Joey should never have been made Defining myself through the lens of Friends (a favorite pastime of my generation), I'm a Chandler man. A lot of guys in the 18-35 demographic feel the same way: we like to think of ourselves as the funny, witty, awkward, and sweet one in our little tribes.
I don't know anybody who identifies with Joey Tribbiani, the good-looking dope with a bottomless stomach, heart of gold, and Chamberlain-style notched belt. Yeah, we all like pizza, and we're not always that bright, but we just don't get laid that much.
To fall in love with a character, you've got to see at least some of yourself in him, and up to this point, we just haven't been cool enough to love Joey.
With Joey, NBC hoped, once again, to catch lightning in a bottle. In order for "Must See TV" to compete with 2004's Thursday competition (led by Fox's The OC, smelling blood and moving in from Wednesdays), the network needs Joey to follow in Frasier's post-Cheers footsteps.
That's a tall order for anyone, but Joey/LeBlanc didn't even stand out on Friends. Even in the last two seasons, when writers amped up his role by including him in the Ross and Rachel plot line, Joey wasn't a focal point, there was Ross and Rachel, then there was Chandler and Monica, then Phoebe and Mike (Paul Rudd, upon whom I conferred the "Seventh Friend" status that Tom Selleck and Michael Rappaport never achieved).
When the focus shifted back again to the two central couples, Phoebe all but disappeared whenever she wasn't playing Oracle for someone's love life. And Joey remained ancillary, peppering scripts with "How you doin'?"s and gags about his not sharing food.
No one ever truly liked a Joey-Episode, and I could honestly have seen the Series being more successfully, and more enjoyable without him. He near ruined the work the others were doing, becoming Characters we cared about, and willed to succeed across 10 Seasons.
Joey was the least likely Character to spurn his own Series, Monica & Chandler and in the Suburbs with their Babies, Ross & Rachel in the City with theirs, Phoebe in any situation, but not Joey.
Weak points in the show are the supporting Cast; none of whom have any comic timing at all, shamed by the memory of Aniston. Now, it could be because they are young, or maybe because the writers are concentrating on writing jokes for LeBlanc, so they are just not writing funny jokes for the supporting cast at all.
It was a hopeless battle from the inception, Joey isn't a strong enough, or interesting enough Character to Lead his own Show. He was the weakest Character on Friends, and that's been made blatant, despite the money and attention thrown into the mix.
Not nearly enough thought or effort has been put into the Setting, the Family or the Friends. With the Show's Ratings now dropping, it really is only a matter of time before NBC is forced to make the decision to pull a Series it never should have aired. It's a real shame, and I hope it doesn't tarnish the memory of the Series Joey was derived from.