Shipping News/ My life without me - both better They're right! Old material, hackneyed, lame, avantgarde...14 years ago maybe. Good acting, directing, and cast, but the script, the plot, the story is unoriginal and clichéd. Collin Farrel's character is a little inconsistent in his portrayal. Sometimes dim and sometimes normal, a little too goofy sometimes. The movie lost me once he moved into the Village with his childhood friend and Robin Penn. Up to that point it was filled with potential and a strong basis for a decent plot. But once the move to NY happened, everything became predictable and pedantic. It wanted to be Life As A House or My Life Without Me or Shipping News, all of which were better. This is a movie entrenched in mediocrity.