Primetime Emmy Awards (2018)

Primetime Emmy [Winner]

Outstanding Directing for a Variety Special

Glenn Weiss

Primetime Emmy [Nominee]

Outstanding Variety Special (Live)

Michael De Luca
Jennifer Todd
Rob Paine
Jimmy Kimmel

Primetime Emmy [Nominee]

Outstanding Production Design for a Variety Special

Derek McLane
Alana Billingsley
Kristen Merlino

Primetime Emmy [Nominee]

Outstanding Lighting Design/Lighting Direction for a Variety Special

Robert A. Dickinson
Travis Hagenbuch
Michael Berger
Andy O'Reilly
Patrick Boozer
Ben Green

Primetime Emmy [Nominee]

Outstanding Music Direction

Harold Wheeler

Primetime Emmy [Nominee]

Outstanding Sound Mixing for a Variety Series or Special

Paul Sandweiss
Kristian Pedregon
Thomas Vicari
Marc Repp
Tom Pesa
Patrick Baltzell
Christian Schrader
John Perez
Pablo Munguia
Mike Parker

Primetime Emmy [Nominee]

Outstanding Technical Direction, Camerawork, Video Control for a Limited Series, Movie or Special

Kenneth Shapiro
Eric Becker
John Pritchett
Terrance Ho
Keith Winikoff
Guy Jones
Bob DelRusso
Dave Eastwood
Ralph Bolton
David Carline
Jay Kulick
Danny Webb
Shaun Harkins
Garrett Hurt
Tore Livia
Allen Merriweather
Lyn Noland
Mark Whitman
Freddy Frederick
George Prince
Rob Balton
Danny Bonilla
Rob Palmer
David Plakos
Easter Xua

Art Directors Guild (2019)

Excellence in Production Design Award [Winner]

Variety, Reality or Event Special

Derek McLane
Alana Billingsley
Kristen Merlino
Margaux Lapresle
Erica Hemminger
Yigit Isik
Kyle Courter

GALECA: The Society of LGBTQ Entertainment Critics (2019)

Dorian Award [Nominee]

TV Musical Performance of the Year

Keala Settle

Dorian Award [Nominee]

TV Musical Performance of the Year

Sufjan Stevens

Online Film & Television Association (2018)

OFTA Television Award [Nominee]

Best Reality or Non-Fiction Program

OFTA Television Award [Nominee]

Best Individual Host or Panelist in a Reality or Non-Fiction Program

Jimmy Kimmel

OFTA Television Award [Nominee]

Best Direction of a Reality or Non-Fiction Program

OFTA Television Award [Nominee]

Best Writing of a Reality or Non-Fiction Program

OFTA Television Award [Nominee]

Best Production Design in a Non-Series