Wow... As many before have said, this will not appeal to everyone. It won't even appeal to the majority, but it certainly leaves its mark. It's a horror filled thriller that feels very different to others of its genre. It's truly original.(If we ignore the fact that it's a shot-by-shot remake of the original Austrian version.)
An idyllic bourgeois family on an idyllic bourgeois vacation is held hostage and terrorized by two sweet, well-dressed, psychotic youths. It is all a game. It's a game they've played before, a game they're very good at, and a game they always win.
The cast is superb. Watts and Roth are predictably good. Watts plays terrified well and Roth is completely believable as the trapped father, frustrated by his powerlessness.
But Michael Pitt with his relatively short resume, which doesn't show, is truly captivating as Paul. His character is odd and captivating and he knows it! We want to know "why?" we want to know what's going on in his head and he taunts our desires. Along with his trusty, unstable sidekick, Paul, he's almost comically sociopathic. The absolute horror of the whole event and its perpetrators is what draws us in.
It's self-reflexive bits (always reminding us that this is just a film) work well. It breaks the palpable tension with moments of levity, fitting in with the "this is just a game" theme. Addressing the camera, considered avant-garde six decades ago, still manages to feel fresh and surprising. We're pulled into Paul's game, we're in on the joke, and its not all that funny.
What are their motives for abusing the family? Well, what are our motives for wanting to watch a family abused? It's all in the name of entertainment, babeh.
Peter and Paul manage it all with a smile and a wink and some preppy looking outfits. I doubt any one of us makes it through to the other end still feeling that clean.
But, hey, give it a try.