the story is easy to follow. You're introduced to a lovely family whom you want to see succeed. Tragedy strikes. Motivation is introduced via villains, cute kids and animal friends, and intriguing plot devices. Things begin to fall apart around the middle when disjointed tricks of editing to confuse the viewer into believing something is happening that isn't really happening. They're trying to get you to see things from the protagonist's perspective, but that message comes too little too late.

    And all potential falls apart. Whatever message was trying to find a voice gets lost in translation.

    Realistically, one movie cannot possibly be all things to all socially-relevant issues and invested audiences, but I feel like it's not hard to find a bridge to join two concepts like what this film is trying to marry which is family, acceptance, love, safety, and coinciding mental illness. There's a lot to unpack here, but the editing is like a baggage handler who sends your bags to Hawaii while you're off to England; you may have fun on your trip but you're just not gonna have what you need for the journey.
  • I have watched this movie with zero expectations, If i'm honest I was just looking for an ok movie to watch on a Saturday night, but this movie was a lot more of that. To begin with the plot kept me in the edge of my seat during the whole movie, also it has an amazing set of characters that were brightly played by all the actors/actresses despite, in some cases, the young age. This is an unforgettable movie that will make your eyes go wet. I will totally recommend this movie.
  • andrewchristianjr19 November 2023
    Strong performances, conveying the fear, terror, and isolation that their characters are feeling. The film is visually stunning, with beautiful shots of the English countryside. The Marrowbone house is especially eerie, with its dark corridors and hidden rooms. The movie is also very well-paced, building up the tension and suspense until the final, heart-stopping moments, although it does become very confusing unless you watch carefully.

    Strong performances, conveying the fear, terror, and isolation that their characters are feeling. The film is visually stunning, with beautiful shots of the English countryside. The Marrowbone house is especially eerie, with its dark corridors and hidden rooms. The movie is also very well-paced, building up the tension and suspense until the final, heart-stopping moments, although it does become very confusing unless you watch carefully.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    'Marrowbone' is not your typical haunted house tale. Instead, this is a beautifully told story. It doesn't rely on loads of jump scares to keep you awake, although it does have some very effective jump scares.

    Firstly, the acting. Wow, great! The actors are really good and I believed them every step of the way. I felt their agony, joy, hurt, etc. The visual effects were also very good. Some scenes were downright creepy. The film has a few back stories, though, and during the final act they jump backwards and forwards in time, showing these scenes simultaneously. This can be a bit confusing, but if you put your mind to it, it is quite easy to follow. I'm just not sure why they opted for this method.

    The twist ending is interesting and unexpected. It reminded me a bit of 'The Others', starring Nicole Kidman. Ok, now here's some spoilers. I have some issues with the father being locked up in the attic. Being locked up for 6 months and presumed dead, he was remarkably strong still. Wouldn't he have cried out for help? We only occasionally heard him via means of footsteps, creaking floors, etc, but a man being locked up for so long would be desperate to escape and wouldn't have been so passive. If he was too weak due to hunger or thirst, I could understand it, but - as mentioned - he looked quite powerful still when he made his appearance towards the end. Just saying.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    The family featured are from England, the husband is an evil person, they flee to the USA for safety and to claim an inherited property, which includes a rather large homestead in bad need of maintenance. (Actually filmed in Spain.)

    The mother is sick and before she dies tells the kids to keep it a secret, bury her in the garden, all stay together until the oldest, George MacKay as Jack, turns to a legal age to be the head of the family.

    This is not a straightforward story, it is clear from the start that strange things are going on but only hints at what. When it all comes together during the last 30 minutes or so we see two parallel stories, one in real time and one some months earlier, that explains exactly what happened.

    The movie also has Anya Taylor-Joy as Allie who works in the local town's public library, she and Jack become friends then much more. I enjoy movies she is in, she is a good actress and has such interesting, exotic looks.

    Interesting movie but you have to pay attention to everything. I found it on the Kanopy site via my public library subscription, I streamed it via ROKU. My wife skipped.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    A mother and three children flee an abusive patriarch and move to a remote rural home. While there, strange events begin to occur while dark secrets seem to hover in the background.

    This gothic film is one which I felt improved as it went on. By the finale, once the twist ending had slotted into place, it made you reconsider what you had just seen and realise that the fabric of the narrative was more complex and layered than previously realised. It later becomes apparent that the narrative is very fragmented and that the story is in a large part one from the perspective of the unreliable narrator. I like movies like this, which can be regarded as puzzles, with pieces not yet in place, or completely missing. Consequently, The Secret of Marrowbone is a very worthwhile film if you appreciate this kind of thing too.
  • I didn't know much about this movie when I rented it except that it was considered a "horror" movie. And in some of the reviews, they said it was more like a thriller. I wish I wouldn't have known what genre this movie was listed under. To me, a horror movie is bloody violence, etc and a thriller is a scary movie where you're tense or you jump when something unknown jumps out at you. I waited the entire movie for any of those things to happen and it never came through. This was a drama. One of the type of dramas where it keeps your interest throughout and it's an alright movie. I would say it's one of those movies where you watch it on a Sunday when you're having a lazy day and not much is on TV or Netflix.
  • filippomedioli14 November 2020
    The finale, not only ruins a fairly enjoyable and suspenseful movie, but gives a really wrong message. MENTAL HEALTH ISSUES SHOULD BE FOLLOWED BY SPECIALISTS AND LOVE CANNOT CURE A DISEASE. Mental health awareness out there. Be safe people
  • Warning: Spoilers
    It was a heartbreaking movie to watch. Which is what makes it worth watching. I liked the plot and the performances. No jump scares anywhere but lots of creepy vibes. However, there are a number of shortcomings of this movie that makes it a little less enjoyable. First of all, if the father was a murderer who was hunting for his family, why would the mother take them back to her ancestral home? Surely the father would know of her maiden name and her childhood home. This was extremely flimsy plot point. Of course he found them in merely 6 months. This is the first place anyone would've looked. Then, they didn't build the story properly. They should've shown more flashbacks and given more details. A lot of things were left unexplained.
  • Many horror movies like using a similiar constellation. An outcast house, scenes in the dark and some kind of monster. This is also the case on this one.

    But in this movie things aren't as the camera tells us. I was in fact really suprised by the plot twists this movie takes and I think they did fit well with the story.

    The actors were great and so is the directing! The timing on some scenes is fantastic!
  • Warning: Spoilers
    There are parts of this film that create tension and suspense. But overall, the movie harkens more to a psychological thriller or dramatic story than anything else.

    First and foremost, the acting is superb all around. The pacing, while slow at times, is necessary to the story and shouldn't disappoint. The 'twist' ending is not all that revelatory, but sad nonetheless. Leading up to it, I found myself hoping it wouldn't turn out the way I thought it might. The cinematography is great as well.

    In my eyes, there are a few issues with the film.

    1. Place in time. The movie takes place in 1969, though there are parts, especially near the beginning that seemed to depict a time that could've been up to ten years earlier.

    2. Sound editing. This is one of those films where certain actors' monologues can be quite low in sound. This is unfortunate and such a distraction.

    3. Animal death. I lose appeal for a horror/thriller film the minute the killing of an animal takes place. It rarely does anything to further a story and I find it in bad taste. Plus, the way it happened in this movie was terrible. It's all I keep thinking about and I want to like the overall picture more, instead. But, I can't.

    4. Surprise, surprise! What kills most cannot kill me! It is absurd to think a man can be stabbed through the throat and, not only survive without medical treatment. But to also be able to carry out the deeds that occurred afterward, AND survive with no issue, for months without said medical care? Preposterous!

    5. Casting. I believe the three eldest children were in their twenties during filming and it shows on at least the guys, especially Billy. That actor, sad to say, looked about 30.

    Aside from the small issues I raised above, the movie is pretty good. Devastating. Worth a watch for sure.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    The plot synopsis promised an interesting supernatural horror/thriller, but what do we get instead? The usual let down where the "ghost" turns out to be a very real person, plus a cliché "twist" where the protagonist turns out to be schizophrenic and only imagining his family members to be alive. I hate these movies that trick you like that. 3 points instead of 2only because the imagery was nice.
  • Marrowbone is best described as horror drama movie. Although the twist in the end has been used in many other movies, but the story is such beautiful one. I like all the characters in it, Jack, Bill, Sam, the sister (her name I forgot), Allie, Tom, the father & the mother, their acting are very convincing. The scenery in the small town / village is so adorable (I live in the city, as city can be boring sometimes, so maybe this movie is my weekend getaway) too.

    Whoever the director is, at least she/he is smart enough to tell a story which doesn't need lots of CGI (compared to ugly Justice League -> bad story & too much cheap CGI), but always rely on the power of the characters & the plot.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    While the editing and script pacing is a little weird, this is a fair attempt at making a speculative fiction piece that is both creepy and odd. It was enjoyable enough, and all the actors were superb, but the way the story unfolds is a little clunky. There are definitely too many endings when what I would have liked to see is some more time spent with Allie getting to know the family, and the setup. There's only one brief scene that could have been played out instead of the unnecessary scene with the doctor at the end *we get it, no need to spell it out, this is not the end of Psycho*. This film probably needed one more round of polishing on the script before filming, because it does have a quality of OCD tying up of threads at the end, and it's really not necessary to be so exacting about it all! Also felt Allie was not really built up to be that in love with Jack. They'd only met a few times, and we didn't see any evidence they were anything but casual friends that snog.

    Note: This film does not pass the Bechdel Test. Both female characters could not exist, and the film would carry on, because the film is NOT told from Allie's POV, not sure what she's in it for really. Jane's a hatstand in peril. Oh, and the mother, who has two short scenes. Could just be not in it too. The woman in the shop could be not in it. Girls need to be more than the living being that needs protecting or kissing. See Beast or The Village for notes on how to do girls in horror.

    Still prefer this to most other movies out, but I don't want to see the script dangling out the back.
  • This movie is boring and way overrated I thought the synopsis sounded good and never watched a trailer so I was expecting a decent movie. Unfortunately I was disappointed by this slow moving long boring film that I am still questioning why its classified horror. Jack Ketchum's The Girl Next Door is far more horrific than this and its not under the horror genre. I don't know what the hype is for this all I can say is don't believe the rating and if you are watch with the lowest standard for movies and you might enjoy it but I expected a good movie and boy was I wrong.
An error has occured. Please try again.