First of all I would like to say that I watch everything. I work at home so this forces me to have television shows playing while I work. This show came to me because I'm simply running out of things to watch.
This show makes me angry with each episode. I just finished season 1 and although I want to quit, I don't have anything else to watch I can't imagine the second season being worse.
That said here are the positives and negatives of the show....
- Positives The show is watchable. The bad guys are innovative, smart, and very capable even though they are regularly marginalized. I can't give it the lowest rating possible only because I can actually stomach most episodes.
- Negatives The acting is bad (terrible in fact). The only acting that is convincing and acceptable is that of the mad scientist and the bald boss.
The humor is pathetically cliché.
The star agent (Dunham) is unreasonably invincible. This is what angers me the most from the show. Her character is as worse than Dr. House as a boss, kills more people than Vic Mackey, and violates more civil rights than Jack Bauer. What is worse is that she does these things completely without consequence to herself. She's not even knowledgeable about any of these cases yet she commands so much even from superior officers with no repercussions.
The gimp character (Astrid) is completely useless and is part of the show by affirmative action or something because she looks "ethnic". She has no scientific knowledge and no agent uses. She is just there to buy the groceries which is then doubly insulting that she's there for the slave work.
The bad guys are regularly eliminated even though they drive the interesting parts of the show. The double agent whose wife was executed in her own home by agent Dunham and pistol whipped in front of many officers while surrendering was doing amazing things like walking through walls and teleporting people. His character was immediately eliminated and we went back to stories of monsters. What is more important is that the bad guys are much more powerful and intelligent yet they always lose to a team of three whose smartest person has research 20 years old at least which brings me to another problem.
The boss (bald black guy, probably my favorite actor in the show) went from repeatedly relegating the stupidity and emotions of Dunham to giving her any and everything she wants (including many illegal searches, interrogations, etc.) in a span of a few episodes.
The science of these things are much worse than normal and the analogies given are quite pathetic. However if I were critical about this, I couldn't watch the show.
Scientific advancement in this show is so slow that apparently a scientist who has not even touched a microscope in decades has the equipment necessary to solve the current problems.
Finally, the scientist's son is pathetic. His IQ is supposedly 180 according to the first episode. Why then is he relegated to being nothing more than comic relief for the show and a connection to strange criminals.