Terrible...see the original, but skip this one As a fan of the original 'Wickerman' I was hopeful that this one would be alright, as Neil LaBute stated he was 'so inspired' by the original 1973 version. I stand disappointed. If there was anyway to give this thing zero stars on the above voting slot I would. In short, this remake is terrible.
Well, okay, the scenery is beautiful, and the girls are pretty.
But the script is very incoherent, with the logical connection between the cop's nervous breakdown (with hallucinations) and the events on the island is totally not established, and the mythological background of the island's feminist society can best be described as mostly inaccurate, out of context where at all even close to accurate, and a hash of misused ideas overall. Even the concept of a hive-type society is not used in a proper manner. It's as if Mr. LaBute and his colleagues just slapped together a bunch of stuff that scared them as children.
Nicholas Cage's emotional expressions run the gamut from A to B (to paraphrase an earlier critic). Ellen Burstyn and the other ladies are not allowed to use any of their formidable talents. One can only conclude bad direction is at fault.
Much of what made the earlier movie so wonderful: the old-style folksongs and music (many of which were authentic), the use of surviving pre-Christian English customs and festival-practices, the emphasis on fertility and sexuality (without being crude, another thing that most modern film-makers seem incapable of doing) are all missing.
One can only conclude that Mr. LaBute may have watched the original movie, but he didn't really SEE it.
Save your money & rent or buy the original.