Joker, the musical Arthur Fleck is in Arkham State Hospital while awaiting trial for the murder of five people, including talk show host Murray Franklin live on TV. He is hardly the animated, wise-cracking Joker we knew before, a shell of his former self. However, things change when he meets a woman at a musical activity. Her life story seems very similar to his and they immediately hit it off. She is Lee Quinzel, aka Harley Quinn.
I enjoyed the first Joker movie. A great blend of action, drama, intrigue and psychological themes. The movie was lifted to another level by the performance of Joaquin Phoenix as Arthur Fleck / The Joker, a performance that won him the Best Actor Oscar in 2020.
Joaquin Phoenix reprises that role here in a film that promises to further progress the Joker story. The addition of Harley Quinn, played by Lady Gaga, makes things even more intriguing.
Well, so much for that. For one, rather than the dark, tight, intense atmosphere of the first film we have a film that aspires more to being a musical than anything else. Any tension and atmosphere is lost pretty quickly once one of the musical numbers starts up, and there's plenty of them. Quite irritating as any momentum is lost due to these unnecessary detours, the main reason I tend to dislike musicals.
You also get the feeling the musical numbers are just there to draw the movie out, making it appear to have more substance than it does. The net result of the musical interludes is an unfocused feel to proceedings.
Despite the setbacks caused by the songs, there are several points in the movie where it appears that the plot will find a direction and go somewhere quite powerful and entertaining. You can see the plot options opening up and think, aha, at last we're getting somewhere, just for your hopes to be dashed by writer-director Todd Phillips taking the least interesting, plot-progressing option.
The end result is a plot that feels like it hasn't progressed at all, despite taking up nearly 2.5 hours of your time.
Can't fault the performances though. Once again, Joaquin Phoenix delivers in spades and Lady Gaga is solid as Harley Quinn. Good supporting cast.
These performances can't make up for the drab script and musical-theme-caused inertia and lack of focus, they simply lift the film from bad to mediocre. Quite a disappointing offering especially considering how good the first film was.