Misleading Title The horse whisperer has little -almost nothing- to do with that gentle method of horse training known as horse whispering. Redford's character is the Marlboro man after he gives up cigarettes. The female lead is a stereotype of a career woman obsessed with work. We get geographic stereotypes as well, with the New Yorkers being rude, demanding, short-tempered, bossy, and too busy to be nice to people. Redford's character, and the others at the ranch, are decent god-fearing folks, such as you'll only find west of the Mississippi. They possess a wisdom that comes only to those who live in the middle of nowhere, and spend their days talking to horses. The story develops very slowly. The movie is really about relationships - between the lead characters, and between mother and daughter. A chick flick. Not one to horse around with.