They could have swapped sorority for glee club for all the difference it made to the plot. First off, something positive: I love that house. Way more believable than the McMansions that do not match the careers or lifestyles of the owners.
OK, that's done. How dumb is Aya? She just takes Taryn's word about the sorority as gospel. Surely she has "sisters" in New York that she could have asked about Taryn. Helping her with a meal and some words of encouragement, sure, but beyond that, get real. They're also not talking one bit about the sorority, which would have obviously caught Taryn in a lie. There's still no way in normal conversation that it wouldn't have come up.
Some silly stuff. How did she mess with the dramatic client's brakes in a grocery store parking lot in broad daylight? How did she know where the client would be? Do people just know how to tamper with brakes?
The look on Aya's face when she meets Steve and realizes she's let a nut into her life is everything. It's the look of a person who just got smacked in the face w/their own stupidity. She bears responsibility for everything that is transpiring. Even after everything, including being told Steve was killed and knowing something happened to her roomie, she won't connect the dots. Even when a trusted friend reveals that Taryn is not a sister, she still won't accept reality. She's almost too dumb to live. I get tired of protags doing their notGoogle searches near the end of the movie when any normal person would have done that straightaway. Honestly, Aya's aunt should tell her to find another place to live, since she can't be trusted to not invite psychotic strangers to stay with her. And poor Steve....this might be the most played straight Lifetime warning of "don't stick your thing in crazy."
Taryn's body count was too high and sloppy for her to get away. She didn't even change her hair! How is there are there no manhunt for ya know, a killer going on? The age gap between Aya, Taryn, and then Sarah doesn't seem large enough. The makeup in this movie is really heavy bc I was shocked to see Aya is only two years younger than me.
So many recognizable faces. I recognized Lily from Y&R (not a fan, but she's ok here). I also recognized Molly (GH) and Kate, I think, from DAYS. Ironically, some of the sillier elements of this movie are totally plots that soaps would use, so I guess it was just another day for this cast. The villain's actress was very good at playing delusional to the point of being dangerous and unpredictable.
Good grief, the ending. Taryn puts on a convincing performance claiming to be abused....why not help her get to a shelter?! What a dumb old lady. I have no doubt Taryn will not only cling to her, but she'll end up in the will, and the old couple will have separate and tragic "accidents."
There's a 2020 movie called No Good Deed with the same kind of dummy for a protagonist and similar plot elements, but this one was better and more believable. Would I watch again? Not sure.