Nicole Kidman Deserves an Emmy I'm an old guy, and have always heard that real-world Lucille Ball was a far different person than the crazy redhead on "I Love Lucy." But Nicole Kidman really brought that difference to life.
Usually, fictional depictions of well known people are a huge disappointment. (See "The Eyes of Tammy Faye" for several examples.) But everyone in the cast of "Being the Ricardos" got it exactly right. And none more so than Nicole Kidman. She somehow pulled off an impressive Lucille Ball imitation, right down to the mild 1950's smoker's rasp that later became very sadly noticeable.
But it was more than just her skills as an impressionist. Kidman also completely personified the radical personality change between the fiery, uncompromising, courageous, temperamental, and occasionally irrationally-demanding offstage Lucille Ball, and the wide-eyed slightly goofy onstage character the world fell in love with.
The rest of the cast was perfect. For some reason, there was a lot of pre-production controversy about whether Javier Bardem could pull off Desi Arnaz, but he played the charismatic, philandering, hard-driven role perfectly. Nina Arianda was a surprisingly beautiful Vivian Vance look-alike, frustrated over playing a frumpy housewife married to a man who was old enough to be her father. And J. K. Simmons pulled up his pants, stuck out his stomach, and sold William Frawley as a hard-drinking, flip, sarcastic, but nonetheless caring member of the "I Love Lucy" family.
The plot didn't actually follow the real timeline, but for goodness sake what decent fictional account of a historical event does? From that perspective, I was only disappointed with one scene - the ridiculous phone call that Desi Arnaz puts on a speaker phone in front of the studio audience toward the end of the movie. On top of the fact that this never happened in real life, I couldn't help but wonder why the voice of the actor on the other end of the phone sounded absolutely nothing like the famous person they were supposed to be playing.
But other than that very small flaw, the film was great. I went into "Being the Ricardos" a bit hesitant over the mixed reviews, but ended up being completely captivated. If this entire production doesn't earn multiple awards, Nicole Kidman should at least win for her amazing transformations into both Lucy Ricardo and Lucille Ball.