Better the second time around I wasn't too fond of this show the first time I watched it, but it was better the second time around. Unlike a lot of other viewers I thought the last seasons for the most part made sense.
One thing which is jarring though is the decision to compress time in the later seasons. In the earlier ones it could take several episodes for someone to get from points on opposite sides of the map- In the last season in particular they rush to and fro with lightning speed. I listened to the audio commentaries on the blu-rays, and it was a conscious decision in order to get to the end sooner.
I have to be honest, the whole actual game of thrones aspect, who will rule the North, sit on the Iron Throne etc is the part i liked the least. After a while I couldn't care less who ruled.
Perhaps it's because I'm from a monarchy (albeit a constitutional one) that I lack an American's fascination with royalty. Off with their heads, I say. Every single last one of them. So the never ending discussion about pledging fealty and bending the knee bored me to tears. So much for breaking the wheel.
The battles, the white walkers, the dragons, gratuitous violence and nudity etc is window dressing in my eyes. The real heart and soul of this show is the development of some (some being the operative word) of its characters.
I'm likely not alone to be fascinated by the trajectory of Arya Stark. That is, until it comes to a screeching halt once she reaches Braavos (which I am told mirrors the books where she's stuck still to this day). Her relationship with The Hound is a highlight of the series.
And then, of course, there is the complicated (to say the least) dynamic between the Lannister siblings.
But that's about it. The Stark boys all seem to be one-note idiots being tricked again and again. Both Rob and Jon are so milquetoast they melt into the background. Poor Theon is stuck in a dungeon with a painfully over the top side character (here's looking at you, Ramsay) for half the show. And don't get me started on the dreadful Three-Eyed Raven side quest with Bran which is spinning its wheels endlessly.
The show looks gorgeous considering that it's made on a (albeit generous) TV budget. Until we reach the final episodes where it goes full Tropical Thunder with its cinematography when Fabian Wagner et al are seemingly given free reins.
Suddenly the show turns into a day-for-night underexposed muddled mess of greyish brown nuances, a look which carries over to the House of Dragons spin off. I have listened to the smug comments made by Wagner et al about how the consumers who watch this show know nothing about proper calibration of their televisions and only watch content on the phones and iPads. Well, as it so happens, I have worked as an AV-technician (as well as a lighting technician for film and television) so I have watched both shows on a well-calibrated 65 inch OLED screen in a room with blackout curtains, and it still looks like garbage.
Their next excuse is that streaming compresses the image resulting in a loss of picture quality, and that the image is completely different when you watch it on blu-ray or a 4k disc.
I'm sorry, but how do you think most consumers view your product? Who do you think you're making this product for? Talk about a big middle finger right in our faces. Again, as it so happens, I have watched the Game of Thrones on blu-ray on the same setup, and the change in image quality is miniscule.
It's time for smug hack Wagner to take lessons from real cinematographers who are known for dark cinematography but understand the necessity of contrast, like Gordon Willis or Darius Khondji.