Blown away by IMDb's elitism once again! Disclaimer on Author: Okay, just because this is such a charged subject and these forums are a grab bag of personalities, here's what I'm like: 28, white male, from Arizona and went to a tiny liberal arts college in LA. I'm a staunch Democrat and the saddest things I can remember happening in my lifetime match up pretty closely with a list of the Bush Administrations "accomplishments." I've never been a fan of our military's recruitment tactics or the blind patriotism that often accompanies a conversation concerning the armed forces. As for movies, I generally prefer high-minded dark comedies or spy thrillers as my genres of choice, and, though it may be cliché, most of my favorites DO fall in the AFI 100 or IMDb 100.
Having bored you with the above, to this WONDERFUL movie. To the complaints about acting: yes, there are maybe two scenes involving two of the not-actors-but-actual-US-Special-Forces-Operatives when they're speaking about their family in private where their lack of learned acting cues is apparent, but I would argue that ANY of the scenes in this movie are 100x more "real" than any such equivalent in the history of Hollywood. Oh also, boo-hoo, you didn't this film stood up to Sophie's Choice? Did you expect it to? How well SHOULD our Navy SEALs be able to fake small talk on camera, anyone? Moving on...
If you're normal and you enjoy action movies on any level whatsoever, you will LOVE this movie. And not just for the action or the plot or the rad shots (all I have to say is river and minigun), but also for the naked realism. The plot (shot from both sides of the conflict and in like 4-5 languages, no idea what movie the "one-sided" lunatics were watching) is excellent because it's anything but slow and yet is literally step-for-step as real a representation of a future terror attempt on U.S. soil as you will ever see at the movie theater. The choices made by the terrorists in this movie are based off of real-life intelligence analyses that identify actual such glaring holes in our borders and intelligence.
Oh, and then there's.... the action. Ever wonder how real a Hollywood commando is? Watch this, find out. See what ACTUALLY goes on in the real world when you read a story about a terrorist killed in another country. Though the briefings for each mission were unrealistically short and brief to a fault, this is easily forgiven for how much detail and thought is put into the action sequences of this movie. It pulls of Hollywood "Wow" with a sort of surreal unbelievability, because you realize what you're seeing HAS HAPPENED.
I watch a thousand movies a week and few ever strike me as this one did. Riveting story, immaculate camera-work, attention to the tiniest of minutiae, and some seriously great acting considering THESE MEN KILL TERRORISTS FOR A LIVING AND ARE NOT PAID TO ACT IMDb (sorry new reader, it's these people, you gotta understand).
This is NOT a recruitment video, despite what some lower-hanging fruits on this thread may say. If, after watching this movie, you're of the opinion that people will WANT to go put their lives on the line as these guys do in the movie, then you really need to stay off your cellphone during the film because see... you missed some parts where it totally sucked to be anyone even related to these guys. Or when they die (which, spoiler, they do, but not all of them of course).
So, to wrap up, this is a well thought out, HIGHLY realistic and detailed take on what a modern mission might look like for a SEAL team on call. All SEALs in the movie are also SEALs in real life. These men are integral to telling the story, and as one would expect, the movie comes from the point of view that the team's actions in the film and in general are noble in cause. THIS is where I believe the low-low IMDb rating and trash talk on these forums comes from.
SOME of those on the far left in our country sometimes find even the faintest scent of patriotism akin to calls for a new American fascist regime. So, I'd say many didn't like this because the producers didn't for example, explain why/how the Chechen terrorist was radicalized and turned against the US only after being wronged himself, or rather how he is a human at his heart and not just some cookie cutter bad guy. But any reasonable person would already know this. Most people bright enough to read this deep into a movie review probably have a sense of the world greater than you're given credit for. It's OK, no matter what all these crazies say, I trust you to watch this movie alone. You won't go sign up for 4 tours in Afghanistan the next day, I PROMISE. In fact, to ANYONE who called this movie "propaganda," I'll pay you $1,000 to find me ONE person who joined the military as a result of seeing this movie. Or hell, who has, before this point CLAIMED to join because of this film. Such utter nonsense, garbage like that is why so many people flee this website, I wish IMDb would just offer a moron filter for my searches.....
Good job, you finished!!!