The acting, direction and cinematography in this series is exquisite. Absolutely spot-on.
But the story and the dialogue and the characters... no. Just no.
I found myself wanting to shake the characters all the time. Just talk to each other, for crying out loud. How can two such supposedly brilliant people be so bad at communicating? I get that they're still young, but even so, why were they so awful at having a proper conversation?
The characters' inability to express themselves was infuriating. Connell mumbled his way through life, unable to articulate a single opinion. Marianne wallowed in her endless misery.
Their break-up at the end of their first year at university was particularly aggravating, involving about three inarticulate sentences and then that was it - they were over. What?! You don't just give up after three sentences - you continue talking and have a conversation to clear up the misunderstanding. Arrgggghh. *headdesk*
And these characters were supposed to be highly intelligent and literate?? Based on their conversations, neither of them seemed particularly interesting, so why were they so interested in each other - and for that matter, why should we, the viewers, be interested in them? There was plenty of *telling* that Marianne and Connell were fascinating and brilliant - their scholarships, Marianne's coterie of admiring friends at university, Connell apparently a fantastic editor - but we were *told* this, not shown it.
Crucially, those two never seemed to have any fun together. Why would you want to be with someone who doesn't make you laugh, who doesn't put a smile on your face and a twinkle in your eye?
And then the ending. Ah yes, let's self-sabotage the relationship yet again. Just go to New York with him, for god's sake, Marianne - you're rich enough, you can afford it. Marianne's reason for not going was because she was finally happy with her life. That's because you're with Connell, you eejit!
I'm just too old for this show, because I have zero patience - either in fiction or in real life - for the kind of stupid miscommunication and misunderstandings displayed here. If the characters had just had *one* proper conversation, they could have been together from university onwards and we would have been spared six more episodes that frantically contrived to keep them apart.