Good movie but expectations were too high on my end I went to see the movie about two weeks ago here in Lévis. I had read a lot about it and I was really looking forward to seeing it. It IS a good movie, but somehow, not transcendent as I was hoping.
The depiction of monastic life is very realistic, with St. Benedict's Rule in application. You see the monks pray, work, mostly in silence as they do in real life. But when it comes to touching the core of faith, love, and even though Lambert Wilson, Michael Lonsdale and all the other actors do an outstanding job, it falls short of what it could have achieved. It does raise good questions about how to live our lives. Roger Ebert said that he would have chosen another path for the monks, had he been their Prior, but if you truly love your neighbor, can you abandon him? The monks' choice, given their faith, is perfectly sensible, and they aren't made out to be saints and martyrs. Conveying that feeling of grace and love is much more difficult though, and I blame this in part on my own expectations, not on the movie itself.
In the end, a good movie. But not transcendent.
As an edit, I must admit, that the movie, just like the monks, does not proselytise, which is probably why I felt a bit let-down in the end. If so, that's probably a good thing, and I realize that depicting harmonious coexistence is more essential than ever in today's world.