Sarah Fier / Deena
'Real' Sarah Fier
Henry / Josh
George Fier
Lizzie / Kate
Elijah Goode / Mayor Will Goode
Isaac / Simon
'The Pastor' Cyrus Miller
Constance / Ziggy Berman
Abigail / Cindy Berman
Hannah Miller / Samantha Fraser
Grace Miller / Mrs. Fraser
Mad Thomas / Tommy Slater
Solomon Goode / Nick Goode
The Widow / Mrs. Lane
Caleb / Peter
Union Townsman 1
Union Townsman 2
Union Townswoman
Beth Kimball / Rachel Thompson
Jakob Berman
The Watchman / Officer Kapinski
Alice
Skull Mask (as Noah Garrett)
'Shame Killer' Isaac Milton
Billy Barker
'The Milkman' Harry Rooker
Ruby Lane
Young Nick Goode
Nightwing Killer
Adult Ziggy / C. Berman
Martin
Officer Kuzio
TV Anchor
Highschool Kid
Queen of Air and Darkness Girl
TV Reporter (uncredited)
Ruby Victim (uncredited)
Kid (uncredited)
Martin B. Franklin (uncredited)
