Abandon Logic All Ye Who Enter Here When I got to the end of this six-hour miniseries, my main reaction was "Huh?" So much of this miniseries followed no particular logic whatsoever. When it ended, it left the lingering question of "What was it all about?"
*SPOILER ALERT*
The Overlords show up and all of a sudden warring factions put down their weapons and begin hugging. No methodology for the how or why of this happening is ever given.
Why cure all illnesses plaguing mankind, if they are only going to wipe out the planet within a century or so?
With all of humanity's needs being met through renewable resources and equitable distribution of those resources, mankind suddenly becomes a bunch of dullards. Supposedly only in New Athens is there any attempt at creativity. You would think that, without the worries and stress of everyday existence, mankind would be free to pursue the arts and creativity, but no. People suddenly lose their curiosity and inventiveness for no reason.
Supposedly jobs are few and far between, so who is producing and distributing all of the food, water, energy. etc.?
The whole deal with the children makes no sense. With all of the people's needs being met, there is a baby-boom. The newborn children all develop psychokinetic and telepathic abilities. For what purpose? And there was never any explanation of where the kids were taken to, once they were Raptured up into the Overlords' ships. Why not leave them on Earth, where, eventually, they and their offspring would populate the planet?
What was the trigger for the Overlords to show up at this particular time in mankind's evolution to breed these children, then take them away? Why not 1,000 or 5,000 years before, or 100 or 500 years in the future? Once again, no logical explanation is given.
Lastly, with all of the millennia of human creativity from which to choose, Karellen picks some obscure song to preserve as an example of human creativity?
If this was religious allegory, it was told strictly from a Judeo-Christian point of view, while the majority of mankind has other beliefs. Why would those people react as though the Overlords are the personification of the Devil and the Overlords' planet as the Christian version of Hell? There was a lack of any sense of how these people of differing beliefs would react to the Overlords.
There is so much of this that just made no logical sense, and good SciFi SHOULD make at least some sort of sense, no matter how far-fetched. Even religious allegory should make sense. But, too much was done here for no particular rhyme nor reason.
By the end, I felt that I had wasted six hours in a meaningless pursuit.