Van Helsing was better. "The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen" came out around the time of "Van Helsing", which seemed like they were also wanting to bring back all the classic horror movie characters to the big screen, buuuut . . . in LEG's case, it doesn't work as well as it should.
You are introduced to Alan Quartermain, a man who was once some kind of great agent in the UK, until he turned his back on them after the dead of his son, but his 'retirement' doesn't last as long as he wanted, because an agent, sent by the Queen, goes to Alan, who is lounging in Africa, and tells him about "Fantom", a masked terrorist who wants to take over the world with 'futuristic' weapons, like tanks, for example. Well, Alan joins the hunt for Fantom after an unplanned invitation from Fantom's minions.
Alan is summoned to "M", who announces that he is now part of the League of Extraordinary Gentlemen, who consists of Mina Harker (who has been changed into a vampire by Dracula, therefore going against the original ending in Bram Stoker's novel), Captain Nemo (from "Moby Dick), Rodney Skinner (a thief who accidentally stumbled upon the stuff that made the Invisible Man invisible), and shortly after, Tom Sawyer himself (but how a fence-painting, river-boating boy from Missouri end up with a gun and the U.S. government, I don't know.) After introductions, we are then introduced to two more "gentlemen" who are recommended to join the League: Dr. Jekyll and Dorian Grey. After another uninvited visit from Fantom and his crew, the LEG set off to stop him from taking over the world, though there is a point of betrayal and even a son/father relationship that builds between Alan and Tom Sawyer.
But the LEG is made up of people who resemble horror movie characters, or the low runners from the classic horror movies. When they thought about Mina Harker, I think they thought originally of Dracula, but when Van Helsing took that idea, they decided to alter the ending to Bram Stoker's book to make a character that didn't appease to most Dracula fans, me included. You have Captain Nemo, who is the builder of the first submarine/cruise-liner and the automobile, defiling the history text books. Skinner is an okay character, but he doesn't have much of a role and it's sort of disappointing, especially when the director thought his finishing line for killing someone should be "Night night!" Tom Sawyer is another decent character, but when you notice he fancies Mina, you just roll your eyes because of how stupid the idea is. I also am confused as to how he went from a Missouri troublemaker to some 'secret' agent of the government, oh well.
Dr. Jekyll, who lets Hyde do all the hard work, is actually another disappointment, because they, first off, make a big and bulky Mr. Hyde like in Van Helsing, but they gave him some characteristics of an ape, like his shriek and just his general movements. Also, Hyde is supposed to be the pure EVIL side of Jekyll, so why is he agreeing to save the world? Dr. Jekyll is, of course, the weak and nearly-worthless addition to the League and he won't shut up about being afraid of Mr. Hyde going on a rampage, when it is clear that Hyde is on the good side and doesn't seem that dangerous. Finally, you have Dorian Grey, the immortal with the aging self portrait that, when gazed upon, will reverse the affect, thus killing him, joins the League because he wants to overcome some personal 'demons'.
The acting in the movie is okay, though Dorian doesn't seem like the sly-as-a-wolf guy, more like a Aristocratic jerk, and I also noticed that Mina seems too calm at times and when she tries to act tough, like when she shouts "Save your bullets! These men are mine!", I actually laughed at how desperate the actress was when trying to pull off a scary voice. Skinner is fun and Sean Connery, being the expert actor and all, is probably the best performance, though it appears that the experienced actor is surrounded by newbies at times.
The plot? Okay, but will they stop with whole "love interest" thing that is going on with Tom Sawyer and Dr. Jekyll, who want to get in Mina's pants, because it just a little too out-of-place when it comes to characterizations. I think the reason Sean Connery wanted to be in this movie, because it looks a lot like a 007 movie meeting horror movie classics. You have the masked, fur-coat-with-cane villain who is a genius and wants to take over the world, and you have the experienced agent who wants to stop him. I think he should have stuck to memories of "From Russia with Love".
In terms of special effects, acting, and the script, I'd give the movie a C-, because there is very little special effects (and the effects that are there are pretty lousy), the acting seems a little low-graded when you see how much more-of-an-actor Sean Connery is when compared with the 'newbies', and with the "Mina being the love interest of three gentlemen" and the clique plot twist that I don't want to give away. Van Helsing wasn't that good of a movie, but it looks a little like "Return of the King" to "Alone in the Dark", when compared with "The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen".