A Better Heroine than in the Sword & the Sorcerer While the sex & violence presented is typical of an exploitation film, Verhoeven manages to use these elements to drive home a meaningful message; moral consciousness, knowledge, and a sense of compassion are what make us civilized.
As the story progresses, two men become engaged in a brutal fight to the death over the beautiful princess Agnes (Jennifer Leigh). Steven (Tom Burlinson), her lawful suitor, is a nobleman and a self-proclaimed intellect. Martin (Rutger Hauer) is the villainous mercenary who has violated and abducted her.
To my satisfaction, Flesh & Blood turns out to be more than a banal story about a hapless young virgin, utterly powerless to control her own destiny, who must be rescued by a prince valiant. In fact, Agnes plays the most pivotal role, because it is up to her to decide which of two men she truly loves. If she is held prisoner, if she is forced against her will in any way, it is because she MUST choose one of the two men as her lover, with the full knowledge that her decision will cost the life of the other. Not surprisingly, Agnes experiences considerable difficulty in making a decision. In fact, she never seems to make up her mind even when the story ends.
This kind of dilemma is quite popular among French existentialists. The hero or heroine has complete freedom to choose, but from a moral perspective neither choice is suitable. Compare Agnes' role in Flesh and Blood with the one of Rick Blaine (Humphrey Bogart) in Casablanca, where Rick must choose to either help himself, the woman he loves, or another man who represents a cause he believes in.
To Jennifer Leigh's credit, it is not easy to find an actress for this key role. On one hand, she must act well enough so we sense her distress. On the other hand, she has to be young, attractive, and photogenic in the nude. She fits the mold well enough to make the story work.
Overall, the production value was good in terms of acting, costumes, settings, lighting, and special effects. What I didn't like about the film, however, is its lack of subtlety. The mercenaries are clearly unmannerly, brutal, and falsely pious; all too clearly in my opinion. In the opening scene, just before our heroes set off to rape, burn and pillage, inexplicably, they have to pause for Holy Communion. And, to contrast this false piety, we have false nobility that comes right out of Charles Dickens. The noble lord Arnolfini (Fernando Hilbeck) offers one gold coin to any man who is brave enough to risk his life to set an explosive. And, he later reneges on his promise to share the spoils with the mercenaries.
In general, I felt most of the characters were too stereotyped, with Agnes being the most obvious exception. After being abducted by the mercenaries, her normal role is to feign affection for their leader, Martin, in order that he protect her. She breaks the mold when she actually does "fall" for him, and at one point she actually saves his life. Hawkwood (Jack Thompson) is another character with a more complex personality. While he is a soldier and therefore kills for a living, he demonstrates a moral consciousness and a sense of compassion not portrayed by the other principal male characters. For example, he saves the life and cares for an innocent nun, whom he mistakenly injures during a battle.
Another obvious flaw to the film is its lack of scientific credibility. Just to give an example, there is a point in the film where some of the characters become infected with the Plague. In one scene, one of the rogue mercenaries drinks a cup of contaminated water and moments later becomes seriously ill. While it is true that a person can be infected by contaminated food, to have the symptoms manifest only moments after ingestion is scientific fallacy. The Plague, like many infectious diseases is spread by bacteria. Once a person is infected, it normally takes several days for the bacteria to grow inside the body and spread to various organs, only then do the symptoms appear. While logical flaws like this are all too common in modern movies, in this case it is especially irritating, because one of the characters, Steven, repeatedly boasts that he is a man of higher understanding. Quite simply, Verhoeven doesn't own up to his claim.
While the movie clearly has its strong points, Jennifer Leigh being one of them, there were too many flaws for me to consider it a great film. I gave it 7/10.