An Overwhelming Work of Art If you're not moved by this film, you might need a heart transplant. Three of the greatest actors of our time (Sean Penn, Benicio del Toro, and Naomi Watts) take an extremely tragic script that could have so easily been turned into overbearing pretentious claptrap, and instead create an ultra-realistic, natural, and utterly heart-wrenching film. A lot has been made of the non-linear presentation, but although it may at first seem confusing and unnecessary (and it may not fit the plot as well as a non-linear masterpiece like Tarantino's Pulp Fiction), it soon becomes apparent that the emotional power of each scene would be overwhelming without timely breaks and setting changes. This and other fine stylistic choices from the director create a consistent mood that is inescapable and soul-shaking. But by far the strongest part of this film is the acting. I simply can't remember a film in which all of the major performances were so believably, stunningly, done. Each of the three stars threaten to steal the show, but I was most taken with Naomi Watts's work. She impressed me greatly in David Lynch's Mullholland Drive (especially the soap opera audition scene), but her performance here is nothing short of spectacular. Her reaction to learning of her family's death at the hospital is the most realistic reaction to life-changing loss I have ever seen in film. Coming early in the film, it was at this point that I realized I was watching a masterpiece. If you are a person who goes to the theater to be influenced and moved by art, as opposed to just having a good time, you MUST see this film. Of course, make sure you're in the right state of mind -- you have to drop your defenses, make yourself vulnerable to the film, let it in and scrape your insides out, and accept its heartbreak as your own.