A Masterful Film This may be one of the only times in my life when I say this, but in the case of Master and Commander, the movie is far more engaging than the books. Because I am a nerdy sort, I felt a certain compulsion to at least take a stab at Patrick O'Brian before seeing the film, so I attempted to slog through The Far Side of the World. It was a harrowing experience! Anyway, I went ahead to the movie before I finished the book and was pleasantly surprised to find that such a tedious, though well-written, book translated into an entertaining, watchable film. Russell Crowe and Paul Bettany worked well together again, and the characters of Aubrey and Maturin seemed to fit them like a well-tailored coat. Crowe brought Aubrey to vibrant, intense life, and his performance will not soon be forgotten. I have heard various complaints about Maturin's inaccuracy to the book. Granted, I am not a die-hard O'Brian fan, but from what I have read, I feel that Bettany was true to the spirit of the character, if not to the letter. There is an argument to be made for the fact that certain things on paper may not translate well to film, anyway. In addition, Billy Boyd gets lots of screen time, which only adds to the fun. One of my favorite things about the movie was the authentic portrayal of life on a ship, with its filth, lack of privacy, and genuine camaraderie. I also enjoyed the all-maleness of the story and the fact that the bonds between the characters were strong though not overly emotionalized.
I found this movie to be highly suspenseful and very exciting. I have heard a lot of complaints about it being boring, though. I would simply say that it is not for everyone. The more literary a person is, the more likely he or she will be to enjoy it. I will definitely see Master and Commander again and savor its cinematic beauty, exciting story, and superb acting.
See it. I dare you!