Got this in a holiday sale because I love adventure games with strong narratives (TLOU 1&2, Uncharted series, Horizon series, Tomb Raider, Spider-Man 1&2, Star Wars Jedi series, Ghost of Tsushima, RDR 1&2, etc.) I saw reviews fawning over PT's historical horror-fiction narrative and comparing to other games in the "caretaker and escort" subgenre like TLOU and GoW, so I was excited!
All that said, I'm on Chapter 14 (out of 17) and feel compelled to write my 1st videogame review on IMDB as a disclaimer for those still considering buying. In my opinion, PT is no where near the standards of the games I listed above.
I understand Asobo is smaller than most "commercially successful" studios in the industry, so the music and landscape are impressive for a team of 40 developers...but the clumsy traversal+aiming mechanics, lazy dialogue, lighting issues, and many poor-developed level designs are very distracting. Which is a shame because the setting and the relationship development of the two main characters has a lot of potential. Even some allies have charming personalities, but under the surface, they're just stereotypical plot devices. The young voice actors did the best they could with the below-average writing in their dialogue.
I've played other recent adventure games from smaller studios (like Firewatch and Stray) and the difference is those managed to have developed characters and game mechanics in addition to a compelling story...which made those fun to play instead of feeling like a tiresome chore to get from one level to the next. I made it to chapter 14 (out of 17 total) and am considering quitting and watching the rest of the story in another player's video walkthrough because I don't have anymore patience or excuses left in me to keep playing.
Lastly, the lack of custom options or accessibility *for a 2019 game* is unacceptable given the amount of money the studio still expects from players for this.