Not your typical Murder Mystery Jack Nicholson stars as a retired detective who pledges to the
mother of a murdered child that he will catch and punish the killer.
Sean Penn's strength as a director seems to grow with every new
film. Although seemingly a stock thriller, Penn takes the time to
delve into the characters, thereby creating a far more realistic film
where the audience gets to truly know the characters. Also, the
script doesn't follow the typical patterns of the genre. There are
several twists that are quite clever, especially the ending. Finally,
the photography by Chris Menges perfectly captures the Nevada
forests and mountains which brings a peaceful effect to the film,
giving the film an ironic feel.
However, Penn still seems to have problems with editing. His
shots tend to linger upon their subject far longer than need be. As
John Cassavetes is a favorite of his, he tends to emulate the idea
of shooting and shooting and shooting...
The only other problem, though not a damaging one, is the casting
of Jack Nicholson. While his performance is quite good, he fails to
grasp the most essential characteristic of the detective...vulnerability. Nicholson's never been the vulnerable
type...he's got too much wicked charm for that. With a more world
weary actor, the film would have had even more impact than it
does.
Despite it's faults, there's enough good acting, and combined with
an involving plot, The Pledge delivers a thriller with more on it's
mind than your typical serial killer flick.