Good Premise, Setting and Visuals Ruined by Dumbed Down Story Another "I Robot" clone and almost done right. I immediately was pleased with the setting and special effects; a world destroyed by a nuclear disaster surrounded by well done Asimov-esque robots to help mankind survive. The automatons decided to go rogue though.
Antonio Banderas' accent didn't help though. So I resorted to subtitles. Now I was able to concentrate on the plot, only to be confronted by an armada of plot holes. In addition, the grand finale resembled a script of any B-action movie writer. Although this wasn't a Hollywood movie, it definitely had the signature of it throughout, which includes the executive producers. That turned out not to be a good thing, other than the availability of a somewhat decent budget.
The introduced premise was interesting, supported by the movie's own Two Laws of Robotics. The special effects were done very nicely, as well as the artistic, almost noir-ish atmosphere. All of this goodness produced an expectation of an intelligent pursuit of the storyline. But soon enough my disappointment was triggered: it does not do that at all. Besides the aforementioned plethora of plot holes, the protagonist resembled a petulant child. Ignorant on what happened around him, despite being spoon-fed with reality and direct answers. I assume the movie makers tried to express Jacq Vaucan's contempt of robots (why?), but that wasn't executed well. The bad guys were stereotypes pulled straight from a catalog. The thugs are violent, the boss is heartless. Cliché galore at your disposal.
So here it is, a movie with tons of potential, thoroughly ruined by the same traits which many mediocre movies share. I think it's a must-see movie for a Science Fiction addict like myself, but I wouldn't encourage anyone to pay for it. That will only reward the system which does the same type of damage to any movie time and again. If my fellow SF fan, or anyone else, has the opportunity to see it for free, then I would like to inspire you to watch it. Otherwise I don't think you should bother.
I get it, criteria and tastes differ heavily amongst us mortals.
The acting was fine, the right actors were on the right spot. One is better than the other, but almost none of them bothered me. Antonio Banderas did. He aged notably, for the good though! Going by his looks, he was the right person to be the tired lone experienced investigator, put on Earth to tackle something bigger than all of us. But his acting was mediocre which was somewhat masked by his heavy Spanish accent and the calm demeanor the storyline demanded from him. He spoke softly to compensate for the accent. In turn the audio editors increased the volume of his voice, which awkwardly articulated the consonants. I've seen this technique before with the same effect.
The movie is rated "R". I have no clue why. It's bit of a deep movie, probably not aimed at 10-year olds, but the level of violence was very minimal and its nature wasn't worse than what you see in many mainstream TV-series aimed at the young. No sexual content either, other than some innuendo by a pleasure robot, who didn't look erotic at all. In fact, it looked funny. Some bad language is present, but nothing that needed to be rated "R". Having said this, here's more positive news about the movie: no senseless nudity! I have nothing against nudity and sexual exploits in movies, but the scenes are forced way too often only to sell, without adding anything else. It doesn't happen here. Bravo!
To conclude, this movie I rated five out of ten stars, which is almost a satisfactory six. The massive amounts of plot holes, inconsistent and unintelligent approach of the story and cheap action ending prevents me from rating it any higher. For me, it had everything in place for a seven or an impressive eight stars. That's how dumbed down the movie eventually was. The slow pace and fine scenery masked it somewhat. But it all started to add up, giving me nothing in the end. Antonio Bandera's acting, mumbling and accent was unappealing to me obviously, but I didn't involve it in the final score. Other issues heavily outweighed this.
To move this subject to a somewhat higher level, Good looking Autómata couldn't keep up the promise it made, resulting in a hollow narrative.
Happy New Year!