The Detectives (2018–2020) User Reviews (8)

True crimes narrated by the actual investigators and re-enacted by bona fide actors

[Ed-Shullivan · 8/10 · 23 March 2018]

This episodic approach to detailing real Canadian murders/crimes combines documented actual crimes that are brought to life by the real investigators who solved these murders that took place across the Canadian boundaries. Sometimes using actual newsreel footage of the actual crime scenes and then brought to life by the actors/actresses who re-enact the investigators steps in solving the crimes, in some cases that took years and/or decades to solve.

The twist to this documentary series is that one of the lead detectives who actually worked and/or assisted in solving the crime and ensuring the criminal(s) were eventually imprisoned their stories are narrated by the real detectives and the actors/actresses re-enact the investigations in a summary fashion capturing the highlights which break each case open over the one hour episode.

Obviously the court cases would have taken months or even years to eventually conclude and reach a conviction for murder(s) so the producers and directors were under great pressure to encapsulate the actual crime(s), the victims and the perpetrators stories into a comprehensive and factual story line which they accomplished with exceptional results. Some of these actual crimes I recall when they happened and how horrific some of these murderers were. Once again, the producers/writers/directors provided a well balanced storyline without abusing the viciousness of some of these crimes by glorifying the perpetrators, and sticking to the factual evidence.

It is an excellent series blending the real investigators describing the period of time the crimes took place, their victims and how they solved the murders, and then we get to view some of the actual newsreel footage as the actors walk us through the highlights of the crime solving techniques used to solve the crimes. In closing each episode the writers provide a summary of what punishment the convicted murderers actually received and where they are serving their prison term(s).

I give the series a strong 8 out of 10 for an excellent documentary series that blends newsreel footage, the actual investigators narrating their investigations and then quality actors engaging in the re-enactment of the investigation and summarizing the resulting criminal conviction(s).

Surprisingly well done documentary series

[gdump · 8/10 · 8 March 2018]

Each episode in this series is a reenactment of a major Canadian crime.

I usually find productions like this (e.g. The First 48) to be dry and fairly uninteresting, but the makers have managed to capture the feel of the investigations as well as the facts. I think that this is because this series uses quality Canadian actors. The production values are also very good.

Great Series

[jduyrhfngj · 9/10 · 25 March 2018]

I have to say for a Canadian developed, produced, acted, and directed series, this is about as good as it gets. It stars some of the best, and most recognizable, Canadian actors. To have someone of the stature of Michael Ironside really adds a lot of credibility to the series - even though he only appears in one episode. Hugh Dillon is no slouch either. And to boot it's a CBC series. One of the best they've produced in years. I'm only through the first four episodes, my favourites being 1&3, so far. I really hope they do a season two, and more...

The very first 9 I've EVER given....it's that good!

[Pizzaowner · 9/10 · 17 April 2019]

This show is absolutely extraordinary.....it rivals 48 hours but is paced in a very Canadian way with no fake dramatic build-up. It covers all the most well-known cases in Canadian crime and deals with them is a most interesting and informative way. Narrated and featuring the actual detectives active on the cases it also stars some OUTSTANDING Canadian actor and actresses. I simply cannot praise this show enough from the high production values to the actors and the cases chosen. At the end of each case we hear the resolution and if that is not topical enough, their real names are given as are the cities so internet verification is always possible. Perhaps the BEST true-crime series I have ever seen. Thanks for making it and I hope it continues for more seasons. VERY highly recommended.

HOORAY! CBC

[jayg-94128 · 10/10 · 26 March 2020]

An exceptionally well rounded CBC show based on real life crimes. I realize that there are a limited number of shows produced each season but I'm hoping that "The Detectives" season could be longer. Barring longer seasons my next wish is that this series will continue for a few more years to come.

For a cbc show...it's great

[coolcanuck-85580 · 9/10 · 2 October 2021]

Very well done. For being a Canadian show I'm actually proud to say, WTG CBC for making a quite enjoyable mystery documentary.

Best true crime out there

[carnagecarney · 9/10 · 18 March 2021]

CBC is really on a roll the last few years fantastic original programming - this show being no exception and a fabulous addition to high-quality true crime dramas.

Great production - HIGHLY recommend.

Much better than the average true crime show

[EPMD57 · 9/10 · 7 June 2023]

I like a lot about this series.

They got the actual detectives from the cases to talk through the investigations. I felt this gave the show a weightier impact than had a narrator presented everything.

The tone was very professional -- cases were neither sensationalized nor presented as entertainment. It's tricky to get the tone just right with a show like this, but they did.

The reenactments were appropriately presented and well-acted. Some similar shows would overdo it on the suspense and try to turn everything into a horror movie. This show resisted that temptation and merely stuck to what I assume are the facts.

I would love it if CBC produced more seasons. I raced through the first three seasons in less than a week.