Absolutely horrible This movie was on HBO today and I foolishly wasted 2 hours watching it. It is quite possibly the most unrealistic Western I have ever seen. I have trouble even calling this movie a Western since it is so ridiculous, but I guess if you have "cowboys" riding horses, it's a Western.
Why Hollywood decided the real story of Jesse James wasn't interesting enough and had to add details is beyond me. Heck, the 1939 classic "Jesse James" dances circles around this film and it was made over 60 years ago.
I could comment on the horrific historical inaccuracies, but I see others have already covered that ground. What disturbs me is that so many people are willing to blow these off and say, "Well, it's a movie, it's supposed to entertain me, so therefore it's okay." Well, no people. If a movie is going to be based on historical events it has a responsibility to portray those events accurately. Sure, some things in movies I can live with, such as changing hitting positions of Shoeless Joe in "Field of Dreams," but to portray Jesse James and his gang as a bunch of fun-loving heroes doing the country a justice is wrong. Yes, some people looked up to the gang since they stood up to the big bad railroad, but this was not a sentiment shared by the majority. In truth, James and his gang were thieves and killers. When a movie blatantly ignores history like this, the problem that arises is that people actually believe this is what happened and don't seek out the
truth.