False premises, false facts The movies have a long tradition of falsifying history in order to present a dramatic story. But the true story of the Battle of the Bulge doesn't need any falsifications to increase its drama. What is worse about this movie is its totally false premise which makes the confrontations between the Americans and Germans simply one between driven Nazis and heroic Americans, with one American in particular saving the day. Another egregious lie attributes the German defeat primarily to their lack of gasoline for their tanks. Therefore, when the Nazi fanatic is killed, the rest of the disconsolate but 'good' Germans just walked back home.
The German attack on the very stretched American lines in the Ardennes in 1945 was a highly calculated effort to split the British and American forces not unlike Hitler's drive, in 1940, between the British and French which led to the Dunkirk evacuation. In 1945, the German plan needed precise coordination and timing with particular units achieving specific goals at specific times. They didn't achieve this because of the actions of innumerable small groups of Americans who held river crossings, road junctions, passes and small hills against overwhelming concentrated forces.
The German plan broke down because just as a unit swept aside a small group of American infantry at one crossing, they were stopped by another. The battlefield was filled with small groups of bodies of American men who had been killed manning these blockades. The German plan broke down because their armies could not coordinate their advances in the face of tenacious and unpredicted resistance by small units.
By the time the skies cleared, and Allied air power could be brought into play, the Germans were stretched all across the Ardennes. In addition, Patton's Third Army was able to wheel around 90 degrees to concentrate its power on the flanks of the large German forces.
Looking at the trailing German retreat in this awful movie, you would not know that the Germans would continue fighting for another four months on a two front war. The Germans failed in the Bulge, not because they ran out of fuel, but because individual Americans held them back at great sacrifice until reinforcing arms could be brought into play. Despite large losses and a surprised and disjointed command, they held on and forced the Germans to move forward at greater than expected cost. The American generalship, once the scope of the attack was understood, responded quickly and correctly.
The large German forces brought into the Ardennes were not led by Nazi fanatics but by highly professional officers. They had surprise, weather, manpower, equipment, concentration and a well-thought out plan to their advantage, and they were defeated by the American officers and men in the field who won at great cost. This movie is an effort to distort history in order to accomodate the political notion that the 'good' Germans were just forced into this battle by Nazi fanatics, and that only the lack of supplies kept them from winning. It's an insulting lie.
For those who want to see a truthful film about the Battle of the Bulge, try "Battleground", which does get the story right.