Fantastic Directing/Acting - wish more Bernstein less Lenny I am a huge fan of Bradley Cooper and loved the film "A star is Born" which was really a pivotal movie in both acting and directing plus the singing was so passionate it gave one chills and deep emotions as a masterpiece love romance.
I was looking forward to watching Maestro and I absolutely loved the directing, cinematography and acting, plus Bradley has mastered sound design- and I especially loved the juxtaposition between the black and white first half of a Pseudo, sober years and semi heterosexual years for lack of better representation , and then switching over to the colorful color 2nd half phase of party mode/promiscuous Lenny mode, which did show a fantastic separation of his two different evolving levels of existence inside the marriage and family life.
However, I'm not really sure why Bradley made this movie as it's very personal introspective film and as moving as the story is about a man's marriage, especially as a closet queen gay man free yet trapped inside a complex marriage - it seemed rather odd that we get little sense of what created any kind of connection to the man's passion for music; and it's definitely not a typical biopic like Rocketman or Bohemian Rhapsody or Star is Born that drove you towards the passion that makes those artists delve into their music. If anything it's quite the total opposite of "A weird marriage is Born" that makes you feel sad of the inner turmoil of Lenny pretending to be someone else yet truly conflicted in his true love of his wife versus his true sexuality and how to make the two flow together and that story feels very unappealing and trite in 2023.
I did not really feel inspired by it, or deeply moved by it, and it felt kind of blase for the most part except the acting is superb yet the story is not inspiring enough to merit such a lengthy movie.
Maybe other people might enjoy it, but I think the majority of people that want to see it is for his musical talent will be disappointed as that's not the main story. .
There's a couple minor parts where he plays conductor which has some passion but it's 5% of the movie. The rest is just this very complex demented marriage that seems rather trite in today's day and age yet maybe for the people in the 1950s it would be sensational but after 1 hour I was hoping it would pivot to a new 3rd act of showing his passion for his music and how it related to his sexuality but instead it quickly stays the course and ends in the cancer phase which is moving yet feels like a sad way to end the film esp showing his hitting on young students create a rather pathetic old queen - which maybe is the whole irony of the film.
Kudos to Bradley for a phenomenal job directing it and making it look superb, and the acting is fantastic but as one person said, I would've preferred to see "more Bernstein and less of Lenny" as I just didn't really care about him as a character / individual
and it did not make me feel like he was that grandiose of a person to merit a movie of this level
maybe more time could've been spent showing what actually made him so unique or his music so passionate that people wanted his attention all the time
instead it was like watching a star musician but you never see what makes them a star on stage and instead you see what a messed up individual he is that had a very complex inner struggle in his marriage and family life to the point of exhausting the whole story on his turmoil or denial - but told in such a masterful manner that it's a shame that it missed its mark for me personally.
Six stars and looking forward to Bradley's next film as he's definitely developing as a filmmaker
so really looking forward to seeing
what is the next story he's going to create/direct.