Add a Review

  • Nothing new here--same plot that they have recycled hundreds of times. Same 10 square miles of Ontario that looks NOTHING like the Midwestern US.

    As usual the thing that makes it watchable is the acting/chemistry of the main characters. The whole cast is pretty good but the lead actress is particularly strong at the feel-good/romance element. They should put her in as many movies as she can deal with because she can single-handedly rescue the whole thing.
  • This is actually the third Stephen Huszar film I have seen in a row now and I have to say I don't mind that one bit. He is really quite a guy, handsome and funny with a lovely smile and manly to boot. Add to that Steven Weber whom I have always liked as an actor ever since I saw him in Jeffrey and the fact that the story isn't bad either and you've got a winning formula.

    The romance is cute and the family storyline makes it more than just the usual. I like the fact that we get time to see the couple come together and rekindle their past where as some films are rushing it all lately to the point that you're wondering why and how they fell in love after meeting twice?

    It's not one that has a huge difference to its tale or a standout, but it does what it does well.
  • Hallmark's Christmas output is very variable and 2018 was a mixed year for them. Some though are above average level and there are some surprisingly very enjoyable ones amongst the average and less films that there is a good deal of in their output. Along with my love of Christmas and that it was one of the films in my Christmas Hallmark/Lifetime film completest quest, my main reasons for seeing 'Return to Christmas Creek' were because of liking the concept and having liked the cast in other things.

    'Return to Christmas Creek' may not be an exceptional film and has shortcomings. Yet it managed to be to me a quite charming and enjoyable film and in the surprisingly good category of Hallmark's Christmas output. Of a very mixed bunch, 'Return to Christmas Creek' is towards being one of the better Hallmark Christmas films overall and one of the better ones of 2018. A festive cracker it may not quite be, but it's not a humbug either and overall this is a road worth taking.

    It is predictable story-wise with a lot of familiar Hallmark tropes with not much fresh done with it. It does get treacly in spots, a common problem with Hallmark well before 'Return to Christmas Creek' and just as bad and perhaps even worse now.

    Also thought that the first quarter could have been tighter pace wise and that some of the supporting characters were on the caricaturish side.

    On the other hand, 'Return to Christmas Creek' has a lot of plus points. It is very professionally filmed and the locations are simply beautiful. A lot of Hallmark's Christmas films suffer from being over-scored, meaning being too constantly used and too loud. That isn't so big a problem here. The film is a rare case in a Hallmark Christmas film where both lead characters were both likeable and interesting, neither too perfect or with flaws overwritten. Steven Weber's character is also easy to like and is well developed.

    Tori Anderson is an immensely charming lead and has fun with her material. She has a very engaging and at its best sparkling chemistry with easy going and sympathetic Stephen Huszar. Their relationship also develops realistically and is worth investing in. Weber brings a lot of heart to his role and the film. The dialogue can be treacly, but it did generally make me smile and didn't take itself too seriously (while not treating things as too much of a joke either). The story is light-hearted and heart-warming, even if originality pretty much goes out the window. It isn't sluggish and it is not as contrived as other Hallmark Christmas films. The messaging is sweet and didn't find myself being beaten around the head with it.

    Summing up, nice film as long as not too much is expected from it. 7/10.
  • Review Date 7/13/2019

    I have Reviewed OVER 500 "Christmas Films, & Christmas Television Movies , & Television Specials". Please BEWARE Of films and specials with just one review! For instance When "It's a POSITIVE" chances are that the reviewer was involved with the production. "If its Negative" then they may have a grudge against the film for whatever reason. I am fare. I am on a mission to watch every Christmas Movie ever made. Since 2014 I average 100 a year.

    As Christmas approaches, Amelia Hughes, a career-focused Chicago app developer lacking in holiday spirit, returns to her small hometown of Christmas Creek to rediscover the meaning of Christmas. There, she reunites with her childhood best friend Mike and her estranged uncle Harry, whose mysterious rift with Amelia's father divided her family during the holiday season when she was a child.

    This was a nice story and Steven Weber was shockingly very good. I love again that they don't make the career woman a heartless villain. In fact she is the hero of this story!
  • 7/10 - holiday fun with Hallmark and full of familiar tropes
  • After a hot-shot app developer's new idea for a Christmas app is shot down in the boardroom, she seeks inspiration at the inn run by her uncle, who she hasn't seen since her family left under a cloud years before. Some really good performances keep the interest throughout. The delightful Tori Anderson as Amelia oozes charm, portraying fragility when required, and Stephen Weber as Harry (the uncle) is excellently guarded when introduced and has a good character arc. Very enjoyable family drama set around the Christmas season.
  • Kirpianuscus26 January 2020
    Actually, just nice. Not original but the familiarity of every pieces defining it, from family to romance are well used and the result is far to be more than predictable but with a nice effect.
  • kz917-122 July 2019
    Most of this film was cute & enjoyable.

    The female lead's nickname Mels for Amelia. The mentions to airplanes and Amelia Earhart.

    Cute premise, some of the secondary characters were grating.

    But all in all a cute showing.
  • rjspear21 November 2018
    Warning: Spoilers
    Tori Anderson as Amelia Hayes does a wonderful job of carrying this fun holiday movie. Stephen Huszar as Mike does a nice job of being an childhood and maybe love interest of Amelia's. Steven Weber plays Amelia's estranged Uncle Harry who runs the family Lodge in Christmas Creek. The beautiful Kari Matchett does a effortless job playing Pamela who used to be Harry's girlfriend. Lyla Elliott as Mike's niece Scout steals every scene she is in. Return to Christmas Creek does feel familiar but at the same time new. If you are looking for a nice way to spend a under 2 hours on a Christmas movie I think you will enjoy this movie.
  • Jackbv12317 December 2020
    This movie is a combination romance and story of a family working through long time issues. There are a lot of the formula themes for a Christmas romance like one lead goes home to fix an new app that has problems. Two high school flames reunite. Town tree lighting. Ginger bread contest. Service man separated from wife and kid.

    The story doesn't have any real surprises or highs or lows. The tension is normal family issues. The one slightly unusual thing is the "Fly-by Christmas" which involves Amelia (whose heroine is Earhart) getting reacquainted with flying.

    Tori Anderson and Stephen Huszar are comfortable together but their story is diluted by other things. Most of the acting is adequate including supporting cast.
  • Sorry, but here goes on an honest review.

    Very boring. Little story with bland acting. I like Hallmark movies but this one was soooooo boring. It piled a bunch of uncaring people into scene after scene of what was advertised as a Christmas movie. Hallmark needs to step it up in the production department.

    Rating-4 Lumps of coal in Christmas Creek stocking.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    First things first: There are "cliffhanger" kisses (spoiler alert...hopefully the only spoiler)

    Thankfully, it's not all there is to this movie. FEELINGS, nothing more than feelings (I just mean, this is not really a review):

    This movie is about the love for family, and its importance...of letting people in...and maybe, also about the true meaning of Christmas.

    I like the chemistry between Steven Weber and Kari Matchett. There's something so real about the way they look at each other.

    Thankfully I also like the chemistry between the two leads, Tori Anderson and Steven Huszar.

    The little girl, Scout, played by Lyla Elliott, is more than adorable. She may only be a supporting character, but she was able to internalize well. She longed for her father, but she still was able to exude the joy within. Troy Bundle and Janet Porter play her parents. They were believable enough.

    Vanessa Matsui(Carrie, Amelia's Executive Assistant and friend) is a natural, but she wasn't able to display it much here. Still, she made the most out of her role.

    Byron Abalos, Nathan, well, he did what he could with the role given to him. He's good.

    Anyways, instead of doing a roll call and give more spoilers, I think I'll just say that yes, there are predictable stuff, but there are some surprises too.

    Thanks for your time.

    :-)
  • Really good acting. Love it when Hallmark uses "old" actors like Webber. They bring nuance and feeling to the story. Tori is really good. Genuine. A really good Hallmark movie is one where you don't even want to go to the bathroom for fear of missing a few words. This wasn't one of them. Try to change up the Hallmark predictablility of how the movie progresses. We all know how it'll end. Duh. That's why we love Hallmark. Add a few twist, turns and hooks. Thanks Hallmark.
  • Kavita14 December 2018
    The main actors were rather wooden... without much chemistry... the best part was Stephen Weber...

    But it was a passable Xmas story...
  • ambie71922 November 2018
    Obviously with the sheer volume of movies Hallmark puts out at Christmas they can't all be great. This one was ok but nothing particularly special or memorable. Tori Anderson was delightful, hopefully she gets another shot as a Hallmark lead in the future.
  • The best thing about The Return To Christmas Creek is the high wattage appeal of Tori Anderson. She's beautiful, charming, engaging and something of a Taylor Swift lookalike. She plays the always smiling Amelia and sparkles in the role. Steven Weber (from the TV show Wings) is also outstanding as her Uncle Harry, as is Kari Matchett as his estranged girlfriend Pamela.

    Amelia's love interest is her childhood friend Mike Ruggles played by Steven Huszar. Ruggles' niece, Scout, well played by Lyla Elliott, actually looks like her namesake from the movie version of To Kill a Mockingbird.

    The chemistry between Amelia and Ruggles is OK (with yet another infuriating "almost kiss") but their relationship takes a backseat to the drama of the feuding brothers, the lost love between Harry and Pamela, a failed app that Amelia developed, the seaplane, and the Inn.

    Everybody who watches Hallmark movies expects and loves a happy ending. But here, the many conflicts were all too neatly wrapped up and solved in just a few minutes. They even threw in a returning soldier scene. It was a bit much.

    And yet, an overblown and unearned feel good ending still feels good. But where do Ruggles and career woman Amelia end up? Maybe I missed it, but someone will need to move.

    Still, I can forgive a lot with someone like Tori Anderson leading the way.

    Pet Peeve:

    Amelia's job would require her to have the ability to write computer code. But there is absolutely no indication that she has any such skills. A passing reference to her computer science skills would have been nice. There are an increasing number of new romance novels that celebrate women with careers in STEM fields (e.g., Love Hypothesis by Ali Hazelwood) and supermodel Karlie Kloss has promoted coding for girls (through camps called "Koding with Klossy"). But I don't recall seeing such women represented in Hallmark movies. This seemed like a missed opportunity to showcase a female lead in a STEM field.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    Can he ever live down his Wings past? The poor guy can't get away from airplanes.

    Actually this one's not bad. Kari Matchett is just delicious as Weber's love interest. The younger generation is kinda blah though.
  • teebear81711 July 2020
    This one is great if you are a dentist. This actress with her oversized teeth was over smiling in EVER scene. All you see is a flash off piano sized teeth non stop. I was ready to scream half way thru. Zero chemistry with her male counterpart. Same plot, same scenarios, same diologue, same overworked white corporate person who lost the Christmas spirit in every movie. Most of them have some country Inn, or Toy store, or farm, or restaurant or something some evil person wants to shut down and our hero saves the day and of COURSE, Finds true love. The lead actors predictably, have non stop coincidental run ins. The actors dont always have chemistry. They must have one writer who does all these conveyor belt movies. Some are good but often they are yawnfests. This one, i felt zero chemistry between the main pair. Steven Weber was like ive never seen him. Dull and morose. Just felt contrivedand way too much teeth lol
  • I enjoyed this movie and acting. It is Christmas season and yes it is predictable but it is fun!
  • HotToastyRag21 December 2023
    Tori Anderson hasn't been much of a big-family-Christmas person ever since she and her parents moved away from Christmas Creek and had a falling out with her uncle, Steven Weber. Instead, she's risen high in the corporate world and gone on tropical vacations to unsentimental places. Then, one year, everything goes wrong: her pitch gets rejected at work, her boyfriend dumps her, and her family gets a surprise invitation to return home to Christmas Creek. Without telling her parents, she hops on a plane and hopes to mend fences with her uncle.

    When she arrives, Steven is very friendly but a little reserved - and understandably so. They haven't seen each other in fifteen years, and he has bad blood with her parents. Steven also has trouble of his own, as he and his ex-girlfriend, Kari Matchett, obviously still have feelings for each other but are afraid to try again. It's not exactly a wonderful time of year for him, but perhaps as Tori reminds him of the importance of family, she can also get him to believe in love again. She has her own romance with her childhood sweetheart all grown up, Stephen Huszar. Parts of this Hallmark Christmas flick are cute, but it doesn't really have anything to make it stand out among the rest as a yearly holiday favorite. I'll probably watch it again in a few years, though.
  • Another Hallmark Christmas favorite. The cast (Tori Anderson, Stephan Huszar and Steven Weber) did a phenomenal job. The movie focused on finding the meaning of Christmas amongst a lingering family feud between Ameila's father and uncle. Family and forgiveness are the key. The writer, Kirsten Hansen, brings to life a fabulous family Christmas movie.
  • the_mora_family18 November 2018
    I know I love a movie when I find myself smiling most of the time throughout the scenes
  • Compared to all movies: 7.8. Compared to Hallmark movies: 9.5

    I was hooked from minute 3. This is my favorite Christmas movie so far this year, and I don't anticipate many will surpass it. The sets are great, the scenery is pleasant, the people are believable, and everything is polished beyond the norm. I also enjoyed that the majority of this takes place during the day as opposed to the usual nighttime.

    This is by far one of the most dynamic and well-balanced seasonal movies i've seen. I might place this in the "must-see" category, at least re-watch it every few years.

    I suggest you watch the film and waste no more time reading further...

    In case you need more convincing, fine...

    Maybe, just maybe my disproportionate review is because I have a crush on the lead actress. Tori Anderson, is an unknown to me, which says a lot considering I've seen everything (or so I thought). Steven Weber from Wings is one of my favorite comedians from the 90's.

    Let's talk about Tori Anderson for a bit, because I am immediately in love with her style and charisma. She is the real deal and shares some unique qualities seen in any great actress. I'd like to say it's poise, or presence, maybe a bit of both.

    Ok, now to the story. If I had a nickel for every Hallmark movie wherein a person owns a lodge, Inn, hotel, or restaurant, can play the piano, puts on a gingerbread house contest... The plot is ordinary, but delivers better than most. I appreciated the attire - not too formal, or fancy, just normal for the holidays. At the end the plot has some holes, jumps around a bit, and becomes a bit drab for about 10 minutes. I can overlook this because few movies are perfect. I wish they would have modified a few plot lines, maybe tweaked the events a bit, and it would have been more palatable.

    And what's up with Scout? I think Scout is a female, but there is definite gender identity undertones, probably by design.

    The acting showcased in this film is actually the best I've seen in Hallmark thus far. The parents are quite personable and lively, and also convincing as bitter rivals. Near the end was a visceral encounter, old wounds being reopened, and it felt so real. The male lead (Huszar) and his family, including Scout, are engaging and expressive. The slow and steady progression of two romances is a rare treat, and they are both orchestrated flawlessly. Enter Kari Matchett - so very charming and lovely. Huszar's character was so-so at first, and then I found myself yearning to be his best friend. Amazing character development - bravo. Bottom line: not one character was bland.
  • mchthom4 November 2021
    This is a wonderful movie. The two lead actors had great chemistry. Steven Weber still looks good. He is such a good actor. I loved the storyline. I have nothing negative to say.
  • Love this movie, have watched it more than 20 times, Torri is just adorable in this movie and has the most beautiful smile ever and trying to fix the family feud of so many years. Stephan is just so kind and loving, although he is in all of his movies, but is a family for sure family man as you can see he loves his niece and helps his sister out while her husband is deployed. Steven Weber is great in this movie under all his stress with all the family problems and his girlfriend problems and trying to run the Inn all by himself yet still in love with Pamela after all these years. Will watch this over and over as I have it recorded.