Might be my first ever "1/10" I think I never gave a 1/10 to any show, ever. All have some merits. "You" is a totally different beast. And got to make a major spoiler to make my point. So if you want to try to give this show a shot, stop reading.
Just watched the first season and the begining of season 2 but had to stop. I couldn't stand the main character, "Joe" and the plot twists piling up went too far.
The whole story gravitates around this hideous Joe, a stalker-sociopath, that has nothing that could make him remotely likeable. He is obsessed with finding "the one true love". Pretty soon finds a "victim/target". And you are told that he had an ex girlfriend that misteriously disappeared. He has no particular "moral" pseudo-justification like Dexter (another character I cannot stand, but am not a fan of these types of shows in any way shape or form, so I might be biased).
However, it started in a pormising way. The "internal dialogues", the locations and the first few episodes seemed interesting. The fact that you are dealing with a seriously disturbed character becomes clear pretty fast. But you could still believe there might be some kind of evolution or redemption somewhere along the way. Soon enought the whole thing becomes pretty predictable and then you have the final episode of season 1, which tells a lot about how dumb the writers think the audience is.
During season 1, for a series of events both the main character and his new found love obsession end up going to the same therapist. The show hints that they actually talked estensively of their respective sentimental lives. The only difference in the narrative is that Joe, to "disguise" his identity, claims to be gay in a relationship with another man. However, a few scenes show that the stories the two tell the therapist are simmetrical. And the events of their love life totally match. How could the therapist not have any kind of hint that most likely the main character was lying on the identity of his partner?
The twist of the show unfortunately relies on this flaw in the story. After killing his girl friend, as expected, he manages to frame the therapist (its more nuanced, the girl friend actually helps him, but that is the bottom line). The therapist is a totally unaware moron? Really bad at his job? Horrible defence attorney? Or are we to believe that, being married, the guilt for being unfaithful is enought to wanting to spend the rest of his life in prison for murder? On top of that, no one is surprised by the number of disappearances and murders surrounding the main character?
Maybe I missed something, maybe the show answers these questions later on. I might never know. But that was too much for me. So, besides the oppressing atmosphere, the strong feeling of wanting to beat the living s*** out of Joe, the story unfortunately just falls apart.
1/10 because, besides hating everything about this "Joe" guy and the glorification of sociopaths, I feel the "framing the therapist" part is just far too weak to be believable.