Chazelle's big, loud and brassy tribute to old Hollywood Taking it's title from Kenneth Anger's seminal muckraking book (Hollywood Babylon) Writer-Director Damien Chazelle's film certainly takes the legend of Tinseltown excess to heart in it's rousing opening sequence - A debauched bacchanalia party in which stars, starlets and wannabees dance, cavort and engage in just about every sexual variation with freaks, geeks and animals as entertainment. One of the gate-crashers is Nellie LaRoy (Margot Robbie) who, in intentionally cliched fashion, gets "discovered" that night.
Morning breaks and LaRoy must stumble to a film set to get her big break. Also on location is another of the previous night's revelers, major film star Jack Conrad (Brad Pitt), chauffeured by one of the lowly workers at that gathering, Manny Torres (Diego Calva). Whisked to the set, Nellie knocks the socks off the filmmakers - and, Voila! Instant starlet!
This first hour is energetically orchestrated by Chazelle showing all the gusto his talent, cast and millions of dollars can pull off. Unfortunately, once that initial surge winds down, so does his script's imagination. Set during the transition from the silents to talking pictures, Chazelle's movie ends up being a fairly simple and straightforward rise & fall narrative, using the coming of Sound as the main reason for Nellie and Jack's career and personal downfalls. Chazelle tries to weave in a couple of major supporting characters in Sidney Palmer (Jovan Adepo) and Fay Zhu (a very sharp Li Jun Li), but never gives either enough screen time to flesh out their characters. Sidney is a black musician who becomes a featured player in 'race films', while Fay is an Asian starlet who writes inter-titles for silent films - although we only truly see her 'at work' for a couple of minutes. Instead, the focus is on her flamboyant bi-sexuality. Inadvertently, Chazelle turns the character into the same thing that Fay's real life model (Anna May Wong) was in Hollywood: The Exotic. It's symbolic of Chazelle's lack of a strong point of view to his screenplay, which he has said was researched over years and years. The spark seems to have all gone into the physical production - but not it's soul. The Art Direction, Costumes and Justin Hurwitz' score all energetic if not always period accurate.
Stylistically, Chazelle relies almost exclusively on excess with BOOGIE NIGHTS and WOLF OF WALL STREET being clear influences. The emphasis on bodily functions, out-sized gestures and proclamations of how important Hollywood is becomes wearying. There are a few sporadically interesting moments in the overlong last couple of hours, in particular a heart to heart between Jack and a gossip columnist, Elinor St. John (Jean Smart). It's a rare moment when the film slows down and has an actual discussion. Pitt is quite good when the script gives him a chance. Robbie is a ball of energy and carries the movie on her shoulders when it flags, but, her character is constantly short-changed and just ends up disappearing off-camera. Calva is, in some ways, the central role here, and he carries it off well, benefiting from an actual story arc.
The epilogue begins as a nice, if bittersweet, grace note. It takes place in a movie theater - of course (certainly seems to have been a common theme of several auteurs in 2022). Chazelle tries to link his film with those that inspired him, but as it continues on and on and on, he seems to be equating his own work here with not only a specific motion picture classic, but with the full continuum of cinema. Ambition or Vanity?