Took a while, but won me over The first few episodes were really hard for me to watch. Too many Klingons and long, slow scenes of Klingon dialogue. I gave up for a while, and months later I tried again and hung in there, first because I had run out of favorites to watch, and then because I like the character of Michael Burnham portrayed by Sonequa Martin-Green.
*** Spoilers ***
Once the initial foundation of a war with Klingons was established, they were able to move into more characters and plot twists that hooked me. For starters, Michael in prison. What a fascinating, dark, edgy twist for a Star Trek semi-vulcan officer who was on track to become a captain! Branded as a traitor for mutiny and blamed for starting the war with Klingons, she is plunged into a strikingly unique role in the saga.
Then there is the ship's distinctiveness. The show is named "Discovery" not because that is the mission, but because that is the name of a very special experimental ship that did not belong to Star Fleet. It was an elaborate R&D vessel with an experimental new propulsion system, until Star Fleet confiscated it for military purposes. The Discovery's crew resents that. The new captain from "Fleet" is nothing like any we've seen before. He is rude and uncomfortably borderline unethical. He does not have the same values we are accustomed to seeing Star Fleet officers have - except in the occasional episode where an Enterprise crew encounters a rogue or alien-influenced captain. He recruits the traitor and exploits her situation and her unique skills.
Since the show is only available via the CBS All Access streaming outlet, they have decided they can drop an F bomb now and then. The first time I heard that it was a shock. I'm not shocked by F bombs, but this is Star Trek! I'm not sure I like them messing with Gene Roddenberry's vibe, but I will give them a pass as long as they don't go berserk with their newfound freedom to drop an occasional naughty words. Don't turn into Veep! I love Veep, don't misunderstand me, but this is Star Trek! Respect the creator's vision.
I absolutely adore the spore drive! That entire concept, with the tardigrade and fungi in the universe and zapping into or through other dimensions - APPLAUSE!!! CHEERS!!! WHISTLES!!! Really cool, exciting, imaginative, innovative ideas! Now, don't tell me somebody else already thought of that, I don't care if it was suggested or written elsewhere, I love what this show did with the idea.
I love that Michael Burnham has extraordinary empathy.
I love that some of the characters are uncomfortably dark because they come from an alternate universe.
I especially love the diversity seen in this cast and in the characters they bring to life so exquisitely.
The show totally hooked me by the end of Season 2 such that I feel great anticipation about Season 3 and confident these writers, actors, and artists of every kind it takes to create a great Star Trek series will deliver years of satisfying relationships, twists and plausible surprises.
Did I forget to mention Spock? No, I would never forget my favorite Vulcan. What a pure delight this version is! I was a little hesitant to like this "Spock has a sister" bit - but now I see, now I see why and how we have never heard Spock speak of Michael Burnham.
I could go into more details about what I love about each character, particular episodes, and the arches, but I have said enough to let the producers and investors know this is a fantastic success and to deliver a big thank you and well done to the cast and crew!