Thoroughly modern misfire Have loved Donizetti's music for a long time and 'Lucia Di Lammermoor' is my personal favourite of his operas, namely for the sextet and the Mad scene. It is though an opera that has been better served on recordings (the Joan Sutherland and Luciano Pavarotti being a notable example) than in live performance or film. The Metropolitan Opera HD Live series has two previous 'Lucia Di Lammermoor' productions, one starring Anna Netrebko and the other Natalie Dessay.
Of the three, this 2022 production is easily the worst. Regardless of whatever misgivings anybody had for Mary Zinnaman's production, and there were staging touches that weren't really to my taste, they may find themselves appreciating that production after seeing this badly misconceived effort. One that is possibly the worst production of the entire Metropolitan Opera HD Live series since Luc Bondy's 2009 'Tosca'. Even with lots to like and even love musically, though even that wasn't entirely smooth sailing, one is far too distracted by the disastrous visuals and staging.
There are three things that are outstanding. The high point is Riccardo Frizza's conducting in what is one of the best conducted 'Lucia Di Lammermoor' productions this reviewer has seen. He is a leading interpreter of Donizetti and the expertise really shows in a hugely energetic yet also extremely richly detailed reading, even succeeding in bringing out little details very rarely heard so prominently. The orchestra play wonderfully under him, with the strings and winds on particularly good form. Also standing out was the harmonica in the Mad scene, very haunting and affecting.
Also thought that the chorus gave some very committed and musical singing throughout, despite being ill served by the staging. Of the principals, the one outstanding one is Artur Rucinski. Who makes for a vocally thrillingly robust yet elegant and dramatically deliciously wicked Enrico, while never coming over as a one dimensional villain. Did think though too that Eric Fenning and Deborah Nansteel were good and Matthew Rose acts and sings with authority, despite some unsteadiness here and there.
Nadine Sierra was a lot more mixed in the title role, loved her middle register and her voice is surprisingly agile for an instrument that may be classed as a little on the heavy side for the role. She sounds wonderful in the Mad scene and vocally only some oddly articulated trills let her down. Dramatically, apart from her haunting account of the Mad scene, she is too one dimensional with most of it revolving around one expression, a blank stare that makes Wednesday Addams' deadpan expressions more animated. Javier Camarena on the whole sounded over parted as Edgardo, he does very well in the duet between him and Rucinski and even better in a musically done and expressive Act 3. Too often though he was too strained and underpowered, with pretty much the whole of Act 1 sounding off, and he never comes to life dramatically in a very stand there and sing with stock gesture type of acting. He and Sierra never blend well together and their chemistry lacks warmth and passion.
Faring worst are the production values and the staging, which are quite frankly a disaster and prove themselves frequently obstacles and distractions for the performers and even more so the viewer. There is far too much use of the video screens, used in every scene and done in a way where the viewer doesn't know where to look which really affected the drama's coherence or being able to get invested in it. Also didn't see the point of them most of the time, with them adding absolutely nothing to the drama and only succeeds in confusing it, and they were ugly to look at, only working in Lucia's Act 1 aria. The costumes are a complete mish-mash and an unappealing mish-mash at that, where telling the time and place was very hard. Especially Edgardo's.
Have also not seen a worse staged production for anything in a long time. Far too much use of the rotating set, which again was predictable and added nothing, with the Mad scene being especially wronged in this aspect. Far too much blocking, especially for the chorus throughout who are never able to show much individuality as a result and at the start of Act 1. Far too much emphasis on gratuitous everything but the kitchen sink stereotypes, some distasteful like with the zombies and everything with the Goya beans. And throughout it's very chaotic and over-cluttered, which meant that investing in the drama and characters was pretty much impossible. Not only is the drama dull and lacking in focus, it is also incoherent where character motivations are unclear, the whole concept jarring with the text and where the question why is present on the viewer's lips.
Overall, very underwhelming. Lots to like musically but wasted by boo-worthy production values and staging. 4/10.