Very good, but not great *SPOILERS* I had a big grin on my face as I heard the John Williams' title music for this Superman movie :) I was hoping they wouldn't forget it; and even the titles are the same - Nice intro! Brandon Routh was very good, in both roles. And his imitations of Chris Reeve's mannerisms from the first two films were spot on. Of course, the visual effects were terrific; the flying looks just great. But why did they use a CG model near the end for a close-up flyby instead of real Brandon?...
Kate Bosworth on the other hand was badly miscast. She is too too young to play Lois. Lois should be in her mid-30s, not looking like the 23 the actress is. Subtract the five years Supes was away looking for the remains of Krypton and what do you have? An 18-year-old Lois.
I don't know why the writers decided on Lex Luthor again (a Smallville tie-in?), but that villain's day was up long ago; another threat would have been better than another wacko scheme by Luthor (his weak introduction at the beginning wasn't good either). Luthor's threat is actually not that interesting, and considering the facts of what he proposes is just dumb, especially when you get to see what "land" he conjures up.
What I enjoyed most in the movie were the quieter moments. One early scene on the Kent farm was amusing, though the flashback seemed arbitrary. Scenes of Superman soaring into the sky through the clouds were exhilarating, and of him gliding through the skies above Metropolis, alone. Some of the scenes between him and the (too young) Lois were nice (even if they had been recycled from the first two movies; good for the fans I guess - and they were).
The movie touched on Christ symbolism a few times a little too closely for my liking, and I could've done without the "will he or won't he" at the end of the film - the outcome is so obvious I felt a bit patronized, and those unnecessary scenes just added to the overlong running time.
The dedication to Christopher and his wife Dana in the credits was very touching.
It's a difficult one. I really wanted to like this movie so much. Parts of it were excellent; Brandon Routh did a great job in a tough role to fill. Bosworth just annoyed me with her miscasting. Lex just seemed like an anachronism. But those visuals and the superhero stuff in the movie had me very entertained (even if the climactic ending with Lex was boring and cheesy).
I hope they make a second movie. A better script and story next time around (isn't it always the same lately?) to match the quality FX.