Who was the bad guy here? I started watching this show and got into it rather quickly before, midway, it started to derail. I re-read the plot and was a bit confused about the characters. I was under the impression that Stephen was supposed to be a gaslighting narcissist who was also uber charming. I mean, it sort of fit. Well, except for the charming part. He actually was more creepy than anything and I really couldn't see anyone getting taken by a guy like this. I know it happens but I just don't think they portrayed his character accurately if that is what they were going for. I also thought Lucy was supposed to be kind of a wide-eyed naive college freshman who falls for his charms. She wasn't wide-eyed nor naive. She also wasn't likeable. At all. Neither was Stephen but, to be fair, I don't believe he was supposed to be. In order to garner sympathy for Lucy, if that's what they were trying to do, likeability would have helped. Somewhere along the way, she becomes obsessed with Stephen. Or at least that's what you are supposed to think. It didn't totally come off that way to me though. Maybe it's because there was no chemistry between the two (their sex scenes were painfully dull) but I never got "obsessed." She really liked him and she fell for his lies but she also had a side guy that she seemed much more happy with. I don't know. Honestly, I'm just not sure who was supposed to be taking advantage of whom since it seemed like they just took advantage of each other and everyone else around them. .
The only interesting part of the show was seeing Stephen at home with his family. You could see where he learned such tactics and the viewer could actually feel sorry for him for a minute. Just for a minute though because he immediately goes back to being a despicable person rather quickly. Lucy's family, on the other hand, was vastly different from his in every way. Weird, because I believe that's one of the things she thought bonded her and Stephen. Their toxic families. I didn't get toxic from hers. I could understand her feelings about the situation with her mom, but the whole thing seemed much more complex than she made it out to be. I'm not condoning what her mother did, but she really should have talked to her about it. Of course, if she did that, she wouldn't be able to play victim and personality wise, that's pretty much all she has.
What I ended up getting out of this show is that Lucy and Stephen are pretty much made for each other. Both are manipulative, selfish, narcissistic, immature and make horrible choices. They're stupid while being intelligent at the same time. On some level, they really should be together because no one else should ever be subjected to being in a relationship with either one of them. I'm not sure if a second season would change my opinion on that or if I'd even bother watching to find out.