Lucy
Peter (as Dondré Whitfield)
Uncle Barney
Mrs. Swinson
Daphne
Celia
Rinda
Maeve (as Jaida Iman Benjamin)
Joe
Lucy (18)
Alice
Carla
Ed (as Paul Roles)
Lucy (K) (as Zoe Calloway)
Alice (K)
Karen
Mr. McHenry
Peter (18) (as Byron R. Johnson II)
Ophelia
Portia
Skate Boy
Mayor (as Kenric Reitz)
Caroler (as Aleq Bey)
Caroler 2
Caroler 3
Caroler 4
Caroler 5
McHenry's Costumer
Mr. Swinson (as Leonard Butler)
Maeve's Dad (as Wendel Matthews)
Maeve's Mom
Christmas Party Attendee (uncredited)
Cafe Patron (uncredited)
Cookie Party Coordinator (uncredited)
Ice Fisherman (uncredited)
Ice Skater (uncredited)
Town Pedestrian (uncredited)
Townsperson (uncredited)