The Tusk Identity Crisis In some ways "Tusk" succeeds as a comedy. I found myself laughing at a lot of the films jokes and there seemed to be a LOT of intentional humor there. The problem was that as the movie progressed the line between what was intentionally funny and what was not got shady.
Don't get me wrong, I firmly believe this movie had it's silver linings. This movie had two AWESOME performances in it from Michael Parks and Johnny Depp.
Parks just seems to pour his heart and soul into his role as the eccentric, psychotic Howard Howe. His stories and monologues are spoken with absolute conviction and believability. He's interesting to boot. Heck, you even believe he would be the type a guy to deform a human being into the form of a walrus.
And Johnny Depp (as he always does when Tim Burton isn't involved) knocks it out of the park with his performance. He is truly funny in my opinion and vanishes into his role as detective Guy Lapointe. The movie's weakness however is it's very premise: a man being surgically transformed into... a walrus.
The movie kind of dropped off the rails for me, and I believe the rest of the theater whenever the big walrus reveal happened. Here it was, the big moment, the reveal the movie has been thrusting with full momentum towards since the first second AND.... laughter from all around me. I mean what else can I say? It looks as ridiculous as it sounds, and it became very distracting because every time I tried getting back into the illusion the walrus would pop back up, the people behind me would start laughing, and I'd be right out of the illusion again.
The movie suffers from an identity crisis. It's marketed as a "more cuddly "Human Centipede"", but at least "Human Centipede" knew what it was. A gross-out horror film. It is not by any means a good film, but it's easy to stay focused and not get distracted. "Tusk" is just as disfigured as it's Justin-Long-Walrus-Monster...Thing. It talks like a comedy, it walks like a comedy, but something about the tone is trying desperately to be a horror film. For this reason, I think the film would have benefited from going full balls-to-the-wall comedy.
As I was saying to my fiancée last night, I am a Kevin Smith whore and I want to support everything the man does. I loved "Red State" and thought the film was a masterpiece. I mean that 100% and could argue for it all day. "Tusk", however, just kind of left me, I'll admit, a little confused about how to feel. I still love Kevin Smith and will continue to support what he puts out, but for now I have to say #WalrusNo.