Maybe for laughs, but fails horribly as a Western Don't remember what I thought of this movie back in 1960. Whatever, it failed to register a positive enough memory to entice me into a second viewing....until this week when I saw the dvd version at our library. A Hollywood rip from the excellent Japanese movie, The Seven Samurai, fails horribly as a copy or as a Western.
The film has a number of actors I've always enjoyed watching. The failure, as I see it, must sit with the script and direction. It is full of Hollywood style, social commentary, that borders on the ridiculous, at least for a Western.
Yul Brynner and Steve McQueen team up early on to help transport a coffin to boot hill. Seems some of the town folk are preventing the burial because they don't want an Indian buried with the whites. Sure, and this Indian was lying dead in the street before some benevolent traveling salesman gave the undertaker $20 for a proper burial. This is a border town where temperatures do get into the hundreds. Bodies aren't left out in the noonday sun, like road kill, regardless of their racial makeup. Our two heroes volunteer to take the hearse up to boot hill. McQueen is given a "scatter gun" and rides shotgun on the hearse. Along the way (two blocks) he shoots someone (we guess) from a distance that a sawed-off shotgun wouldn't have been effective. We don't see who gets shot, but Brynner points out the window, which is open, thus making it suspicious. I could see the open window being suspicious in 1960, with the air-conditioning running, not during the movies period. They arrive at boot hill and the road block dissolves with one bigot being shot in the hand, another in the arm. The movie goes downhill from there.
I do enjoy good Westerns. I didn't enjoy this film at all. Expect it could be rented more for laughs, which wasn't my purpose.