Embarrassing There are better written, acted and shot preschool children plays (ilkokul müsameresi) than this. Worst "thing" you can ever watch in Netflix and god you know how high that statistic is since Netflix is 90% crap...
So let's dive into a deep analysis after first season.
Script:
Weak script with shallow dialogues. Sentences keeps repeating, not natural, not believable. Well if you first write in another language and translate it back to native original language after, this is what you get...
Acting:
Horrible, terrible, intolerable... you can take their acting diplomas and burn them in the fires of hell but wait, none of them are professionals... Under normal circumstances, the producer should be cancelling the show for good or re shoot it with different script, cast, director, cameraman, costume designer... till to the guy who serves tea in set... (Mehmet Kurtulus excluded).
Cinematography:
Exteriors are fine. Even good. Nice drone job. Interiors are inconsistent. Sometimes the scene has great dramatic lightning that takes your focus from horrible actings and silly dialogues, and sometimes it's like shot with a very first generation camera phone. Full of gren, out of focus... scenes have continuation problems. Most of the skips are not tied up to the previous. The actor runs, and stops at the edge of the camera thinking that She is out of frame. It is full with mistakes like that. Mistakes that not even a fresh cinema student at his first year would make...
Color correction:
This process saves a poorly shot scene, might fix bad lightings, give spirit to the product etc etc. I will just give one example out of millions, the car goes out from the underground car park to outside daylight, you wait 2.7 seconds for camera to regain contrast and focus. They show the audience 2.7 seconds long full white frame... so you know how seriously taken this thing is...
Special effects:
There are 5 or 6 effects in all 2 seasons. You can find people making fun of these effects all over the internet. A 5 year old with a decade old computer can do maybe not better but the same at least.
Sound:
As I can see from the shadows of booms all over the actors faces or on decors, they shot this hideous thing with sound. But it is dubbed in its native language so my guess is they even didn't get that right so they had to use those sounds as pilots for dubbing.
Fighting choreographies:
Well this is the biggest problem in all Turkish shows. Very very bad fighting scenes. But in this thing, it is very well done. Good job.
Art direction:
The few milliseconds long historic scenes are realistic and nice. Costumes are ok. Hakan wears the same patched jacked for 2 full seasons. Era decors are really bad. For example the bowl in first season. It's wood but painted like it's metal and everyone pretends that it's metal. Hilarious.
After watching the second season...
I had high hopes for second season saying to myself that "well they can't do worse than the first season?" Well congratulations guys, you did the almost impossible and surpass yourselves.
I was so ashamed that I took my eyes of the screen many times to not see. In this show there is the protector, loyals, immortals and a last minute oracle. They are all shallow... no origin stories, no details, no believability... the show is over and we have no clue about the what is these protectors, immortals and loyals about and you sadly you are not curious. you can't emphasize with any of the characters. Every death in this thing is a relief. "one less bad acting" you say.